1. A central population result is already in prior work, and the "improvement over Tanaka" is measured against the wrong baseline.
Proposition 7's exact second-moment system is already in Tanaka (2026), Appendix A.8–A.9, equations (32)–(33). The only difference is normalization: Tanaka sums disagreement over agents, while this paper averages it. Substituting
UTanaka=R,VTanaka=NV
turns his equation (32) into the paper's first moment equation, and his equation (33), divided by the population size, into the second one, term for term.
The "added value over Tanaka" gate in Table 3 and the RMSE comparison in Figure 11 are both against Tanaka's simplified mean-field model, not his exact equations. So they show an advantage over an approximation, not over what Tanaka actually derived. As written, this overstates the advance over prior work.
Some later results may still be new: the relaxation-rate approximation and its N-scaling (Prop. 9), the consensus theorem for general sample counts and adaptation rates (Thm. 2), the conserved weighted mean (Prop. 8), and the bounds and expansion (Props. 3–4). These should be positioned on their own. But the exact moment closure itself is not a new contribution, and that removes a large part of what the paper presents as its advance.
2. The pieces don't add up to an explanation of the problem the paper sets out to address.
Two separate theories under one notation. The deterministic part assumes explicit numerical pooling and a known common likelihood. The population part assumes evidence-free sampled messages and a fixed convex receiver rule. Writing both as "kernel then update" is fine, but Theorem 1 mostly lists their separate properties. No result uses evidence, sampled communication and predictive quality together. The geometric embedding is not used in either the order-gap results or the population equations, which work in plain simplex coordinates.
The state can lose the information communication is supposed to carry. The paper's own XOR example (Prop. 15) shows that agents can have identical answer distributions while holding complementary information that solves the task once it is shared. A theory built on answer distributions can therefore miss exactly what makes communication useful. The authors acknowledge this and propose a richer history/probe state, but that state is not tested.
The quality results lack an explanation. In E1, pool-then-update wins in all 18 cells, but the independence product is the exact posterior there. So the comparison ranks two approximations of a known optimum, with no condition explaining why one wins. The random-target experiment adds little: any two different predictions can be ranked either way by a suitably chosen target.
The LLM connection is not established. The native transfer gate fails for both models. A theory paper doesn't need benchmark gains, but it does need either a justified abstraction of a real LLM protocol or a substantial result in its narrower setting. The caveats in the paper are appropriate, but they don't supply that missing link.
Thank you for your careful review and constructive comments.
Q1. §§2–3 give global two-sided symmetric-KL bounds, a scale-invariant lower certificate, and quartic-or-zero behavior on the stated linear family; the exact zero set allows dependent posteriors. §4.1's quality ordering is restricted. The normalizer-only upper bound (§3) follows from divergence contraction; priority checking is incomplete.
Q2. No native mechanism is validated: both Qwen2.5-3B/7B transfers failed; population transfer was not run (§7; general response, point 2). We ran no newer model; model age is not an established cause.
Q3. It was not necessary: the revision keeps three propositions, one corollary and one theorem (§§2–4), using direct simplex proofs and separating discrepancy from quality. Unification/population extensions are removed; §5/App. B correct attribution/movement.
Q4. None for native agents. Table 2 compares rules against a joint-law oracle; three product entries are uncomputed and the local baseline is not all-information/token-matched. App. D is a finite synthetic check, not native validation; speed/horizon limits remain (general response, points 3–4). The retained title exceeds our explicit-probability scope.