- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper investigates whether image agents can complete visual commissions that require integrating heterogeneous source materials, maintaining constraints across dependent stages, and coordinating multiple deliverables. It introduces Visual Commission Bench (VCB), comprising 600 tasks across 12 categories and 5,039 requirement checks, together with V-Protocol. VCB evaluates final deliverables through requirement satisfaction, strict task success, and visual quality. V-Protocol combines task, cognitive, and expression modules with a dynamic operation graph and a shared execution harness to manage tool execution, artifact revisions, dependencies, and online verification. Experiments compare task completion across systems on VCB, WISE-Verified, and Mind-Bench. Component analyses and execution-trace observations further examine module selection and runtime enforcement.
Critical strengths
-
The problem formulation addresses a practical need. The paper extends evaluation beyond individual image generation to complete visual commissions, emphasizing information extraction from multiple source files, dependent operations, preservation of evolving constraints, and coordinated delivery. This setting more closely reflects practical workflows than evaluating prompt adherence or the quality of a single image alone.
-
The benchmark has substantial scope. VCB includes 600 tasks, 12 categories, 45 subcategories, 4,288 source files, and 5,039 requirement checks. Evaluating requirement satisfaction separately from visual quality helps identify cases in which images appear satisfactory but the overall commission remains incomplete. This benchmark contribution is potentially useful independently of the proposed reference agent.
-
Explicit execution-state management has practical value. Supplementary Figure 5 illustrates the relationships among task specification, module composition, operation-graph execution, verification feedback, and delivery, while distinguishing stale artifact dependencies from invalidated verification reports. Table 2 reports high task completion rates, and Appendix D provides descriptive analyses of execution traces and controller usage that offer concrete observations about reliability in multistage execution.
Critical weaknesses
Major Weaknesses
-
The methodological novelty of V-Protocol and its module-selection claims are not sufficiently established. The framework combines three module families, capability matching, operation graphs, artifact revision management, and online verification for visual commissions, but its key technical additions over existing skill orchestration and workflow execution systems remain unclear. In particular, the Introduction claims that module combinations are selected dynamically using effect profiles estimated on separate development tasks. However, Section 4.2 and supplementary Figure 5 describe capability matching, configured priorities, capability coverage, and model-based selection, with module-effect estimates used only for offline diagnostics. The module-budget experiments in Appendix C do not establish the benefit of using effect profiles for selection either. The technical claims should be aligned with the implementation, the mechanisms distinguishing V-Protocol from the closest systems should be specified, and controlled comparisons should separate the contributions of modular guidance, candidate filtering, and effect-based selection.
-
Although the overall workflow is illustrated, the key decision mechanisms remain insufficiently specified for reproduction. Supplementary Figure 5 clarifies task specification, module composition, guarded execution, verification feedback, and revision invalidation. However, Appendix A still primarily outlines the responsibilities of the model and the harness, without providing complete pseudocode, a module inventory with its actual guidance, executable input/output schemas, candidate-ranking rules, or key prompt templates. The available materials do not sufficiently specify how operation nodes are created and revised, module applicability is assessed, stale dependencies are resolved, or semantic verification feedback triggers editing, regeneration, or replanning. These implementation details should be provided, together with a complete execution example containing the actual task specification, operation graph, module assignments, artifact revisions, and verification results.
-
The comparability of baseline access capabilities and execution conditions remains insufficiently documented. Appendix B.2 standardizes the controller and image backend but notes that shared backends do not imply equal call counts or execution time. Main-text Figure 4 and supplementary Figures 18 and 20 attribute GEMS failures to its inability to read files autonomously, although file access is a core prerequisite of VCB. These comparisons may therefore conflate system adaptation with methodological differences. The paper should report each method’s file and tool access, main-experiment budgets, and retry and recovery rules, and compare methods under shared capability interfaces and explicit budgets. Although Table 7 reports controller usage and session duration, it excludes earlier attempts, subsequent manual recovery, and some model calls; caching and service load are also not matched. These statistics do not support a rigorously controlled comparison of total cost or latency.
-
The ablations are confounded by subset selection and execution history, preventing isolation of the components’ causal contributions. Appendix C states that the diagnostic subset was selected using historical Full performance rather than as an independent held-out sample. Full reuses historical outputs from earlier runtime versions and recovery runs, and exact equivalence of historical model weights was not verified despite the shared controller identifier. In contrast, the new variants use frozen implementations and receive one execution per task within limits of 256 steps, eight generation calls, and eight editing calls, without subsequent output-driven recovery runs. Differences between Full and the variants in main-text Table 4 and supplementary Table 5 may thus reflect subset selection, runtime versions, model versions, and recovery opportunities. Although the authors appropriately describe these results as exploratory diagnostics, they do not establish the independent effects of the core components. All configurations should be rerun on a prespecified task set selected independently of Full performance, using the same frozen model and runtime, budgets, and recovery rules, with uncertainty reported across repeated runs.
-
The absence of an independent human study of final deliverables leaves evaluation validity insufficiently established. Human involvement in Section 3.2 concerns reviewing requirement checklists and does not replace independent assessment of generated outputs. Section 3.3 uses the same Qwen3.8-Flash-Next model to evaluate both requirement satisfaction and visual quality, and the supplementary material reports neither corresponding agreement with human judgments nor user evaluation. VCB emphasizes complete visual commissions, for which readability, layout, consistency across deliverables, and practical usability have subjective aspects. It is therefore unclear whether higher ReqPass, TaskPass, and VQ scores correspond to task completion that human evaluators would accept. A human study should use stratified task sampling and conceal system identities. Multiple independent raters should assess requirement satisfaction against the requests and source materials, as well as visual quality, consistency across outputs, and overall readiness for delivery. Designers or intended users could be included for C-tier tasks. Inter-rater agreement, agreement between automated and human assessments, and paired comparisons with the strongest baseline should be reported, together with confidence intervals.
Minor Weaknesses
-
The tier-level analysis would benefit from more detailed task-structure statistics. S, M, and C differ in both task categories and execution scope, and the authors already clarify that they do not represent intrinsic difficulty levels. Reporting the distributions of source-file counts, applicable requirement checks, deliverable counts, and dependency depth for each tier would help interpret TaskPass differences. The decline across tiers alone cannot separate the effects of task type from those of dependency complexity.
-
The Introduction contains redundant text and typographical errors. Two consecutive paragraphs on page 2 begin with “Existing evaluations have extended image generation...” and substantially overlap; the text also contains “require require.” The misspellings “conmmission” in Figure 2 and “achives” in the Figure 4 caption should be corrected. The repeated paragraphs should be consolidated and the manuscript carefully proofread.
-
Citations and sources for published results should be made more explicit in the tables. Several benchmarks in Table 1 lack row-level citations, while the published GPT-Image-1.5, Nano Banana Pro, and Qwen-Image-Agent results in Table 3 lack itemized information on model versions, sources, and evaluation protocols. Complete references should be added to the tables or footnotes, with clarification of whether these results are directly comparable to the shared-backend experiments.
-
The module-budget experiments introduce an additional intervention. Appendix C permits bypassing the expression-module prerequisite when the module budget leaves no room for an expression module, so the differences in Table 5 do not arise solely from module counts. The actual module distributions and diagnostic-subset size should be reported, and the effects of budget restrictions should be distinguished from those of relaxing the prerequisite.
Questions for authors
-
Do module-effect profiles influence runtime selection in the evaluated implementation? If so, where do they enter candidate ranking or selection? If not, how should the corresponding claim in the Introduction be interpreted, and what mechanism distinguishes the implemented selector from capability matching followed by model-based selection?
-
Are the complete module definitions, key prompt templates, input/output schemas, and operation-graph update procedures available? A representative execution trace showing module assignments, artifact revisions, and verification-triggered repairs would help establish whether the framework can be reproduced from the provided materials.
-
What file-reading, retrieval, image-editing, and workspace capabilities were available to each baseline? In particular, was GEMS given a compatible way to access the source files? Please clarify the main-experiment budgets and retry and recovery policies for all methods.
-
Are component comparisons available in which Full and all ablations use the same frozen controller weights, runtime, task set, budgets, and recovery policy? How many tasks are in the diagnostic subset, and what selection rule was applied using historical Full performance?
-
Was any independent human evaluation of final deliverables conducted beyond checklist review? If available, please report the sampling procedure, evaluator qualifications, inter-rater agreement, agreement with automated judgments, and paired comparisons against the strongest baseline.
9 comments
Reply-2
A1.2 Module-Effect Profiles
Module-effect profiles do not influence runtime selection in the evaluated implementation. This mechanism was part of our initial design, but we subsequently removed it to avoid potentially favoring similar benchmark tasks and compromising the fairness of the comparison.
The implemented selection procedure is as follows:
- Retrieve candidate modules whose capabilities overlap with the requirements declared by the current operation node.
- Establish a deterministic candidate order using configured priority, the number of required capabilities covered, and module identifiers.
- The controller assesses applicability and selects suitable modules based on the current operation's goal, input artifacts, and the modules' applicability conditions.
- Load procedural guidance from the selected modules. Some support modules can also be preselected during method selection for the task and loaded at matching operation nodes.
Accordingly, we have removed the inconsistent description from the Introduction and revised the relevant text as follows:
We present V-Protocol as a reference agent for end-to-end visual commission completion. V-Protocol relies on two complementary designs: adaptive module composition and runtime enforcement. Adaptive module composition forms an operation graph and configures its nodes by ranking candidate modules, assessing their applicability, and selecting suitable guidance. Runtime enforcement executes the graph through a dedicated harness that enforces execution constraints, governs stage transitions, and manages tool execution.
This wording is consistent with Section 4.2, the supplementary framework figure, and the selection rules in the appendix.
A1.3 Ablations
The two original component ablations correspond to the two designs described above:
- w/o Runtime Enforcement: Retains module selection and tool access while relaxing the specified execution gates.
- w/o Adaptive Module Selection: Uses the same predefined module combination for all tasks while retaining the guidance text of those modules and task-planning capability.
To address the reviewer's request to distinguish modular guidance from candidate filtering, we add two fine-grained ablations:
- w/o Module-specific Procedural Guidance: Replaces module-specific guidance text with interface descriptions while retaining metadata, interfaces, program templates, candidate recommendation, and runtime constraints.
- w/o Capability-based Candidate Recommendation: Removes capability-overlap filtering and ranking by capability coverage from automatic candidate recommendation, while retaining module guidance, model-based selection, preselected support modules, and other loading paths.
| Configuration | w/ Module-specific Procedural Guidance | w/ Capability-based Candidate Recommendation | RP ↑ | TP ↑ | VQ ↑ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| w/o Runtime Enforcement | — | — | 81.59 ± 0.57 | 60.44 ± 0.79 | 3.760 ± 0.038 |
| w/o Adaptive Module Selection | × | √ | 88.55 ± 0.31 | 64.44 ± 1.92 | 4.148 ± 0.081 |
| w/o Adaptive Module Selection | √ | × | 91.32 ± 0.41 | 67.22 ± 2.55 | 4.068 ± 0.036 |
| w/o Adaptive Module Selection | Fixed | × | 82.28 ± 0.18 | 61.83 ± 0.93 | 3.865 ± 0.006 |
| Full V-Protocol | √ | √ | 94.28 ± 0.18 | 69.11 ± 0.67 | 4.202 ± 0.005 |
Fixed denotes the same predefined four-module combination for every task, retaining its guidance text. This is the fixed-module ablation described in Section 5.2 (Component analysis).
Full V-Protocol outperforms all the ablated configurations across RP, TP, and VQ, isolating and quantifying the performance gains attributable to the proposed modules.
Accordingly, Section 5.2 (Component analysis) describes the fine-grained ablation settings, and Table 4 reports the results.
Reply-3
Major Weaknesses 2 and Q2: Detail of V-Protocol
Major Weaknesses 2. Although the overall workflow is illustrated, the key decision mechanisms remain insufficiently specified for reproduction. Supplementary Figure 5 clarifies task specification, module composition, guarded execution, verification feedback, and revision invalidation. However, Appendix A still primarily outlines the responsibilities of the model and the harness, without providing complete pseudocode, a module inventory with its actual guidance, executable input/output schemas, candidate-ranking rules, or key prompt templates. The available materials do not sufficiently specify how operation nodes are created and revised, module applicability is assessed, stale dependencies are resolved, or semantic verification feedback triggers editing, regeneration, or replanning. These implementation details should be provided, together with a complete execution example containing the actual task specification, operation graph, module assignments, artifact revisions, and verification results.
Q2. Are the complete module definitions, key prompt templates, input/output schemas, and operation-graph update procedures available? A representative execution trace showing module assignments, artifact revisions, and verification-triggered repairs would help establish whether the framework can be reproduced from the provided materials.
A2: We thank the reviewer for the attention to reproducibility and the detailed suggestions for clarifying V-Protocol’s decision mechanisms and implementation details. We will make the code publicly available. In the revised supplementary material, we have expanded Appendix A as follows:
- Appendix A.1 (Selection rule) specifies capability-based candidate retrieval, ranking by configured priority and capability coverage with module identifiers as the tie-breaker, and controller-assessed applicability.
- Appendix A.2 (Schemas and operation-graph updates) presents the principal structured interfaces in Table 5 and pseudocode for the execution loop (Algorithm 1), module selection and loading (Algorithm 2), dependency freshness and verification-triggered repair (Algorithm 3), and operation-graph updates (Algorithm 4). The subsequent Controller and harness paragraph clarifies their respective roles.
- Appendix A.3 (Actual Execution Trace) provides a recorded end-to-end C-tier workspace example, including the final TaskSpec, operation graph, node-level module assignments, image revisions, and verification results. Table 6 summarizes the execution steps and artifact versions, while Figure 6 shows the generated images, including the schedule before and after verification-triggered regeneration, together with the final delivered outputs.
Reply-1
We sincerely thank the reviewer for the highly recognization of VCB’s practical value and the benefits of V-Protocol’s execution-state management. We also appreciate the reviewer’s detailed comments, which have helped us refine the methodological description and clarify key implementation details. We have provided point-by-point responses to all comments and revised the relevant sections of the manuscript and supplementary material accordingly.
Major Weaknesses 1 and Q1: Novelty of V-Protocol
A1: We thank the reviewer for highlighting the need to clarify V-Protocol's contributions and implementation details. We address this concern through the methodological contributions, runtime selection mechanism, and ablation studies below.
A1.1 Novelty Claims
V-Protocol is built around two complementary designs: adaptive module composition and runtime enforcement. These form the core of our methodological contributions and are implemented as follows.
Adaptive module composition. The system constructs a TaskSpec from the user request and publicly available source materials, and forms an operation graph using an applicable task template or model-based planning. Each operation specifies its goal, input and output artifacts, capability requirements, and permitted actions. Task, cognitive, and expression modules provide reusable guidance for task procedures, content reasoning, and visual expression, respectively. Multiple types of module guidance can be combined within the same operation, and modules can be reused across operations.
Runtime enforcement. Based on the current execution state, the harness checks input availability, dependency freshness, action permissions, and budgets, and registers generated artifacts and their revisions. Verification reports are bound to a specific image's identifier, revision, content digest, and verification criteria. If the image or relevant criteria change, an earlier report cannot directly serve as evidence that the current revision passes verification. Final delivery must also satisfy the specified file requirements and current completion conditions.
Implementing these designs involves more detailed mechanisms. For example, the modular guidance and candidate filtering identified by the reviewer are concrete mechanisms used to implement adaptive module composition.
We also compare V-Protocol with SCOPE, the most closely related system: