- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
CoMO4D reconstructs dynamic rigid objects from a monocular video using a shared canonical geometry for each tracked object and frame-wise translation, rotation, and scale. The framework combines intra-frame object and semantic-region relations with cross-frame observations of the same object through adaptive gated fusion. The proposed modules are trained while the underlying encoders and decoders remain frozen. The paper also introduces the CARLA-based CoScene4D dataset and evaluates transfer to V2X-Sep, Waymo, and PandaSet.
Critical strengths
- The shared canonical geometry provides a useful object-centric representation of dynamic scenes. Combining spatial context with identity-aligned temporal observations is a reasonable approach to recovering object states under partial visibility and occlusion.
2.Evaluation on three external datasets provides evidence of cross-domain transfer. The pose results and module ablations support the benefits of relational and temporal modeling, and the comparison with frame-wise SAM3D shows a substantial reduction in mesh-generation time.
Critical weaknesses
Unclear source of appearance improvements and insufficient implementation details. Figure 5 suggests that CoMO4D produces better object geometry and appearance than SAM3D. However, the source of this improvement is unclear: the geometry and appearance components are frozen, and training uses only translation, rotation, and scale losses. Although improved conditioning could benefit a frozen decoder, the paper does not explain sufficiently how the proposed modules produce these gains or distinguish them from improvements in object placement. Moreover, the sources, checkpoints, and pretraining of the frozen components, as well as several preprocessing choices, are not specified. These omissions make the method and its appearance improvements difficult to assess and reproduce.
Questions for authors
-
Figure 5 shows improved object appearance over SAM3D. How do the trainable modules affect the frozen geometry and appearance generation components when supervision is limited to object-state losses? Please specify the underlying models and checkpoints, and, if possible, compare appearance with object poses held fixed.
-
Please introduce the SAM3D Forloop protocol in the main text, correct its reference, and provide the missing CUPID citation. Is CUPID also applied independently to each frame and object, or does it use cross-frame information?
-
I could not find an AI Use Statement in the submission. Please add this required section in accordance with the ICLR 2027 author guidelines.