- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes MoDA, a flow matching framework for joint antibody CDR sequence and structure design. It combines multi-scale constraints, cooperation-aware residue role modeling, and modality-adaptive interactions among sequence, position, and orientation. Experiments on RAbD report improved structural accuracy and predicted binding-energy success rates, with ablations supporting the proposed components.
Critical strengths
1.The paper is clearly motivated by heterogeneity across structural scales, residue roles, and sequence–geometry modalities. The framework addresses these aspects through well-integrated modules, with multi-scale constraints informing residue roles that guide message passing and modality-specific updates.
2.MoDA achieves strong overall structural performance on RAbD, reducing CDR RMSD from 1.8139 to 1.5780 and improving CDR-specific structural metrics.
3.The module-level and operation-level ablations, together with analyses of constraint representations, residue roles, and modality interactions, provide useful insight into the model’s behavior.
Critical weaknesses
1.Several definitions and operations require clarification, including the functional form of and its relation to flow time, the construction of in Eq. (4), and the normalization operation in Section 3.4. It is also unclear how missing unit-specific features are handled when constructing for framework or antigen residues that do not belong to all the listed functional units.
2.The reported results are inconsistent across tables. Table 1 reports RMSD, lDDT, and G-lDDT values of 1.5780, 0.9677, and 0.8341 for MoDA, whereas the learnable-schedule configuration in Table 4 reports 1.5776, 0.9586, and 0.7668, respectively. Although the RMSD discrepancy is small, the differences in lDDT and G-lDDT are substantial. The authors should clarify whether these discrepancies arise from different experimental settings, separate runs, or reporting errors.
3.Incomplete reporting of implementation and computational cost. Despite the code release, the manuscript leaves important settings unspecified, including the number of role prototypes, adapter rank, and training and sampling configurations. Runtime, memory usage, and parameter counts are also not reported, making reproducibility and the cost of the added modules difficult to assess.
4.The paper claims high sequence diversity but does not report direct diversity measurements. Neither sequence recovery against a single native reference nor target-level binding-energy success establishes diverse generation.
Questions for authors
1.Could the authors clarify the definitions of , , and , and explain how missing unit-specific features are handled when constructing for residues that do not belong to all functional units?
2.Do the MoDA results in Table 1 and the learnable-schedule results in Table 4 correspond to the same model configuration and evaluation protocol? If so, what explains the discrepancies in RMSD, lDDT, and G-lDDT?
3.How are structural and sequence metrics aggregated over the 100 candidates generated per target? Are they averaged over all candidates or computed from selected candidates, and is the same protocol applied to every baseline?
Thank you for the additional experiments and for clarifying how the 100 candidates per target were evaluated. The paired analysis across targets gave me more confidence in the reported structural improvements. I also appreciated the comparisons with simpler models of comparable size, particularly the one that kept the same auxiliary supervision and used ordinary residue embeddings.
I still have a question about Table 1. I understand that the original Tables 1 and 4 used different sets of atoms to calculate G-lDDT. My understanding from your response is that both the original and revised versions of Table 1 use Cα atoms. Could you clarify why MoDA's G-lDDT in that table changed from 0.8341 to 0.8192?
My main remaining concern is how to interpret the learned representations. On rereading Sections 3.3 and 3.4, I still found it difficult to connect the equations to what each component actually learns. The perturbation experiments help show that different components affect different aspects of the prediction. Since the training objective already encourages low cosine similarity, I'd be cautious about taking the observed separation as evidence that each component has learned the particular function described in the paper.
For these reasons, I'll keep my overall score at 2. Could you also update the manuscript with the changes highlighted in different colors? I had trouble locating some of the revisions mentioned in your response.