- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents EMPIRIC, an agentic framework for learning residual world models through interaction for novel tasks that require trial and error. Starting from a supplied physics simulator, an LLM-based coding agent generates executable programs to model missing physical mechanisms. The framework further integrates Bayesian parameter inference, simulation-based planning, and informative experimentation to support robot manipulation under uncertainty.
The method is evaluated across five simulated manipulation domains, achieving 25/25 successful runs and outperforming three agent-based baselines in success rate and interaction efficiency. A real-robot experiment involving wind forces and domino manipulation further demonstrates its practical applicability.
Critical strengths
-
Effective integration of physical priors with agentic world-model learning. Extending an existing physics simulator with executable missing mechanisms is a practically meaningful design choice. It allows the agent to leverage established rigid-body dynamics while modeling additional phenomena, including history-dependent effects. The resulting models are interpretable and can support planning across different task configurations.
-
Strong empirical performance across diverse physical mechanisms. EMPIRIC achieves consistently high success rates across five simulated domains, substantially outperforming the evaluated agentic baselines. The real-robot demonstration also provides encouraging evidence that the framework can identify physical properties through interaction and use the resulting model for planning.
Critical weaknesses
- Limited methodological novelty beyond existing programmatic world-model learning and agentic frameworks. The central workflow of EMPIRIC is to use an LLM to generate executable world models (simulators), evaluating predictions against observations, revising the models, and planning with them. This has substantial overlap with existing approaches such as WorldCoder, TheoryCoder, and POMDP Coder. Similarly, residual physics modeling, Bayesian system identification, and information-driven experimentation are well-established techniques.
The principal distinction appears to be the use of a supplied physics engine as an inductive prior, with an LLM generating executable extensions for missing physical mechanisms. While this is a sensible and useful design, the paper does not clearly establish a fundamentally new learning algorithm or sufficiently explain what methodological capabilities go beyond combining existing techniques in an agentic structure.
Additionally, the high-level decisions regarding mechanism generation, model revision, and experiment selection remain largely delegated to the general-purpose coding agent, while parameter fitting and simulation-based planning rely on established techniques. Consequently, I find the contribution more convincing as a system integration effort than as a distinct methodological advance.
Furthermore, although the framework is evaluated across different physical mechanisms, it is unclear how much domain-specific engineering is needed to support a new environment, given the domain-dependent prompts and additional reference files described in Appendix D. This raises the question of whether the framework's generality comes from a distinct learning methodology or primarily from the flexibility of the coding agent and supplied infrastructure.
- Insufficiently controlled baseline comparisons to isolate the claimed contributions. The experimental comparisons conflate the proposed residual modeling approach with substantial differences in the infrastructure available to each agent. EMPIRIC receives a supplied executable physics simulator integrated with the robot's skill controllers, along with dedicated tools for parameter fitting, model validation, trajectory rehearsal, and plan refinement (Appendix B.1 and D.3).
In contrast, the Direct agent has no supplied simulator, while Standalone Simulator must construct its predictive model without the supplied base simulator. Although Direct + Scene receives scene assets and engine code, it is unclear whether it has access to comparable skill-level simulation, model-fitting, and planning interfaces (Section 4.1).
Appendix D.3 indicates that EMPIRIC can simulate robot skill execution before learning any missing mechanisms, including checking grasp feasibility and collisions. I believe this could already provide a substantial planning advantage. The authors also acknowledge in Section 4.1 that some baseline failures arise from incorrectly modeling robot skill execution, suggesting that the supplied simulation infrastructure may contribute significantly to the observed improvements.
While these comparisons are meaningful at the system level, they do not isolate the benefits of the proposed residual-model learning methodology. An important missing baseline is a coding agent equipped with the same base simulator, skill simulation, fitting/evaluation tools, and computational resources, but without EMPIRIC's prescribed residual-model representation and learning workflow.
Overall, the results demonstrate the effectiveness of the complete framework, but currently provide insufficient evidence that its proposed methodological contributions are responsible for the gains.
Questions for authors
-
Could you compare EMPIRIC against the coding agent with access to the same base simulator, robot skill simulation, parameter-fitting/evaluation utilities, and computational budget, but without the proposed residual-model representation and prescribed learning workflow? This would help isolate the benefits of the proposed method from those of the supplied simulation infrastructure.
-
Could you clarify the precise tool access and system prompts provided to Direct + Scene and Standalone Simulator, particularly whether they could rehearse robot skills using the same underlying physics engine and access equivalent trajectory-evaluation functions? This information is important for assessing the comparability of the experimental settings.
-
Appendix D.3 reproduces the system prompt for only one Bridge run and notes that prompts for other domains contain domain-specific differences. The agent also receives reference files that are not reproduced in the paper. Could you clarify how much domain-specific engineering or prompt customization is required when applying EMPIRIC to a new environment with unfamiliar physical mechanisms?
While the test tasks evaluate new configurations within the same domains, it remains unclear how readily the framework can be extended to entirely new physical mechanisms without additional domain-specific engineering. To what extent does the proposed framework generalize to entirely new mechanisms without additional domain-specific modeling support?
3 comments
Response to Reviewer M7Ty (2/3): W2
W2.
Insufficiently controlled baseline comparisons to isolate the claimed contributions. The experimental comparisons conflate the proposed residual modeling approach with substantial differences in the infrastructure available to each agent. EMPIRIC receives a supplied executable physics simulator integrated with the robot's skill controllers, along with dedicated tools for parameter fitting, model validation, trajectory rehearsal, and plan refinement (Appendix B.1 and D.3).
In contrast, the Direct agent has no supplied simulator, while Standalone Simulator must construct its predictive model without the supplied base simulator. Although Direct + Scene receives scene assets and engine code, it is unclear whether it has access to comparable skill-level simulation, model-fitting, and planning interfaces (Section 4.1).
The revised comparison separates the residual model from the supplied infrastructure, as the reviewer asks. All agents share the coding agent (Claude Opus 5), the skill library and the step budgets. The table below (Table 1 and Appendix A.4 in the paper) lists what else each agent receives.
| Agent | Scene assets | Base simulator (engine, robot model) | Mechanism learning interface | Harness fit | Explicit uncertainty | Solved (of 50) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Direct agent | no | no | no | no | no | 35 |
| Direct + scene | yes | no | no | no | no | 41 |
| WorldCoder (adapted) | yes | no | no | no | no | 38 |
| Direct + base simulator | yes | yes | no | no | no | 37 |
| No learning | yes | yes | no | no | – | 30 |
| No harness fitting | yes | yes | yes | no | yes | 41 |
| No explicit uncertainty | yes | yes | yes | yes | no | 39 |
| EMPIRIC | yes | yes | yes | yes | yes | 47 |
Direct + scene and WorldCoder (adapted), which the submission called Standalone sim., receive the scene assets (URDF and meshes, with no masses or frictions), and PyBullet is importable in their sandbox. They do not receive the base simulator, which holds the simulated robot, so they can rehearse a skill only in a simulator that they write themselves. All baselines can apply the task evaluator to the trajectories that they predict, as EMPIRIC can (Appendix A.4 lists each agent's tools).
Appendix D.3 indicates that EMPIRIC can simulate robot skill execution before learning any missing mechanisms, including checking grasp feasibility and collisions. I believe this could already provide a substantial planning advantage. The authors also acknowledge in Section 4.1 that some baseline failures arise from incorrectly modeling robot skill execution, suggesting that the supplied simulation infrastructure may contribute significantly to the observed improvements.
The base simulator's physics engine and robot model do not explain the gain by themselves. Direct + base simulator and No learning have both but cannot add mechanisms (see the table above), and they solve 37 and 30 of 50 runs, fewer than Direct + scene (41), which has no supplied simulator. In Domino, for example, the base simulator misses the spin of a domino struck at an angle, so No learning solves 1 of 10 runs. Some baseline failures do come from a wrong model of the robot's motion (Section 4.1 gives one in Fan), but the revised paper no longer attributes EMPIRIC's advantage to the robot model.
While these comparisons are meaningful at the system level, they do not isolate the benefits of the proposed residual-model learning methodology. An important missing baseline is a coding agent equipped with the same base simulator, skill simulation, fitting/evaluation tools, and computational resources, but without EMPIRIC's prescribed residual-model representation and learning workflow.
A coding agent with all of these components is basically EMPIRIC itself: the residual model is a subclass of the base simulator in which the agent writes its mechanisms, and the agent decides when to experiment, revise the model, fit and act. We therefore remove parts of this design. Direct + base simulator keeps the physics engine, the robot model and the task evaluator, but it cannot add mechanisms and has no fitting or rehearsal tools; it solves 37 of 50 runs, and EMPIRIC solves 47.
Overall, the results demonstrate the effectiveness of the complete framework, but currently provide insufficient evidence that its proposed methodological contributions are responsible for the gains.
Each part matters for a reliable agent, as three ablations now show: the agent loses 17 runs without the learned mechanisms, and 6 or 8 runs without the harness fit or the explicit uncertainty.
- No learning keeps the base simulator and the rehearsal and planning tools, but it cannot add mechanisms or fit parameters. It solves 30 of 50 runs.
- No harness fitting and No explicit uncertainty keep program learning and solve 41 and 39 of 50 runs. In Domino, where a single push that cannot be undone decides the outcome, they solve 5 of 10 runs each, against 10 of 10 for EMPIRIC.
Response to Reviewer M7Ty (3/3): Q1-Q4
Q1.
Could you compare EMPIRIC against the coding agent with access to the same base simulator, robot skill simulation, parameter-fitting/evaluation utilities, and computational budget, but without the proposed residual-model representation and prescribed learning workflow? This would help isolate the benefits of the proposed method from those of the supplied simulation infrastructure.
Please see our reply to W2: such an agent is basically EMPIRIC itself, so we compare against agents that each lack one part of it (37, 30, 41 and 39 of 50 runs, against 47 for EMPIRIC). All agents have the same budget of environment steps. EMPIRIC uses more computation within it, a median of 278 minutes per run against 50 for Direct + base simulator, and Section 6 and Appendix A.3 state this cost.
Q2.
Could you clarify the precise tool access and system prompts provided to Direct + Scene and Standalone Simulator, particularly whether they could rehearse robot skills using the same underlying physics engine and access equivalent trajectory-evaluation functions? This information is important for assessing the comparability of the experimental settings.
Both agents can use the same physics engine and the same task evaluator, but they do not receive the base simulator, which holds the simulated robot. Our reply to W2 gives the details, and the table there (Table 1 in the paper) lists what each agent receives.
Q3.
Appendix D.3 reproduces the system prompt for only one Bridge run and notes that prompts for other domains contain domain-specific differences. The agent also receives reference files that are not reproduced in the paper. Could you clarify how much domain-specific engineering or prompt customization is required when applying EMPIRIC to a new environment with unfamiliar physical mechanisms?
The revised version needs no prompt customization and no modeling code for a new environment (see our reply to W1).
Q4.
While the test tasks evaluate new configurations within the same domains, it remains unclear how readily the framework can be extended to entirely new physical mechanisms without additional domain-specific engineering. To what extent does the proposed framework generalize to entirely new mechanisms without additional domain-specific modeling support?
The mechanisms in our five domains are already new to the base simulator, which has no glue, lift, airflow, water or heat, and the agent adds each of them from its own experiments with no modeling code from the user. We did not test a domain outside these five. The main assumption is the rigid-body physics engine: for phenomena such as deformable objects, the base simulator can use an engine with soft-body support, or the agent's program can simulate the object itself, and we have not evaluated these extensions (Section 6).
Response to Reviewer M7Ty (1/3): W1
We thank the reviewer for the careful reading and the constructive suggestions. We have revised the agent and added a baseline and an ablation for the comparison that the reviewer asks for (see our general response). All simulated results below are for the revised version.
W1.
We build on these techniques, but none of them lets a robot add a missing mechanism to a physics engine from its own experiments and then plan under uncertainty about it. Prior program world-model learners (WorldCoder, TheoryCoder, POMDP Coder) target grid worlds, games and discrete domains. Residual physics methods (SAIN, NeuralSim) fit corrections to data collected beforehand, and active identification (ASID) fits the parameters of a fixed model.
Our contribution is a new formulation of what the robot learns: a program that extends a domain-agnostic base simulator (a physics engine with a model of the robot) with the missing mechanisms, their parameters and their hidden state, together with a belief over the parameters. The formulation gives two capabilities that the existing techniques lack: the robot learns both the parameters and the structure of its model, and one belief serves both learning and planning (the robot designs experiments to narrow it and rehearses its plans under it). Agents with only parts of this design solve 30 to 41 of 50 runs, and EMPIRIC solves 47.
The same coding agent solves more runs with our model than without it: the four baselines use the same coding agent, skills and budget, and they solve 35 to 41 of 50 runs, against 47 for EMPIRIC (Table 1). The coding agent makes the high-level decisions by design, so that a stronger coding agent improves the system with no change to the harness. Earlier systems such as WorldCoder and ExoPredicator fix the learning flow in advance, which we see as a limitation and an inefficiency.
The revised agent needs no domain-specific engineering. The user provides the task definition, the scene assets, the sensor noise levels and the robot skills that the domain uses, which come from a shared library. The base simulator, system prompt, tools and reference files are the same in every domain. Appendix D reproduces the prompt and marks the three places that differ: the noise levels and the numbers of bodies and asset files.