acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Certifying the Information Value of Adaptive Tool Use

Abstract

An early network alarm can guide a tool-using agent’s next query. Yet when an interactive agent outperforms one that chooses all queries in advance, the gain may reflect better information, easier sequential processing, or additional inference compute. We define adaptive information value as the improvement in optimal expected task utility from choosing queries based on previous responses rather than fixing them in advance, under the same task and query budget. We derive a sound finite-budget certificate that upper-bounds optimal adaptive performance without enumerating adaptive policies. The certificate combines pairwise response-channel overlap with utility-sensitive fractional matching and supports arbitrary finite priors and utilities, heterogeneous query costs, multivalued responses, and memoryless noise. Controlled network-diagnosis experiments show that changing only the tool interface can create or eliminate adaptive information value. Across 63 selected topology lineages and three language-model families, externally optimized adaptive evidence improves prediction accuracy by 5.84 percentage points on the positive-gap interface, with a 4.37-point larger gain than on a matched zero-gap control; both effects remain significant after Holm correction. However, when the models select their own queries, adaptive querying underperforms pre-committed querying in our tests, distinguishing the ability to use adaptive evidence from the ability to select it. Our framework provides a benchmark-level audit of whether feedback creates an information advantage before attributing multi-turn gains to adaptive acquisition.

Primary area:
learning theory
Keywords:
tool-using agents, adaptive information acquisition, agent benchmarks, benchmark auditing, value of information, Bayesian decision theory, adaptive query policies, finite-hypothesis testing

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 49%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.33 over 3 reviews, above 51% of the others.
Reviewer_DXc3OpenReview ↗
Rating
3(+1)
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies whether adaptive tool use provides an information advantage over choosing queries in advance. The authors define this advantage through Bayes-optimal task utility and derive a finite-budget upper bound using pairwise response overlap and fractional matching. Moreover, controlled network-diagnosis experiments show that changing the tool interface can create or remove this advantage. The model experiments further distinguish between using adaptively selected evidence and discovering effective adaptive query policies.

Critical strengths
  1. The distinction between information value and bounded-model performance is valuable. Equation 2 explains why an observed adaptive gain does not establish better information acquisition, giving a concrete basis for evaluating claims about tool-using agents.

  2. The experiments isolate the effect of the tool interface while holding the underlying task fixed. The matched evidence format, presentation control, and model-selected querying comparison strengthen the finding that using better evidence and selecting it are separate capabilities.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The practical contribution of the main certificate remains limited in the provided experiments. In Section 4, all 15 certified zero-gap cases already have a pre-committed solution achieving perfect-information utility. The noisy sensitivity study tightens the bound but leaves every verdict inconclusive, while the headline results rely on exact search. These limitations are acknowledged, but stronger evidence is needed that the proposed certificate enables useful audits beyond simpler bounds or tractable exact computation.

  2. Applicability to existing agent benchmarks remains uncertain. The main empirical evidence concerns small-budget diagnosis tasks, and the model study selects topologies for the desired interface contrast and supplies externally optimised queries. This supports the stated mechanism, but does not yet establish how useful the audit is when the latent hypotheses and response channels are difficult to specify.

Questions for authors
  1. Can you identify a non-saturation setting where the affinity certificate gives a meaningfully small upper bound on adaptive information value and exact search is impractical? A comparison of bound tightness and runtime can be helpful for establishing its practical contribution.
  2. Section 7 describes the oracle gap as a maximum effect for power planning. However, Eq. 2 allows the observed model contrast to exceed this gap when the optimisation shortfalls differ. What additional assumptions justify this recommendation?
Reviewer_r9NgOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper asks whether an agent benefits from choosing its next tool call based on earlier tool responses, rather than deciding on all calls in advance. It distinguishes an information advantage from gains caused by different presentation formats or additional inference compute. The authors define the information advantage as the difference between optimal adaptive and pre-committed expected utility. They derive an upper bound on the adaptive optimum using pairwise response-channel overlap and fractional matching, and use exact search or other bounds when needed. Experiments on network fault-identification tasks compare different tool interfaces and assess whether LLMs can use evidence selected by an optimal adaptive policy.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper addresses an important ambiguity in agent evaluation. A higher score from multi-turn interaction does not by itself establish that feedback-conditioned information acquisition is responsible. The distinction among information, presentation, optimization, and compute effects is useful for interpreting agent benchmarks and designing more controlled comparisons.

  2. The paper provides a precise theoretical formulation and a sound general bound under its stated assumptions. The finite-budget result covers finite nonuniform priors, task utilities, heterogeneous query costs, multivalued responses, repeated queries, and conditionally independent noise. The authors also explain why the bound can be inconclusive and supplement it with exact search and deterministic cardinality bounds.

  3. The experimental design includes several unusually careful controls. The authors compare different tool interfaces while keeping the underlying diagnosis problem fixed, use paired evaluation across selected topology lineages, match final-answer presentation, report token-use differences, and test autonomous query selection separately from the ability to interpret externally optimized evidence. They also disclose negative results, protocol deviations, and implementation corrections

Critical weaknesses
  1. The approach assumes information that is rarely known for real agent environments. Computing the proposed quantity requires an explicit finite hidden-state space, prior, terminal utility, query costs, and a complete conditional response distribution for every tool and hypothesis. Real agent tools often involve unknown system states, partial and changing observations, dependent failures, or nondeterministic behavior that is difficult to model. The paper does not demonstrate a practical process for constructing or validating these benchmark specifications from real-world agent interactions.

  2. The network-diagnosis tasks substantially simplify real troubleshooting. The primary experiments assume exactly one failed bridge or link, a known graph, uniform priors, exact-identification utility, and only two or three tool calls. Operational network faults can be concurrent, intermittent, causally interacting, and only partially observable, with remediation rather than fault-label prediction as the ultimate goal.

  3. The paper does not demonstrate that LLM agents can exploit the proposed adaptive opportunity on their own. The principal positive model result uses transcripts selected by an external exact optimizer and asks models to interpret the resulting evidence. When the tested models choose their own queries, adaptive querying underperforms pre-committed querying by 3.24 percentage points.

Questions for authors
  1. How would an evaluator obtain the latent-state space, prior, and response channel of an existing tool-using benchmark without access to a complete simulator or known ground-truth model? How sensitive are the certificates to misspecification of these quantities?

  2. Can the method handle multi-fault network diagnosis, correlated tool errors, stateful tools, or history-dependent responses?

  3. What is the practical significance of the main LLM result when the query policy is supplied by an exact optimizer, given that autonomous adaptive selection performed worse than pre-committed querying?

  4. Could the authors also evaluate a representative unmodified agent benchmark? (e.g., using its original task distribution, tools, budget, and success metric, and report the fraction of instances for which the certificate yields a conclusive verdict)

Reviewer_4F6iOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper defines adaptive information value, G_info, as the gap between the Bayes-optimal adaptive policy and the Bayes-optimal pre-committed policy under the same task and query budget.

Critical strengths

Separating information, presentation, and compute as sources of multi-turn gain is a clean decomposition, and Eq. 2 is a useful reminder. Appendix K’s demonstration that equal per-call budgets can manufacture a +0.43 spurious advantage is practically valuable for evaluators. The execution is careful: preregistration, Holm correction, and a correction ledger.

Critical weaknesses
  • The claim being audited is one nobody makes. The paper targets the inference “interactive agent beats pre-committed baseline → information gain.” But τ-bench, ToolSandbox, and similar benchmarks have no pre-committed baseline and don’t claim information gain; they report task success. Adaptive-vs-fixed design is a classic contrast in experimental design, not standard practice in LLM agent evaluation. The paper refutes a claim the community has not clearly made.
  • The framework applies exactly where it is least needed. G_info requires a finite latent state, explicit prior and utility, and a memoryless channel. For such problems the Bayes-optimal policy can be computed directly; no LLM is needed. LLM agents matter precisely when the latent space cannot be enumerated, and the authors concede they cannot natively audit any of the benchmarks that motivate the paper. All three “source-faithful audits” use author-defined priors and utilities. Step 1 of the proposed protocol requires declaring a finite hypothesis space, which real benchmarks cannot do.
  • The main conclusions are either obvious or not about agents. “A tool that returns the full structure in one call removes the need to adapt” can be read off the interface, and Appendix D acknowledges Proposition 6 is a 1973 combinatorial-search result. The confirmatory experiment hands models externally optimal adaptive transcripts (ceiling 0.543) versus pre-committed ones (ceiling 0.384); more informative input yields higher accuracy, which says nothing about adaptive tool use. The one informative result—models cannot discover adaptive policies themselves (−3.24)—is negative, in Appendix L, with 200 episodes.
  • The certificate rarely delivers a verdict in practice. Theorem 3 is not used for any headline result (p. 6 states the controlled experiments use exact search). On 72 real-topology cells it certifies 15 zeros, all trivial saturation cells where pre-committed querying already reaches perfect-information utility; on the 24 nonuniform-prior/asymmetric-utility cells—the setting the certificate is supposed to distinguish it from classical bounds—it resolves none. The theoretical contribution is an upper bound that almost always returns “inconclusive” on non-trivial instances.
  • What an evaluator can act on reduces to one item: match total token budget for the pre-committed baseline. That does not require this framework and is already in Kapoor et al.

Honestly, I did not check the correctness of proofs and equations. I assumed they are correct. But the above questions should be answered beforehand.

Questions for authors

please see above

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.