acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

Learning after Execution with Action-Specific Credit

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Execution is often used as terminal feedback: it scores a generated program, but the resulting state is not used for another learning action. Learning after execution instead uses the execution result as an intermediate state that supports an additional learning interaction for the same policy. This creates a credit-assignment problem because the two actions share the same final objective but play different roles in the trajectory. Accordingly, action-specific credit assigns the initial action credit from the final trajectory outcome and the corrective action credit for improvement over the intermediate state. Image-to-TikZ serves as an executable visual testbed for this setting. On 945 held-out examples, learning after execution strengthens the shared policy under single-call inference and also produces a post-execution corrective capability. Single-call render success reaches 92.70%, compared with 88.25% for continued single-stage GRPO after the same number of additional training iterations. This corrective capability is not reproduced by continued single-stage training and depends on the intermediate state. Alternative credit definitions also induce different group-relative preferences over the same trajectories. Together, these results suggest that executable tasks contain useful learning structure beyond a terminal reward.

Primary area:
reinforcement learning
Keywords:
reinforcement learning, credit assignment, execution feedback, self-correction, group-relative policy optimization, program synthesis, multimodal learning, image-to-code generation

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 25%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.75 over 4 reviews, above 25% of the others.
Reviewer_NkiYOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes an action-specific credit assignment method for the image-to-TikZ task. The policy first generates code, then revises or repairs it based on the rendered output or execution failure feedback. Both outputs are scored by their rendered similarity to the target image, with failed executions receiving a score of zero. The shared policy is then updated using a GRPO-like algorithm. Unlike trajectory-level GRPO that assigns the same final-outcome credit to both actions, this method assigns the final score to the initial generation and the score improvement to the corrective action. Group-relative advantages are computed separately for the two stages.

Critical strengths
  1. The method assigns action-specific credit using execution scores from different stages, without introducing additional trainable components or requiring human-annotated corrections.
  2. The evaluation distinguishes improvements in initial generation from gains due to correction and examines when refinement helps or harms an existing output.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The paper lacks a two-stage GRPO baseline with fixed rollout-policy probabilities. Although variant C assigns the final trajectory score to both stages, it uses the paper’s modified probability-ratio computation and therefore does not provide this comparison. Moreover, the continued single-stage GRPO baseline does not match the proposed method in generation cost or optimizer update count, making it difficult to isolate the benefits of the proposed credit assignment.
  2. The evaluation is limited to an initial generation followed by a single corrective action. It remains unclear whether the proposed credit assignment retains its advantage over trajectory-level credit assignment across multiple correction rounds. Experiments with longer interaction horizons would help assess its generality and the accumulation of beneficial or harmful revisions.
  3. Some panels in Figure 5 appear blurry, making fine visual details difficult to inspect. Higher-resolution images or enlarged crops would make the qualitative comparisons easier to assess.
  4. The quantitative ablation results are dispersed across the appendix. A consolidated table in the main text summarizing correction quality, generation performance, and training stability across all credit-assignment variants would make the comparisons easier to assess.
  5. The collapse of variant C in ablation may be confounded by the probability-ratio implementation. Recomputing the denominator from the current policy before each update keeps the ratio at unity under identical forward passes, rendering clipping inactive. Consequently, repeated updates on the collected trajectories lack the clipping-based safeguard against excessive deviation from the rollout policy. This may contribute to the observed instability, so the collapse cannot be attributed solely to shared final-outcome credit. Repeating the ablation with fixed rollout-policy probabilities would help distinguish the effects of credit assignment from those of the optimization implementation.
Questions for authors
  1. Although variant C uses shared final-outcome credit, it retains the modified probability-ratio implementation. Could the authors provide a two-stage GRPO baseline with fixed rollout-policy probabilities and a matched training budget? This would help isolate the benefits of the proposed credit assignment from differences in interaction cost and optimizer update count.

  2. The experiments consider only one corrective action. Does the proposed credit assignment retain its advantage over shared trajectory-level credit across multiple correction rounds? An evaluation with longer interaction horizons would help establish the scope of the findings.

  3. Appendix B.1 explains that denominator log probabilities are recomputed from the current policy and reports that clipping remains inactive. What motivates this choice over keeping rollout-policy probabilities fixed? Could this implementation choice contribute to the collapse of variant C, and does the collapse persist when the ablation is repeated with fixed rollout-policy probabilities?

Reviewer_WoDZOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper examines learning after execution: the policy first generates and executes a TikZ program, then uses the resulting execution state for visual revision or execution repair. Experiments with Qwen3-VL-8B-Instruct on Image-to-TikZ show higher render success and visual metrics than continued single-stage GRPO, with further gains from execution-aware selection. Overall, this is a valuable single-setting proof-of-concept.

Critical strengths

1.The paper provides a clear formulation of learning from intermediate execution feedback. Execution feedback becomes an intermediate state that informs a subsequent policy action, and visual revision and execution repair are incorporated into a unified two-action framework with separately defined credit. This formulation is a useful contribution because it makes the relationship between initial generation, execution outcomes, and corrective behavior explicit.

2.The experiments provide a promising proof of concept and informative behavioral analysis. Under the reported setup, Stage 0 achieves 92.70% render success, compared with 88.25% for continued single-stage GRPO after 100 additional training iterations, alongside improvements in all four visual metrics. Reporting Stage 0, raw Stage 1, and Selected separately, together with analyses of correction, over-revision, repair, and unresolved cases, helps reveal both the gains and the conditions under which revision succeeds or fails.

Critical weaknesses

1.The reported gains are not sufficiently disentangled from additional compute and selection effects. The comparison with continued single-stage GRPO does not match training budgets or separately account for generation and execution costs. Moreover, on Final-945, raw Stage 1 improves render success over Stage 0 by only 0.10 percentage points, while Selected reaches 94.18%, leaving the respective contributions of shared-policy learning, conditional correction, and RSim selection unclear. These confounds prevent a clean assessment of the method’s incremental benefit at comparable cost and substantially weaken the main empirical claim.

2.The evidence does not sufficiently establish the claimed algorithmic novelty or broader applicability. The credit definitions G0=S1G_0=S_1 and G1=S1−S0G_1=S_1-S_0 constitute an incremental-reward decomposition for a two-step trajectory, but a distinct optimization advantage is not established. The C/D ablations do not resolve this issue because their collapse coincides with uncontrolled generation length, fewer normal terminations, and loss of execution signal. The absence of direct comparisons with execution-aware refinement or multi-turn RL, together with evaluation on a single backbone and task, further limits the contribution to a single-setting proof of concept.

Questions for authors

On a common set of items, could the authors report Stage 0, raw Stage 1, and Selected separately, together with raw Stage 1 execution recovery, execution regression, and visual changes among successfully rendered outputs, to distinguish the contributions of shared-policy improvement, conditional correction, and RSim selection?

Keeping all other training settings unchanged, could the authors change only the credit definition of the C/D variants and report generation length, normal termination, and compilation success again?

How does the paper relate to existing execution-aware refinement and multi-turn refinement methods? If no direct comparison is provided, should the claimed advantage be limited to the results relative to the current Direct-GRPO control group?

Reviewer_y9ZeOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
3
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies learning after execution in Image-to-TikZ generation. Instead of treating execution only as terminal feedback, the method uses the execution result of an initial program as an intermediate state for a second corrective action by the same policy. The paper proposes action-specific credit assignment: the initial action receives the final trajectory score S1, while the corrective action receives the improvement S1-S0 over the intermediate state. Experiments with Qwen3-VL-8B-Instruct show improvements in single-call generation, post-execution correction, and execution-aware selection. On the held-out Final-945 set, the proposed method achieves 92.70% Stage 0 render success and 94.18% render success after selecting between Stage 0 and Stage 1 outputs, compared with 88.25% for continued single-stage Direct-GRPO.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper introduces a clear and useful formulation of learning after execution. Treating the execution result as an intermediate state for a subsequent policy action is a meaningful extension of execution-based learning and is clearly distinguished from using execution only as terminal reward feedback.
  2. The empirical analysis is thorough. In addition to aggregate performance, the paper studies factorized credit variants, execution transitions, paired-success correction, state-dependent behavior, multiple visual metrics, and held-out evaluation. These analyses provide useful evidence about when and how the corrective action helps.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The main comparison is not fully compute-matched. The proposed method performs sequential optimization over Stage 0 and Stage 1 actions, while continued Direct-GRPO uses a different number of low-level optimizer updates per training iteration. Matching the number of iterations and training examples does not match optimizer updates, generated tokens, execution calls, or wall-clock cost. Therefore, the experiments do not fully isolate the effect of learning after execution and action-specific credit assignment.
  2. The empirical validation is limited in scope. The study uses one 8B backbone, one executable visual program domain, one main training seed, and a relatively small training set. The bootstrap analysis measures uncertainty over evaluation examples but does not measure variation across independent training runs. This limits confidence in the robustness and generality of the main conclusions.
Questions for authors
  1. Can the authors provide a comparison against continued Direct-GRPO that is matched in optimizer updates, generated tokens, execution calls, and wall-clock training cost?
  2. Can the authors clarify how much of the final gain comes from the additional corrective interaction itself, as opposed to the different optimization schedule used by the proposed method?
  3. Do the authors expect the proposed credit assignment to transfer to other executable domains, model sizes, or tasks beyond Image-to-TikZ?
Reviewer_4nmJOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper study how to make the execution state of the policy’s own prediction a suitable learnable target of GRPO. the question of. On the task of Image-to-TikZ, the proposed method shows kind of efficiency.

Critical strengths

1.The proposed question deserves study;

2.The evaluation distinguishes the benefits from the model's own capabilities and inference settings;

3.The ablation study is relatively complete

Critical weaknesses

1.There are already similar methods (i.e. RRVF, VisRefiner) addressing the same problems, what is the essential difference between the proposed methods and the existed methods?

2.The experiments did not report the results produced by the other similar methods.

3.The presentation of the paper needs to be polished.

Questions for authors

See in weaknesses

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.