acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

The Price of Reliable Rotary Retrieval: Task Geometry, Shared Spectra, and Minimal Adaptation

Abstract

Distinct rotary encodings need not permit reliable retrieval at a reasonable query–key norm. We study this gap in a supplied-address, position-only soft-attention channel, measuring reliability by total off-target mass. Our central result determines the exact price of reusing a representation: relative to an -block spectrum redesigned for each task, a spectrum frozen across all lengths and addresses needs exactly two-dimensional rotation blocks for constant-factor amplitude competitiveness. The obstruction is geometric. Task-specific boundary retrieval can exploit a linear slope, but a frozen spectrum efficient on interior tasks eventually surrounds the target in phase space and cancels that advantage. Stability imposes a separate constraint. For maximum displacement , the maximal critical frequency-error radius is , with feasibility strictly below the threshold. No finite frozen spectrum retains this tolerance order at every length; one length-adaptive frequency restores it while preserving the optimal amplitude order. A finite convex calibration with a dimension-independent approximation factor turns these guarantees into checkable budget certificates. Standard-frequency comparisons and reported checkpoint interventions distinguish representation cost from phase and allocation failures. Together, the results characterize reliable rotary addressing under an explicit resource contract.

Primary area:
learning theory
Keywords:
rotary position embeddings, attention, resource complexity, Diophantine approximation, robust optimization, certified calibration

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 49%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.25 over 4 reviews, above 49% of the others.
Reviewer_ZUqqOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
2
Informativeness
1
Presentation
1
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

The paper studies a synthetic positional retrieval task in which the target token's index is provided. It theoretically analyzes how the choice of RoPE frequencies affects the query–key norm required for reliable retrieval, particularly when the same frequencies must be reused across different sequence lengths and target positions. The authors also investigate robustness to frequency perturbations and provide supporting numerical experiments.

Critical strengths

The paper presents a mathematically precise formulation of positional retrieval and derives theoretical results concerning frequency reuse and robustness. However, given the presentation difficulties described above, I was unable to confidently assess the correctness and significance of these contributions.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Poor presentation. The paper is poorly written, with many concepts/jargons used with little to no proper introduction/descriptions. I find it hard to read/understand. Since I believe the main purpose of publication is to communicate knowledge to each other, a poorly-written paper would has limited contribution to the community.

  2. Practicality of the synthetic task. It's unclear to me what practical value the proposed theoretical results have. I find it hard to imagine a use case where the model is provided with ground truth token index to pay attention to.

Questions for authors
  1. Why must a known address be retrieved through RoPE attention instead of direct indexing?
  2. In what realistic architectures does this constraint arise?
  3. Do the resulting mathematical guarantees provide useful insights for ordinary Transformers?
2 comments

Thank you for your responses. While my core concerns regarding the practical utility and real-world transfer gap remain, I appreciate the author's clarification. The paper still requires significant effort to follow. I will thus keep my score for now.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer ZUqq

Thank you for your follow-up and constructive feedback. We understand your remaining concerns regarding practical utility, real-world transfer, and presentation clarity.

We would like to emphasize that the primary goal of this work is to establish a theoretical understanding of reliable positional retrieval under RoPE, rather than to propose an immediately deployable long-context solution. Specifically, we characterize the cost of sharing a fixed positional representation across different sequence lengths and target positions, prove that exactly one additional rotation block is necessary and sufficient for constant-factor competitiveness with task-specific designs, and establish the critical frequency-error tolerance of 1/(2L)1/(2L). We further show that adapting a single frequency can restore optimal-order robustness and develop convex calibration methods to quantify the associated retrieval costs. Our finite experiments provide additional evidence supporting these theoretical findings.

Our theoretical findings are directly relevant to RoPE-based language models and may inform the design of more reliable positional representations. However, extending these guarantees to full-scale language models requires additional empirical validation, which we are currently completing this experiment and commit to including the results in a future version. However, we would like to reiterate that our core contributions are primarily: we characterize the cost of sharing RoPE spectra across different sequence lengths and target positions for reliable retrieval, establish the necessity of an additional rotation block and the robustness benefits of single-frequency adaptation, and develop a convex calibration framework to quantify the associated retrieval costs.

We appreciate your time and thoughtful evaluation. We sincerely hope for your support.

Reviewer_chhuOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper studies how large the query and key norms need to be for RoPE attention to select a given position reliably. The authors studied the case where attention depends only on position, the target is given and all keys use the same vector before rotation. The authors compare choosing frequencies for each task with fixing them once for all sequence lengths and target positions. The paper's main result: a suitably chosen fixed set needs exactly one extra rotation block to match the task-specific cost up to a constant factor. They also show how adapting one frequency to the sequence length improves tolerance to frequency errors. They also provide numerical certificates and experiments with trained queries.

Critical strengths

The main result explains a specific limitation of reusing RoPE frequencies. Choosing frequencies for a task can make boundary retrieval cheaper. The paper shows exactly what is needed to recover that cost with fixed frequencies. The matching upper and lower bounds are the contribution here. The proofs use known tools,but I did not find the same full result in the related works.

The stability result is also useful. It identifies when frequency errors make retrieval impossible, regardless of the norms. It shows that one frequency adapted to length restores tolerance of order 1/L1/L without worsening the stated cost order. The finite certificates give additional support for the numerical claims and passed the reproduction checks.

Critical weaknesses

The assumptions limit what the results say about ordinary attention. The target address is given, the unrotated key is shared and numerical precision can grow. Table 1 also leaves open why the algebraic frequencies perform better. The comparison is fair, but it does not isolate bad approximability from simpler differences in frequency scale and spread. Standard RoPE's equal-allocation leakage is dominated by adjacent positions. Random frequencies and a smaller RoPE base would be useful controls. The training evidence is incomplete - tables 2–3 have no accompanying checkpoints, per-seed records, or runnable training code. Appendix F.5 acknowledges this. Appendix G.2 also omits the formula for the discrepancy reported in Table 7. This makes it difficult to assess those experiments beyond the reported aggregates

Questions for authors
  1. Could you provide the per-seed coefficients, key energies, frequencies and intervention script for Table 2? Also include the training code and records for Table 3.
  2. What is the exact definition of the Table 7 discrepancy? What is normalized, over which entries is the maximum taken and how are near-zero denominators handled?
  3. How do your bounds compare with https://arxiv.org/html/2607.16072? A comparison of the norm–length dependence and off-target attention? Whether the frequencies can be reused across tasks would help clarify the contribution.
  4. Is there evidence that bad approximability explains the Table 1 advantage? Uniform random frequencies in [0,0.5)[0,0.5) cycles and standard RoPE with a smaller base would be useful additional controls, with the same key and allocation constraints. This is a suggestion for interpreting the experiment
Reviewer_EQZjOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
3
Presentation
2
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies the resource cost for reliable retrieval with Rotary Position Embedding (RoPE), within a supplied‑address, position‑only soft‑attention channel. It formalizes the complementary research question: what exact price must we pay to reuse one single representation. The authors measure retrieval reliability using total off‑target mass / leakage. They prove that for a spectrum frozen before length, address and reliability are known, to achieve constant‑factor amplitude competitiveness against the benchmark of an m‑block spectrum redesigned per‑task, exactly m+1 two‑dimensional rotation blocks are required (Theorem 1). The root obstruction comes from geometric effects. Boundary tasks can leverage a one‑sided linear slope for better resource order. For a frozen spectrum optimized for all interior tasks, its orbit points surround the target in phase space and cancel this order‑of‑magnitude advantage. The paper further analyzes stability under frequency errors. For maximum displacement L, the critical radius of the coherent error box is exactly 1/(2L)1/(2L). No finite frozen spectrum can preserve this tolerance at every length. A single length‑adaptive “clock” frequency restores the 1/L1/L tolerance while keeping the optimal amplitude order (Theorem 3). Finally, the authors convert these asymptotic guarantees into verifiable finite‑resource budget certificates via convex calibration. They use standard‑frequency comparisons and checkpoint‑intervention experiments to separate representation cost from phase‑allocation failures. Experiments run on synthetic position‑only retrieval tasks (n=4096n=4096, k=8k=8), with interval‑integer verification code provided.

Critical strengths

Strength 1: Clean, non‑trivial problem formulation and results. This work formulates the exact resource price for representation reuse as a resource‑theoretic problem. It yields precise, falsifiable characterizations: exactly m+1 two‑dimensional rotation blocks and critical error radius 1/(2L)1/(2L). Shifting focus from mere maximum logit score to suppressing total off‑target mass is a substantial, reusable theoretical contribution for positional encoding retrieval analysis. Strength 2: Insightful mechanistic explanation plus verifiable proof pipelines. The authors attribute retrieval failure to this geometric mechanism: a frozen spectrum surrounds targets in phase space, cancels first‑order slope advantages and leaves only curvature‑driven costs. Full arguments are built via convex combination cancellation, badly‑approximable property and group‑code orbit analysis. Moreover, convex calibration translates asymptotic bounds into checkable finite budgets. Checkpoint‑intervention experiments separate representation cost versus phase‑allocation failure. These methodologies are valuable for follow‑up research.

Critical weaknesses

Weakness 1: Practical meaning of conclusions is limited by huge constants and strict assumptions. Core results only guarantee constant‑factor competitiveness under large constants and idealized setups including the badly‑approximable condition and one length‑adaptive clock. Standard RoPE frequencies are not assumed to satisfy these prerequisites. Therefore the theory offers few actionable guidelines for existing models or existing frequency tables. The theoretical “+1 block” minimality may get washed out by large constants under practical model scales. Real‑world impact is limited. Weakness 2: Weak validation and limited transferability. All experiments run only on synthetic position‑only retrieval tasks (n=4096n=4096, k=8k=8, small dhead=16d_{head}=16). Main reported outputs are aggregated numerical numbers and interval certificates. There are zero empirical tests on content‑dependent attention, multi‑head, multi‑layer or real‑model retrieval. The authors themselves state results cannot directly imply language‑model performance. Empirical support and applicable scope for the “reliable‑retrieval resource‑cost” claim are insufficient, which weakens its persuasiveness as general conclusions. Weakness 3: Heavy AI‑generation artifacts with poor coherent independent reasoning narrative. From the AI‑use statement, large‑language models deeply participated in problem formulation, proof derivation, experiment design and full‑manuscript drafting. The manuscript shows typical AI‑writing patterns: dense stacked mathematical formalisms, rough concept transitions between chapters, and excessive stacking of theorems and lemmas.

Questions for authors
  1. Regarding constants: Can you give quantitative gain intervals for “m+1 blocks versus m blocks” under realistic fixed values of m,k,Lm, k, L? Does Cm=220(m+1)2C_m=2^{20}(m+1)^2 imply this theoretical gain falls below any non asymptotic threshold for most practical model sizes?
  2. Regarding badly approximable property: Do standard RoPE frequency tables satisfy the badly approximable property as defined in your paper? If not, under what explicit conditions does the necessity part of Theorem 1 hold? Can you provide a finite length bound uniform across all spectra?
  3. Deployment implications for the clock: The length adaptive clock frequency requires dynamic frequency adjustment at inference time. How can this construction be compatible with static pre trained models? Is this clock construction only an analytical tool or a practically implementable design?
  4. Boundary for block appending: The paper states “naively appending one block to an existing table does not guarantee success”. Does the minimality of m+1 rely on joint redesign of the full spectrum? How will conclusions change under the setting where we only append or interpolate one block after training completes?
  5. Real‑model transfer gap: All empirical evaluations are conducted within the synthetic supplied‑address position‑only channel, without tests on full Transformer / real language‑model setups.
Reviewer_w7nVOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
3
Informativeness
3
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies the query–key norm required for reliable positional retrieval when the target address is supplied. It establishes the exact additional rotation block needed for a fixed spectrum to remain competitive with task-specific designs, and shows how one length-adaptive frequency restores robustness to frequency errors. Convex calibration connects these results to finite resource budgets. I recommend weak acceptance for the sharp theoretical characterization and geometric explanation, while treating the reported training results as supplementary evidence pending verification.

Critical strengths
  1. The main reuse theorem gives matching necessity and sufficiency results. The distinction between boundary and interior retrieval is particularly insightful: it explains why task-specific designs can exploit a directional advantage that a reusable spectrum eventually loses. This provides a concrete explanation for the cost of sharing a representation.

  2. The resource accounting is careful. The paper distinguishes coefficient amplitude from actual query–key cost, fixes key allocation in the relevant comparisons, and separates frequency uncertainty from arithmetic error. The convex formulations and certificate constructions make the finite comparisons more meaningful than comparisons based only on score ordering.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The checkpoint evidence is not independently auditable. Appendix F.5 states that the original reports, checkpoints, per-seed records, and training executors are unavailable; Tables 2–3 retain only transcribed aggregates. This limits confidence in the claimed phase and allocation repairs. The disclosure is helpful, but the authors should release or regenerate these artifacts before presenting the interventions as validated empirical support.

  2. The practical size of the reuse cost remains unclear. The central theorem covers all lengths, with loose dimension-dependent constants and a failure length that depends on the frozen spectrum. Table 1 compares several schedules at the same block count, but does not directly measure the competitive ratio against the task-specific benchmark. Small-dimensional finite-length comparisons would help show when the extra-block result matters in practice.

Questions for authors
  1. Can the original and aligned checkpoints, per-seed address manifests, and intervention code be provided or regenerated to verify Tables 2–3?

  2. For small block counts where the task-specific optimum can be computed or tightly bounded, how large is the frozen construction’s competitive ratio across finite lengths and target positions?

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.