- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents a technique for learning an embedding model for symbolic piano MIDI files, aimed at extracting multi-level compositional information. This primarily works by chunking MIDI files, representing them as a multi-channel 2D tensor, embedding them with a ViT, and training the model using an InfoNCE-style objective where positive pairs derive from the same composition. The authors mean-pool embeddings to produce 'realization', archive, and composition-level embeddings, which they analyze using cosine similarity. The authors find their approach performs competitively at tasks like identity retrieval, and reveal consistent relationships between archive-level embeddings judged by quantities like embedding cosine similarity.
Critical strengths
The authors explore a potentially interesting problem of learning composition-level representations using contrastive learning. Examination of cross-archive inter-piece relationships is an interesting methodology. The proposed approach performs the best in some evaluations when compared to the authors' choice of baselines.
Critical weaknesses
There are several areas which could use improvement.
Clarity:
In many places the document is quite hard to parse. The prose should be improved significantly before publication. A few examples:
title: 'Rediscovering Chopin'. What does this term mean?
l16: 'KDF' is a non-standard acronym used without being defined.
l18: 'Performance-archive geometry'. This term should be more clearly explained.
l30: 'corpus-conditioned discovery instrument for Chopin archives'. What is a discovery instrument? Does the proposed model just model Chopin's works?
l383: 'Realization split-half reliability evaluates reconstruction within held-out KDF'. This is very hard to parse.
l435: 'The KDF atlas therefore does not support a single monotonic account of Chopin’s compositional development'. Also hard to parse.
Methodological novelty:
The use of segment-level contrastive learning techniques to generate embeddings, and the exploration of compositional relationships in MIDI music have precedent [1], which the authors compare to in this work. There is also a long history of work on music fingerprinting, which is presumably applicable to piano performance audio. In light of this, the methodological novelty/contributions may then be framed as primarily (1) archival differences, (2) data sampling differences, i.e., sampling positive pairs from the different realizations/performances of the same composition, and (3) the evaluations of compositional relationships that the authors introduce. The reviewer views this as potentially below the bar for ICLR, and perhaps better suited for a music-oriented publication venue such as ISMIR.
Evaluations:
Given the methodological contributions, the missing experiment is a controlled comparison that isolates the proposed representation, backbone, sampling strategy. This could include, e.g., fine-tuning other contrastively trained MIDI models on the same data, or otherwise following its methodology, to isolate the effects of the data sampling and training procedure that is used (e.g., using positive pairs from same-composition segments). It would then be easier to evaluate the main contributions of the paper.
[1] Bradshaw, L., Fan, H., Spangher, A., Biderman, S., & Colton, S. (2025). Scaling Self-Supervised Representation Learning for Symbolic Piano Performance. https://arxiv.org/abs/2506.23869
Questions for authors
See weaknesses.