- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents an approach to extend symbolic regression (SR) with a single learned operator . The search then fits the given dataset while attempting to find short formulas, where counts as a single symbol. Experiments show that this setup allows to recover notable functions such as Bessel’s function.
Critical strengths
It is impressive that the proposed method recovers (or gets close to) the desired hidden function in many scenarios. I believe this is a nontrivial finding.
The paper also discusses to what extent it is actually possible to uniquely discover the hidden function, as opposed to variations of it (Section 4). Some theoretical results in this direction are included.
Critical weaknesses
The experimental setup is quite limited. The first set of experiments presented (Section 3) is essentially a single experiment (repeated many times) with data generated by three fixed laws that involve Bessel’s function; while the results are good, it is still just a single experiment.
This is mitigated by the additional experiments in Section 5 (in synthetic an physical scenarios), but the setup is still far from a large-scale test where the deleted function is sampled from a larger pool, including other “complicated” functions.
Questions for authors
Have you considered expanding the set of experiments substantially? It would be desirable to test the proposed method on a dataset where the hidden function is sampled from a large pool.
3 comments
Thanks for the addition. The new experiments are very helpful and confirm my positive assessment of this paper. I'll maintain my current score.
Thanks for your reply and the helpful review.
Thank you for the positive assessment and the concrete suggestion.
We ran the experiment you propose (general response, item 1). Ten special functions that are not in the library are each hidden in three laws drawn at random from six templates, with 10 searches per function.
Together with J0 and Dawson's integral, the paper now tests twelve functions that the library never had, instead of two. The table is now in the main text (Table 1).