- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
As far as I can tell the paper seems to study if several observations are compressed separately and then the compressed representations are used for a prediction task, under what conditions do zero local losses imply zero joint loss, and how large the joint loss can be when the local losses are small.
Critical strengths
None.
Critical weaknesses
-
I have significant concerns about this paper and its integrity. Beyond the first few paragraphs'' (perhaps beyond the first paragraph of the intro), the writing doesn't make sense.
-
The formal problem formulation is not clear and introduces a lot of terms that are not described explicitly. There is a lot of technical jargon that is not defined explicitly. For example, in the first paragraph of Section 3, it is mentioned that "The raw tuple distinguishes every atom." However, I am not clear what "atom" means in this context.
-
Similarly, in the same paragraph it is stated that "let J contain the nonempty fibers of Z". However, "J" is not defined yet. Also, what is a "nonempty fiber"? The rest of the paper goes on like this. For example equation (1) describes two mutual information quantities that depend on some term "\mu" but we do not know what "\mu" is. Perhaps it is related to another term "\mu_x" that is used in the first paragraph, but then we are also not told what "\mu_x" is, or how "\mu_x" relates to "\mu". Then the paper moves on to talking about a "target map" B_T without explicitly defining what is the target.
-
The entirety of the paper goes on like this. Beyond the first paragraph of the introduction, I cannot confirm what the paper is trying to do. In fact, finally when I reached to the AI statement I saw the sentence "Human verification and author approval remain to be completed.", which is quite concerning. The authors do not seem to value the reviewers' and AC time.
Questions for authors
I am not sure what can be done to save this paper. I am not sure why there is a sentence "Human verification and author approval remain to be completed." in the AI statement. I would like to believe this was not intentional, but if authors read the paper they would have caught it. So the most logical explanation is that this paper was submitted without author verification.
I think the best suggestion is please do not submit AI assisted papers without author verification.