- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes DCD, a diffusion-based counterfactual explanation method for medical image classifiers. It separates an image into a class-associated code and a multiscale identity representation, and generates counterfactuals by interpolating the class code toward an opposite-class donor while preserving the source identity features. The method is evaluated on four medical imaging datasets using AOPC and peak degradation.
Critical strengths
The paper addresses an important problem in medical counterfactual explanations: changing classifier-relevant evidence while preserving patient-specific anatomy. DCD obtains the best reported AOPC on all four evaluated datasets and strong PD performance under the selected benchmark protocol.
Critical weaknesses
-
The central identity-preservation claim is not convincingly validated. Table 4 reports LPIPS and an identity-feature distance only for DCD, without comparison to any baseline. Moreover, the identity distance is computed using the model's own learned identity representation, which is directly optimized to remain stable. Therefore, these results do not establish that DCD preserves identity better than competing counterfactual methods.
-
Important ablations and closely related diffusion baselines are missing. DCD combines class supervision, prototype losses, adversarial class removal, cross-covariance regularization, exchange consistency, structural preservation, cycle reconstruction, and realism constraints.
However, I did not find quantitative ablations showing which components are necessary. In addition, the related-work section discusses recent diffusion-based counterfactual methods such as DiffExplainer, DeCoDEx, diffusion-autoencoder approaches, and semantic-abduction methods, but the quantitative comparison does not include several of these closest diffusion-based competitors. The eleven reported baselines are inherited from the CAE/CAML benchmark rather than representing a comprehensive comparison to recent counterfactual diffusion methods.
Questions for authors
Can the authors compare LPIPS and identity preservation against the counterfactual-generation baselines, using an independent identity/anatomy representation rather than DCD's own identity encoder? Can the authors provide ablations for the disentanglement losses, identity conditioning, cycle loss, and realism loss? How sensitive are the results to donor selection and to the use of only six interpolation points? What fraction of test images actually obtain a successful decision-changing counterfactual along the sampled path? Why are several recent diffusion-based counterfactual methods discussed in Related Work not included in the quantitative comparison?