- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes Bounded Precision-Geometry Scaling (BPGS) to stabilize uncertainty-based weighting in multi-task learning with mismatched loss scales. Its main idea is to parameterize each task’s log-variance within a bounded interval determined by the current minibatch’s log-loss statistics. The resulting inverse variances are normalized into task weights. And separate stop-gradient objectives decouple network optimization from uncertainty adaptation. The authors establish batch-conditional boundedness and prove that normalized weights are invariant to uniform rescaling of all task losses under non-degenerate conditions. Experiments include NYUv2, Yeast, and RF1, showing the effectiveness of BPGS.
Critical strengths
- The proposed method is sound and novel.
- The experimental setup is comprehensive with good coverage on multiple benchmarks.
Critical weaknesses
-
Section 4.1 of the manuscript lists the ablation variants. But it doesn't adequately define their configurations or explain how they differ from canonical BPGS. This makes it difficult to determine which components are modified in each experiment.
-
The manuscript contains some formatting errors. This includes duplicated author names such as “Sener and Koltun Sener & Koltun (2018)” on page 2, line 82. And “Kendall et al. Kendall et al. (2018)” on page 4, line 179. Some symbols and lines overlap in Figure 1. This makes the diagram visually cluttered and low-quality. Many tables and figures in the appendix appear outside their corresponding sections, making it difficult to associate the results with the descriptions and analyses.
Questions for authors
- Table 6 reports scale-stress macro-score degradation of 32.3%, 28.5%, and 27.0% for Kendall, UWSO, and BPGS. Figure 5(a) reports 33.3%, 31.7%, and 29.1% for the same comparison. Could the authors explain this difference?
- The experimental comparisons rely on dated baselines, with Nash-MTL (2022) being the most recent. Could the authors include comparisons with recent methods published in 2025–2026?