- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents SwiftVMR, an MLLM-based framework for efficient video moment retrieval. It combines a visual token compressor (Z-MSC), a non-autoregressive distribution-based boundary head (DAPH), and a distillation strategy (DSSD) for a smaller student model. The authors evaluate localization accuracy on four benchmarks and report component ablations and inference latency measurements.
Critical strengths
- SwiftVMR combines visual token compression, distribution based boundary prediction, and student distillation in a coherent framework for video moment retrieval.
- It achieves competitive performance across four benchmarks, and the latency analysis provides evidence of substantial computational savings.
- The ablations cover the main components, while the student model experiments show that the framework can also benefit a smaller backbone.
Critical weaknesses
- The novelty of DAPH is insufficiently established. Prior MLLM work has used a specialized interval decoder or a distribution based time decoder, while Table 2(b) compares DAPH only with a Regressive Head and a variant without DFL. Z-MSC also lacks comparisons with other visual token compression methods under the same token budget.
- Table 1 does not cover several relevant recent methods and relies on results reported under different settings. On QVHighlights, the Avg. Pooling + Regressive Head baseline in Table 2 already slightly exceeds UniTime, while the full model provides a modest additional gain. Without matched training data, video sampling, and visual token budgets, the source of the reported advantage remains unclear.
Questions for authors
-
How does DAPH differ from prior distribution based time decoders such as DisTime? How do their accuracy and latency compare under the same backbone and training setup? [DisTime: Distribution-based Time Representation for Video Large Language Models]
-
Please compare Z-MSC with other visual token compression methods at the same frame count and visual token budget, reporting both accuracy and latency.
-
Why does the simple baseline in Table 2 slightly exceed UniTime on QVHighlights? Please clarify differences in training data, video sampling, and evaluation protocols, and quantify the gains from the proposed components under matched settings.
-
Can the authors compare with recent methods such as Invert4TVG, Divid, and GroundVTS? [Invert4TVG: A Temporal Video Grounding Framework with Inversion Tasks Preserving Action Understanding Ability] [Divid: Disentangled Spatial-Temporal Modeling within LLMs for Temporally Grounded Video Understanding] [GroundVTS: Visual Token Sampling in Multimodal Large Language Models for Video Temporal Grounding]
-
What is the performance of Avg. Pooling + [Text][Video] + DAPH, which is absent from Table 2? This configuration would isolate the gain from DAPH relative to Avg. Pooling + Regressive Head.