acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Depth-Aware Visual Manipulation Relationship Reasoning with Gated Decoder-Layer Aggregation

Abstract

Object retrieval in cluttered scenes depends on removal order, since an object that appears graspable may still support or constrain its neighbors. Inferring this order from a single observation requires accurate object localization and recovery of a sparse, directed relationship graph over many possible ordered pairs. We propose a depth-aware model for visual manipulation relationship reasoning that jointly detects objects and predicts this graph from aligned RGB-D input. Specifically, DFormerV2-S produces multi-scale RGB-D features, while Deformable DETR generates object queries that are progressively refined across six decoder layers. For each ordered query pair, our relation head constructs a directed representation from every layer and combines the resulting evidence with pair-dependent sigmoid gates. Under the unified end-to-end protocol on the constructed ManipRelaD dataset, the model achieves 31.68% triplet F1 and 13.91% full-scene accuracy, improving upon the strongest compared baselines by 16.34 and 3.21 percentage points, respectively.

Primary area:
applications to robotics, autonomy, planning
Keywords:
robotic grasping, visual manipulation relationship reasoning, gated aggregation, cluttered environments

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 27%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.00 over 3 reviews, above 27% of the others.
Reviewer_WnycOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary
  • This paper presents a method for tackling the order of object removal in cluttered scenes, using several depth-aware models. Their approach detects objects, scene depth, and predicts a graph of object removal order.
Critical strengths
  1. The paper tackles a useful problem of visual manipulation reasoning. In particular, here they focus on inferring the order of removing objects from a cluttered scene.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The approach of chaining several depth models does not seem elegant or unified; it does not seem like it is principled for scaling to more complex scenes where objects are stacked and supported on top of each other in various ways, and the camera angle is arbitrary. In the qualitative examples they provide from the benchmarks, for many object pairs there does not seem like there even requires a particular order to remove from the scene; the objects are resting indepednently on the ground surface. A robot that reaches from the top would be able to grasp objects in many different orders. The proposed approach in this paper is in my view, a heuristic for solving the task in a manner that is not quite how modeling approaches should move going forward, nor how humans do the task. A principled alternative approach -- inspired by how humans might do it -- would likely involve some kind of world model that simulates the effects of candidate actions. For each candidate action, it would simulate the consequence, and from there infer the relationships and proposed object removal. Any such model should have the notion of gravity and support, as well as be able to simulate potential actions and predict what would happen. This is briefly discussed with some results, e.g., in the Probabilistic Structure Integration (Kotar et al., 2025) paper. Further, it would be good to explore this task in more diverse scenes, especially going beyond simulation to real-world or robotics scene, for instance. It is likely that there the constraints are quite different.
Questions for authors

None.

Reviewer_fZrbOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes an RGB-D model for jointly detecting objects and predicting a directed manipulation relationship graph from a single image. It uses a DFormerV2-S backbone and a Deformable DETR detector, then constructs directed object-pair features from each decoder layer and combines them with pair-dependent gates. The authors also introduce ManipRelaD, a simulated dataset whose relationship labels are derived from inter-object contact forces. On this dataset, the method achieves 31.68% triplet F1 and 13.91% full-scene accuracy.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper addresses a relevant problem for robotic manipulation: detecting objects alone does not determine a safe removal order. The model uses aligned RGB-D observations and shares depth-conditioned object-query features between detection and directed relationship prediction. This is a sensible way to incorporate geometric information when reasoning about stacked objects.

  2. ManipRelaD contains 3,036 simulated scenes with 1 to 30 objects and ten RGB-D views per scene. Its relationship labels are derived from inter-object contact forces. The scene-level split avoids placing different views of the same scene in both training and test sets, and the shared end-to-end evaluation shows improved triplet recall and F1 over the reported baselines on this dataset.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The benchmark evaluation is too limited. All reported model results are on ManipRelaD. REGRAD provides RGB-D observations and manipulation relationship graphs, making it a relevant external benchmark for the proposed method. VMRD could provide another test using depth estimated from its RGB images, with the depth estimator and evaluation protocol clearly specified. The paper’s RGB-only variant could also be evaluated on the original VMRD images as a reference result. The paper cites the more recent EF-VMR2N but does not compare with it. In addition, D3G obtains 0.00 detection mAP and 0.00 triplet F1 in Table 1. The paper explains why it predicts no positive relationships at the selected threshold, but does not explain the zero detection mAP. Without further diagnosis, this baseline result is difficult to interpret.

  2. The practical value and robustness of the method remain unverified. The experiments use simulated images only, without evaluation on real RGB-D observations or physical robot grasping. The paper also does not test noisy or missing depth, which is relevant to deployment with real sensors. Although Table 2 includes an RGB-only variant, that ablation changes the backbone as well as removing depth, so it does not show how the proposed model behaves when depth quality degrades. Since the stated goal is to determine a safe removal order, a robot experiment reporting grasping or removal success would provide more direct evidence that the predicted graph improves manipulation. This is particularly relevant because triplet recall is 23.58%, full-scene accuracy is 13.91%, and all evaluated methods reach zero full-scene accuracy from 16 objects onward.

Questions for authors
  1. Please evaluate the RGB-D method on REGRAD. For VMRD, report results using estimated depth and specify the depth estimator and relationship-label mapping. Report the RGB-only variant on the original VMRD images as a reference. Please also compare with EF-VMR2N on a common benchmark, or explain why this comparison is not feasible.

  2. Please explain why D3G obtains zero detection mAP in Table 1, and provide detection examples and a threshold analysis. The current explanation about the relationship threshold does not account for the detection result.

  3. Please evaluate the method on real RGB-D observations and report a physical robot grasping experiment. Keep the grasp generator and controller fixed, then compare the proposed graph, baseline graphs, and a graph-free ordering strategy in grasping or sequence success rates and unsafe removals.

  4. Please test depth noise, missing depth regions, and complete depth dropout. Include a controlled RGB-only comparison that keeps the rest of the model as similar as possible. The current RGB-only ablation changes both input modality and backbone.

Reviewer_4bDHOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

Authors propose a new architecture for manipulation relationship graph detection from RGB-D images. Using DFormerV2-S and Deformable DETR detector with an additional relation head the method builds directed pair features for every ordered query pair and combines them with per-pair sigmoid gates. Authors also propose a new simulated dataset of 3036 scenes, 1-30 objects per scene and contact force derived relationship labels. Proposed method doubles the strict F1 based metric over the baseline (31.7 vs 15.3)

Critical strengths

Proposed architecture is a well-motivated design where detection and relation heads share the same depth-conditioned query states for relationship graph detection. Model and its baselines are evaluated with a strict triplet metric and SceneAcc. Contributes a useful dataset compared to existing ones, with focus on denser scenes (upto 30 objects), including per-frame segmentation masks and 6D poses.

Critical weaknesses

Limited Novelty and confounding baseline fairness: Evaluated baselines use their native RGB inputs and weaker backbones, so the headline gain mixes depth/backbone/relation-head contributions. For example in table 2, the ResNet-50 RGB encoder ablation reports an F1 score of 17.28 which is similar to the other weaker encoder baselines in Table 1. The proposed architecture also borrows ideas from EGTR (all decoder layers for relation features) and query-pair feature gating from D2TriPO-DETR, making the design incremental at best.

Manipulation reasoning requires modelling the constraints of the embodiment tasked with manipulation. For example a physical embodiment may face additional challenges in grasping, pushing objects in dense clutter, which is not modelled while predicting the manipulation relationship graph detection studied in this work.

No statistical robustness is demonstrated as all results come from a single-seeded evaluation.

Questions for authors

How robust is the method to depth noise or missing depth - which is a common issue with deploying in the real world. A small study on some real world collected RGB-D images will be useful to demonstrate this.

Can authors report mean and std over multiple seeds?

What are the runtime and memory costs ie inference time per sample, FLOPs or memory? How does this change with N=200 queries and L=6 decoder layers?

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.