- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes MGSPRec, a multimodal sequential recommendation framework based on multi-granularity shared and private representation learning. Specifically, the model first introduces a behavior-guided modality representation optimization mechanism to refine multimodal features and construct modality relation graphs using collaborative signals. It then employs independent Transformer encoders to capture modality-specific sequential patterns and incorporates interest prototypes to enhance user preference representations.
Critical strengths
-
The paper is well organized, and the overall framework is clearly presented with a reasonable motivation for addressing multimodal interference and information redundancy.
-
The proposed method achieves consistent performance improvements over representative baselines across three datasets, demonstrating its potential effectiveness in multimodal sequential recommendation.
Critical weaknesses
1.The computation of the co-occurrence graph and its use in guiding modality relation construction are highly similar to the operations in SGP4SR. However, the methodology section does not clearly demonstrate the advantages of the proposed approach over SGP4SR, and the experimental section lacks targeted comparisons to validate these advantages.
2.The mathematical formulations are not sufficiently clear. For example, the computation of the individual loss terms in Equation (12) is not explicitly defined.
3.The ablation study is relatively coarse-grained. In particular, it lacks a variant that removes co-occurrence guidance while retaining the modality relation graphs, making it difficult to isolate the contribution of the proposed guidance mechanism.
4.The experimental evaluation lacks direct evidence demonstrating that the proposed model effectively addresses the three challenges identified in the motivation. Relying solely on improvements in overall recommendation performance is insufficient to substantiate these claims.
Questions for authors
I suggest adding more targeted experiments to directly validate the proposed motivations and dedicating more discussion to clarifying the differences between the proposed method and existing multimodal sequential recommendation approaches.