- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper introduces an automated game designer that changes the game based on persona. The paper focused on a few dimensions like control driven or goal driven.
Critical strengths
The paper grounds the automatic game design process with respect to persona.
Critical weaknesses
The paper does not compare key LLM providers like openai and anthropic. I believe the idea to enforce persona into the designer is somewhat flawed. I like the idea to understand traces through these persona, but it is quite limiting. Fundamentally this paper needs greater scale, it mostly compares older models, and also simpler card games. No complex video games, nor board games. I would suggest to the authors to look into scaling the work to get better conclusive.
Questions for authors
Here are my raw notes:
ICLR 59742
I can read the abstract! Wow! Ok we want to understand how different LLM / VLM play games and what is it they do in terms of from established psychometric questionnaires.
Introduction. citations for PXI and CORGIS? I guess Vanden and Denisova. shared experience dimensions sounds cool, but also empty, what does it mean? l049 is repeated from the abstract, I know that. please tell me more about these. why limiting yourself to card games, could have been more general board games as well? or even simpler video games.
method. the math is confusing. The method is hard to parse.