- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a recurrent DeepONet to learn the mapping from Brownian noise paths to numerical SDE solutions. A GRU/Transformer causally encodes the noise history, a branch network fuses the initial condition, a trunk network processes time queries, and their inner product yields the predicted state. The method is extended to McKean–Vlasov particle systems, coupled vector dynamics, and SPDE field prediction, and uses a Doob h-transform to construct a generative sampling SDE for single-pass sample generation.
Critical strengths
-
This paper formulates a recurrent DeepONet for learning numerical SDE solution paths from Brownian histories and extend it to direct SPDE field prediction.
-
A six-architecture benchmark and repeated comparisons isolate the effects of noise representation, training data, and optimization budget.
-
This paper measures the cost of generating labels, training, and repeated prediction. It also compresses the trained output network and bound the resulting change in predictions on the training grid.
Critical weaknesses
- Section 4.2's "learn SDE from data and generate samples" is essentially a generative modeling task, yet the paper makes no experimental comparison with diffusion models, consistency models, or flow matching. Related work cites these directions, but the experimental baselines are only MLP, CNN, FNO, and randomized signatures, which are operator-learning-domain baselines rather than generative-model baselines familiar to the deep learning community. What is the advantage of this approach over directly training a conditional diffusion model?
- The paper achieves good results on low-dimensional scalar tasks with only 20 training paths. How does the training data requirement scale to higher-dimensional, more complex systems (e.g., 100+ dimensions)? Where is the scalability limit of the method?
- It would be helpful to include an overlay plot of predicted vs. true trajectories in the main text, to help readers outside the SDE field intuitively assess prediction quality.
Questions for authors
1.What is the essential difference between your method and diffusion models? Diffusion models also learn a noise-to-data SDE, and your recurrent DeepONet also learns a noise-to-solution mapping. Why not use a U-Net score network directly? What advantage does the branch-trunk DeepONet design have over standard diffusion architectures?
2.The SPDE field prediction is essentially a spatiotemporal prediction problem. How does your method compare to video prediction approaches? What advantages does your causal encoder + temporal trunk conditioning have over spatiotemporal attention mechanisms?
3.The model makes causal step-by-step predictions. Does the accumulated error diverge as the number of prediction steps grows? How stable is long-horizon prediction?
4.Currently, each SDE requires training a separate model. Can the model generalize across SDE parameters? Can it adapt to new SDE parameters with a small amount of fine-tuning, similar to transfer learning?