- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper designs a Simplex-Space Flow Matching (SS-FM) to learn probabilities of portfolio weights under market states, then uses PPO or GRPO to learn a policy to decide the concrete weights from the learned probability distribution.
The paper is poorly written, and the motivations, novelty, and logis are unclear. It is hard to see where the novelty is and why the proposed method can be better than the existing portfolio learning approaches. The experiments are compared with only a few standard policies but not state-of-the-art machine learning or deep/reinforcement learning approaches for portfolio selection and construction.
Critical strengths
None
Critical weaknesses
- The novelty and motivations are unclear. Neither learning a portfolio probability distribution nor a policy to determine the exact portfolio is new, and it is unclear how new and effective it is to combine these two together.
- The method description doesn't show clearly the novelty and contributions, and why the proposed method can be better than existing methods.
- The experiments are simple and not convincing. No state-of-the-art machine/reinforcement learning approaches in FinTech is included in the comparison. The parameter setting looks ad hoc and not systemtic. There are only two datasets, which is not comprehensive enough.
Questions for authors
- Where is the novelty of your proposed method? It looks like every component is existing.
- After the portfolio weight distribution has been learned, only is used to realise the actual portfolio. is also used in learning . Therefore, the overall end-to-end process can be seen as learning an actual portfolio, with as an intermediate output/layer. Please explain the differences.
- In the first learning stage, the MVO, MS, and RP portfolios are used as teacher portfolios. In machine learning, students cannot be better than teachers. Do you aim to learn portfolio distributions similar to MVO, MS, and RP rather than better than them? Please explain more clearly why use these teacher portfolios.
- How to set the number of assets K?
- How do the , , and operators in equations (7)-(9) work?
- How is in equation (18) represented?
- Why are the the number of generated candidates is G = 32 and transaction cost is 3 basis points in the experiments?
- Which time periods of the datasets were used? I saw the figures are from 2025-2026, which is very short. How about other years and periods?