- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper constructs RAP, a fairly large dataset for paper-to-poster generation. It includes an automated data construction pipeline that converts posters into HTML/CSS with fine-grained layout, style, and content-slot information. Based on these data, the authors explore two applications: first, PosterRAG, which retrieves an existing template and fills it with content from a new paper; second, SFT and RL on Qwen3.8-27B, using factors that affect poster quality, such as layout, content completeness, and readability, as training rewards. The experiments evaluate reconstruction quality during data construction, as well as the visual diversity of the posters generated by the two approaches and their distributional similarity to human-crafted posters.
Critical strengths
1.The data construction pipeline is quite interesting and provides a clear process that can scale up. In terms of data processing, some of the fine-grained representations are helpful for subsequent training. 2.Using the factors that determine poster quality as a rubric for training is a good idea and a good design choice.
Critical weaknesses
1.The paper does not clearly describe manual spot-checking in the data construction pipeline. 2.I noticed that the authors state that template information from the corresponding original poster is provided at test time. However, in the comparison in Figure 6, I could not clearly see the reference template’s style reflected in the outputs from Astra and Gemini. 3.Table 3 does not specify the parameter count of Qwen3.5. 4.There is a lot of blank space on page 21. I suggest addressing this.
Questions for authors
Ask only questions whose answers could materially affect your assessment. Distinguish clarification requests from suggestions for future work. Was any manual spot-checking carried out during data construction? If so, how many samples were checked, what was checked, and what were the results? In Figure 6, Astra and Gemini do not seem to follow the reference template’s style, even though the template information is provided. Does the prompt explicitly ask them to follow the template? Normally, when we ask AI to help us make a poster and provide a template, we would also ask it to follow that template. If this requirement is made more explicit in the prompt, would the gap still be there? Which size of Qwen3.5 was used in Table 3? Maybe the largest one?