acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Faster Block-Diffusion Serving with Distribution-Free Risk Guarantees

Abstract

Block-diffusion language models are served at hand-picked operating points, such as acceptance thresholds, buffer depth, schedule, checkpoint and precision, and each point is chosen by its mean benchmark accuracy. However, a mean does not tell an operator how often a faster configuration fails on prompts that the slower one answers correctly. On the serving engine and its decode traces, the default commit rule already commits every fully resolved block, a static skip rule captures nearly all of the compute that allocation can save, and self-distillation on engine-decoded targets adds speed at unchanged accuracy. Larger speedups come from lower thresholds, which commit tokens that are still uncertain. We therefore present Redline, a finite-sample procedure that selects operating points, hand-picked or learned, from the correctness of their answers on calibration prompts. Redline keeps the reference-relative risk, the joint probability that the reference answers correctly and a candidate configuration does not, within a user-chosen budget with high probability, and deploys the fastest configuration that passes. It speeds up math at a smaller risk budget than code in both model families, and at a budget of ten percent it deploys a LLaDA2 math configuration that commits over a third more tokens in each forward. It also applies without modification to the acceptance rule of speculative decoding and to weight quantization. On the same calibration data, Redline stays within its stated failure probability, whereas each tolerance of a mean-accuracy rule either gains less speed for some model and task or exceeds the risk budget far more often for another. Code will be released upon acceptance.

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
block diffusion language models, parallel decoding, LLM serving, inference acceleration

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 27%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.00 over 3 reviews, above 27% of the others.
Reviewer_k6eFOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper presents Redline, a mechanism for selecting serving configurations for diffusion language models. Redline adopts a Learn-Then-Test framework using exact binomial p-values with Holm correction. At its core, Redline bounds reference-relative risk and deploys the fastest configuration that satisfies the specified risk requirement. Evaluations on LLaDA2 and SDAR show encouraging quality and efficiency improvements.

Critical strengths
  • The paper tackles an interesting and important problem without requiring additional training.
  • The statistical validation methodology is principled and straightforward.
  • The evaluation shows promising quality–efficiency trade-offs.
Critical weaknesses
  • The technical novelty appears incremental: Learn-Then-Test, exact binomial tests, Holm correction, and the negative-flip-rate loss are all established techniques.
  • The evaluation covers only two model families (LLaDA2-mini and SDAR-8B) and two domains (math and code), limiting the generality of the conclusions.
Questions for authors

Thanks for submitting your work. The problem is well motivated, and I found the statistical formulation clean. However, I am not yet convinced that the contribution goes substantially beyond applying Learn-Then-Test or hyperparameter tuning (e.g., BO) to a new setting. I also have concerns about whether the chosen risk measure fully captures practical serving quality and how broadly the results generalize.

  • The evaluated models are somewhat dated. LLaDA2.1 is cited but not evaluated, and experiments on newer diffusion LMs such as LLaDA2.2 and DiffusionGemma would strengthen the empirical case. This is particularly relevant because newer models such as DiffusionGemma adopt mechanisms intended to reduce sensitivity to decoding configurations.

  • Stronger baselines, including RSI-style approaches, would make the comparison more convincing.

  • The cost of Redline itself should be quantified. The calibration procedure appears to require evaluating every candidate configuration on every calibration prompt. How large is this one-time calibration cost, and how does it compare with the overhead of the baseline methods?

11 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer k6eF (1/7)

We thank the reviewer for finding the problem well motivated and the statistical formulation clean.

Before writing this response, we ran a number of new experiments for the reviews and restructured the paper around their results, which took much of the discussion period. We realize that little time remains, and we respectfully ask the reviewer to read our response and the new experiments.

Our answers in brief.

W1. Contribution beyond testing and tuning. Redline uses shared tests and loss to select faster serving configurations with a regression bound that tuning alone does not provide, and does not claim those components as new. The contribution is certified deployment beyond an empirical operating point (Section 4.2, Table 15, Appendix G).

W2. Evaluation breadth and serving quality. The evaluation includes additional diffusion families, TriviaQA and other serving methods and is not limited to the two main families. The broader tests therefore check practical serving quality alongside the failures that mean accuracy can hide (Section 4.1, Section 5.4, Appendices D.8, H.2 and H.9).

Q1. Newer diffusion models. Both suggested newer models gain speed at smaller budgets than the main grids. Reduced sensitivity permits those gains without making every published setting deployable (Appendix H.8, Table R7).

Q2. Stronger selectors. Redline gains more speed than Pareto Testing on the code grids, while Table 15 compares other selectors. The comparisons separate extra deployment from loss of regression protection (Table R3, Appendices H.6 and D.9).

Q3. Calibration cost. Calibration has a measured one-time serving cost shared by selectors using the same outcomes. Serving savings repay that cost at the reported request volumes (Table R6, Appendix H.4).

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer k6eF (2/7)

W1. What Redline adds to Learn-Then-Test or tuning.

The technical novelty appears incremental: Learn-Then-Test, exact binomial tests, Holm correction, and the negative-flip-rate loss are all established techniques.

However, I am not yet convinced that the contribution goes substantially beyond applying Learn-Then-Test or hyperparameter tuning (e.g., BO) to a new setting.

Answer. Redline uses Learn-Then-Test's exact binomial tests, Holm correction and the established negative-flip loss to bound fixed-model serving regressions without training across an unordered grid. These shared tests and loss are not the paper's claimed contribution. It studies how to select faster serving configurations with a regression bound that tuning alone does not provide.

Section 4.2 presents Redline as Learn-Then-Test [1] for serving, using the joint risk of Equation 1. Section 4.1 links it to the negative flip rate of model-update studies [2, 3], and Section 6 calls Learn-Then-Test our framework.

Section 5.3 measures removing each ingredient on SDAR math at α\alpha = 0.10.

Test choiceBudget exceedance
Net accuracy drop, same Holm step, betting p-valueJoint budget exceeded in 91.4% of splits against pooled risk, against 0.0% for Redline
Drop Holm correctionHeld-out exceedance rises from 3.4 to 17.5%
Also drop finite-sample margin of exact testRises to 64.1% (Table 15)
Redline across all sixteen grid-budget pairsUnder 7% held-out exceedance

Serving risk, multiple-testing correction and finite-sample margin are needed to prevent these budget violations.

Learn-Then-Test controls family-wise error for fixed hypotheses, leaving risk and tested set open. We identify and measure the serving choices and add four properties. The new lower panel of Table 18 lists all six beyond testing (Appendix G).

Redline bounds fixed-model serving's negative flip rate without training. Model-update studies lower it by training a new model (Sections 4.1 and 6). It tests every configuration with Holm because slower configurations still regress.

Slower configurationRegression rateTPFReference TPF
SDAR math acc99/semi708.4%3.093.85 (Appendix D.2)

A fixed sequence as in CALM [4] can stop at an out-of-order configuration (Appendix A.4).

Four properties follow. Risk between separate serving runs covers engine run-to-run variation (Appendix H.1). Forwards need no timing and rank timed configurations like GPU time at calibration batch caps (Appendices H.1 and H.7). A second bound covers the smallest speed-gaining budget (Section 4.2). Candidates come from serving-loop measurements, and one test covers thresholds, a distilled checkpoint, speculative-decoding acceptance and weight quantization (Sections 3, 3.2 and 5.4). These properties make the bound refer to actual serving outcomes and translate it into a choice of deployment.

Bayesian optimization optimizes a searched-data estimate without bounding its returned configuration. On other prompts it can propose Redline candidates (Section 6). Table 15 exhaustively evaluates grids of 7 or 8 configurations in two forms.

Exhaustive selectionResult
Fastest configuration with measured regression rate within budgetBudget exceeded in 28.9 to 64.1% of held-out splits on four grid-budget pairs
Mean-accuracy selectionLess gain on LLaDA2 math or budget exceeded in 71.1 to 72.4% of held-out splits on SDAR math at α\alpha = 0.10, against 3.4% for Redline (Section 5.3, Appendix D.9)

Exhaustive tuning alone gives no such risk guarantee.

The paper studies risk-controlled selection across measured serving configurations. This matters because tuning alone gives no regression bound, as Appendix G explains.

Part 5 compares CALM's fixed sequence and Pareto Testing's search before testing (Table R3).

References.

  • [1] Angelopoulos, Anastasios N., et al. "Learn then Test: Calibrating Predictive Algorithms to Achieve Risk Control." The Annals of Applied Statistics, 2025.
  • [2] Yan, Sijie, et al. "Positive-Congruent Training: Towards Regression-Free Model Updates." CVPR 2021.
  • [3] Xie, Yuqing, et al. "Regression Bugs Are In Your Model! Measuring, Reducing and Analyzing Regressions In NLP Model Updates." ACL 2021.
  • [4] Schuster, Tal, et al. "Confident Adaptive Language Modeling." NeurIPS 2022.
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer k6eF (3/7)

W2. Models, tasks and practical serving quality.

The evaluation covers only two model families (LLaDA2-mini and SDAR-8B) and two domains (math and code), limiting the generality of the conclusions.

I also have concerns about whether the chosen risk measure fully captures practical serving quality and how broadly the results generalize.

Answer. The evaluation tests serving across four diffusion families, three tasks and three serving methods, with one budget limiting regressions and net accuracy drop. It is not restricted to the two main families.

The submitted paper already extends beyond LLaDA2 and SDAR. The revised PDF adds both newer models and open-domain question answering.

ExtensionResult
Fast-dLLM-v2 on its own engine+15.3%, +25.0% and +47.4% TPF at α\alpha = 0.10, 0.15 and 0.20 (Appendix D.8)
Other serving methodsTypical acceptance of speculative decoding for two draft pairs, weight quantization with nf4 valid at α\alpha = 0.10 and 2.81x less weight memory (Section 5.4)
DiffusionGemma-26B-A4B, stopping-rule settingsFrom α\alpha = 0.05, at least +20.4% TPF and 14.3% lower mean latency (Part 3)
LLaDA2.2-mini mathFrom the same budget, +39.3 and +39.8% TPF, net accuracy changes +0.6 and -0.7 points
LLaDA2.2-mini codeSpeed Mode from 0.07, +41.6% TPF (Part 4, Table R7, Appendix H.8)
Open-domain TriviaQA1,000 questions, both families' general checkpoints at code-grid settings
LLaDA2.0-mini, acc85/semi70From α\alpha = 0.05, +19.6% TPF, 17.6% fewer forwards per request, net accuracy change -2.6 points
SDAR-8B-Chat-b32, acc85/semi90From 0.02, +33.9% TPF, 95% interval 32.5 to 35.4%, 25.3% fewer forwards, net accuracy change -0.7 points (Appendix H.9, Table 29)

The same procedure applies across the additional model, task and serving-method settings.

Risk counts prompts the reference answers correctly and the deployment does not, whatever it fixes elsewhere. It upper-bounds net accuracy drop (Section 4.1, Appendix H.2), while mean accuracy can conceal regressions.

Practical-quality or serving checkResult
LLaDA2.2-mini math, Speed ModeAccuracy 0.6 points higher, yet regressions on 3.8% of prompts (Table R7)
Deployed configurations, mean request throughputH100 +14.6 to +40.3%, SDAR calibration RTX A6000 +15.2 to +42.8% (Table R1, Appendix H.1)
LLaDA2, calibrated on H100 NVL and timed on H100 80GBEvery configuration below its budget against the reference of its round in every round
SDAR, three RTX A6000 cards with calibration engine build, settings and batch capEvery served output identical to calibration, same regressing prompts at a rate below budget (Appendices F.3 and H.1)
Hardware changeOne calibration (Section 7)
Re-calibration on H100 80GB, Table 2Faster configuration in all 10 grid-budget pairs where calibration hardware deploys one, same configuration in 8
SDAR code, α\alpha = 0.20, acc85/semi90Request throughput 26.8% higher on these cards (Appendix H.10, Tables 19 and 30)

Regression control adds information beyond average accuracy, and the served configurations also improve request throughput under the stated conditions.

The paper studies regression protection across models, tasks and serving methods alongside net accuracy and request-level speed. This matters because net accuracy can conceal failures on previously correct prompts, as Appendix H.2 explains.

Reviewer_tVVGOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
1
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper introduces Redline, a framework for selecting efficient language-model serving configurations under finite-sample, distribution-free risk guarantees. Rather than relying on average benchmark accuracy, the method controls reference-relative regression risk, defined as the probability that a candidate configuration produces an incorrect answer when the reference configuration is correct. Redline combines exact binomial hypothesis tests with Holm's multiple-testing correction to certify configurations and selects the most efficient certified option.

The authors evaluate the framework on two block-diffusion language-model families, LLaDA2 and SDAR, using mathematical reasoning and code-generation benchmarks. They also investigate three components of block-diffusion serving: self-distillation, computation allocation, and token commitment. Additional experiments demonstrate the applicability of the selection procedure to speculative decoding and weight quantization. The results suggest that regression-aware calibration can identify more efficient serving configurations while controlling a specified reference-relative quality risk.

Critical strengths

This paper proposes Redline, a framework to select faster language model serving configurations while keeping the quality risk under control. Instead of only looking at average accuracy, the method focuses on cases where the reference configuration gives a correct answer but the faster configuration gives a wrong one. This is called reference-relative regression risk. The method uses exact binomial tests and Holm's multiple-testing correction to check which configurations satisfy a given risk budget, and then selects the fastest one.

The authors test the method on two block-diffusion language model families, LLaDA2 and SDAR, using math reasoning and code generation tasks. They also look at three aspects of model serving, including self-distillation, computation allocation, and token commitment. In addition, they show that the same approach can be applied to speculative decoding and weight quantization.

Critical weaknesses

The main approach seems quite similar to existing methods like Learn-Then-Test and CALM. These methods already support multiple configurations and provide statistical guarantees. So I'm not entirely sure what is fundamentally new here, beyond applying existing techniques to model serving. I think the authors should explain more clearly what their new contribution is.

The paper mainly uses tokens per forward as the efficiency metric, but this doesn't necessarily mean faster inference. For example, in Table 4, the distilled model achieves higher TPF, but it also requires more forward passes and generates more tokens per request. The regression risk is also higher. So I'm not convinced that the method actually reduces latency or computational cost per request. I think the authors should provide a more direct comparison of end-to-end latency and GPU cost under the same conditions.

Questions for authors

What is the main novelty of Redline compared with existing methods like Learn-Then-Test and CALM?

In Table 4, the distilled model needs more forward passes and generates more tokens. Does it actually make inference faster?

Would the results change if you measured GPU cost per request instead of TPF?

In Figure 4, how do the experimental results support the theoretical guarantee on population risk?

Could you report the overall performance, including cases where the method falls back to the reference configuration?

Were all configurations fixed before calibration? And how do you justify the assumption that requests are independent when they are processed in batches?

11 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer tVVG (1/8)

We thank the reviewer.

Before writing this response, we ran a number of new experiments for the reviews and restructured the paper around their results, which took much of the discussion period. We realize that little time remains, and we respectfully ask the reviewer to read our response and the new experiments.

We thank the reviewer for raising this.

Our answers in brief.

W1, Q1. Contribution beyond the testing framework. Redline uses shared tests to bound serving regressions across an unordered grid, including variation between serving runs, and does not claim a new testing framework. The contribution changes which failures are protected and which settings can deploy beyond the shared testing step (Section 4.2, Table 18, Appendix G).

W2. Request latency and GPU cost. Every timed deployment is faster than its reference under matched conditions. The measured benefit is lower cost for each request even with longer answers (Table R1, Appendix H.1).

W2, Q2. Distilled checkpoint speed. The distilled checkpoint lowers timed latency against the reference and also improves on the base checkpoint at the same thresholds. Redline still tests the checkpoint's regression risk before deployment (Section 3.2, Appendices H.1 and H.7).

W2, Q3. Ranking by GPU cost. GPU-time measurements confirm request savings, and ranking by forwards preserves the guarantee. Changing the cost therefore selects for request efficiency without changing the protected risk (Appendix H.7).

Q4. Population-risk check. Figure 4 measures held-out and pooled exceedance over random calibration splits. It checks the predicted bound empirically alongside the proof (Section 5.5, Appendices A.2, A.3 and A.5).

Q5. Overall performance and fallback. Reported gains average every split with reference fallback counted as zero and do not exclude reference deployments. The averages therefore reflect retaining the reference when the budget requires it (Table R5, Appendix H.3).

Q6. Fixed grids and batched requests. Grids are fixed before calibration, and the guarantee assumes served prompts under the calibrated batching policy. The assumptions apply to served outcomes, and changed conditions require calibration (Section 4, Appendices F.3 and H.10).

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer tVVG (2/8)

W1, Q1. What Redline adds to Learn-Then-Test and CALM.

The main approach seems quite similar to existing methods like Learn-Then-Test and CALM. These methods already support multiple configurations and provide statistical guarantees. So I'm not entirely sure what is fundamentally new here, beyond applying existing techniques to model serving. I think the authors should explain more clearly what their new contribution is.

What is the main novelty of Redline compared with existing methods like Learn-Then-Test and CALM?

Answer. Redline uses the testing framework shared with Learn-Then-Test and CALM to bound serving regressions and net accuracy drop across an unordered grid, including variation between serving runs. This shared testing framework is not the paper's claimed contribution.

Section 4.2 introduces Redline as an instance of Learn-Then-Test [1] for serving, using the joint risk of Equation 1 instead of a marginal error rate. Section 6 calls Learn-Then-Test our testing framework and contrasts the serving choices with CALM [2].

Redline is more than either framework applied to model serving. It shares Learn-Then-Test's testing step and free choice among valid configurations (Section 4.2, Table 18). For a 0/1 loss, it shares the prompts counted by CALM's risk (Appendix G). It differs from Learn-Then-Test in what it bounds, and from both in which configurations it tests and what its risk covers.

Learn-Then-Test leaves the risk and tested configurations open while controlling family-wise error over fixed hypotheses. CALM fixes both for one early-exit threshold of autoregressive decoding, tested in a fixed sequence against the full model (Section 6). Our contribution identifies the risk and configuration set that fit serving, measures each choice and adds four further properties. The new lower panel of Table 18 lists all six.

First, Redline bounds the negative flip rate for serving configurations of a fixed model without training. Model-update studies [3, 4] lower this rate by training a new model. The same budget also bounds net accuracy drop (Sections 4.1 and 6).

Risk comparisonResult
Learn-Then-Test on net accuracy drop, same Holm step and betting p-value, SDAR math, α\alpha = 0.10Net drop within budget in every split, joint-budget exceedance in 91.4% of splits against pooled risk
Redline, all sixteen grid-budget pairsAt or under 0.2% pooled exceedance and under 7% held out (Section 5.3, Table 15)

The risk choice changes which failures are bounded, even under the same multiple-testing step.

The paper studies the risk and configurations that make regression protection apply to serving. This matters because one budget limits reference-relative regressions and net accuracy drop, as Appendix G explains.

References.

  • [1] Angelopoulos, Anastasios N., et al. "Learn then Test: Calibrating Predictive Algorithms to Achieve Risk Control." The Annals of Applied Statistics, 2025.
  • [2] Schuster, Tal, et al. "Confident Adaptive Language Modeling." NeurIPS 2022.
  • [3] Yan, Sijie, et al. "Positive-Congruent Training: Towards Regression-Free Model Updates." CVPR 2021.
  • [4] Xie, Yuqing, et al. "Regression Bugs Are In Your Model! Measuring, Reducing and Analyzing Regressions In NLP Model Updates." ACL 2021.
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer tVVG (3/8)

W1, Q1. Unordered configurations and further serving properties.

What is the main novelty of Redline compared with existing methods like Learn-Then-Test and CALM?

Redline also tests an unordered serving grid without stopping at out-of-order settings, while Pareto Testing reserves calibration prompts for search.

This part continues what Redline adds to Learn-Then-Test and CALM. After the risk of Part 1, the second choice that Learn-Then-Test leaves open is which configurations to test.

Configurations slower than the reference can still regress. We compare a fixed-sequence walk in design-threshold order and Pareto Testing on the same serving grids.

Configuration exampleRegression rateTPFReference TPF
SDAR math acc99/semi708.4%3.093.85 (Appendix D.2)

Risk does not follow speed order, so CALM's fixed sequence can stop at an out-of-order configuration. Holm needs no order (Appendix A.4).

Fixed-sequence result, Table 15Relative to Redline
LLaDA2 code at all three budgets from 0.10 to 0.20, SDAR math at 0.10Deploys less, by up to 7.0 points of mean TPF gain
LLaDA2 math at 0.05 and 0.10Deploys 0.1 point more
SDAR code from 0.10 to 0.20Deploys 0.8 to 3.8 points more
Held-out exceedance where it deploys moreAt least Redline's, reaching 16.2% on SDAR code at α\alpha = 0.15, against 4.1%

The fixed sequence deploys less in the stated cases, while its extra deployment has at least Redline's held-out exceedance. An unordered serving grid therefore needs a test that does not rely on threshold order.

Pareto Testing [5] splits calibration prompts and tests its front in sequence. Redline tests every configuration on every calibration prompt.

To compare Redline with Pareto Testing [5], we ran both on the 1,000 half splits of Table 15.

Table R3. Redline against Pareto Testing [5].

The comparison uses the 1,000 half splits of Table 15 and reports mean TPF gain %, fallback as zero.

Gridα\alpha = 0.15, RedlinePareto Testingα\alpha = 0.20, RedlinePareto Testing
LLaDA2 math37.537.437.537.5
LLaDA2 code24.720.640.235.2
SDAR math36.532.036.636.6
SDAR code25.824.046.941.7
LLaDA2 math, 50 configurations72.070.672.072.0
Pareto Testing comparisonResult
Equal split, all five grids of Table R3, α\alpha = 0.15 and 0.20Redline as fast or faster, by up to 5.2 points of mean TPF gain
α\alpha = 0.10, LLaDA2 math+36.6% against +24.5%
Same budget, SDAR math+8.3% against +5.4%
Same budget, grid of 50 configurations+50.5% against +31.5% (Appendix H.6)

Testing the full grid retains at least Pareto Testing's speed in the reported comparisons without reserving calibration prompts to search for a front.

Redline adds four further properties. Risk measured between separate reference and configuration runs also covers engine run-to-run variation (Appendix H.1). Forwards need no timing and rank timed configurations like GPU time at the calibration batch caps (Appendices H.1 and H.7).

A second bound covers the smallest budget at which a task gains speed (Section 4.2). Math gains speed at smaller budgets than code in both families (Section 5.2). Candidates come from the serving-loop measurements. Section 3 finds commitment already maximal and allocation within 1.3 points of its oracle. The remaining speed therefore comes from lower thresholds and new checkpoints. The same procedure covers thresholds, a distilled checkpoint, speculative-decoding acceptance and weight quantization (Sections 3, 3.2 and 5.4). The guarantee therefore covers measured execution across candidate types rather than only a calibrated early-exit threshold.

The paper studies selection on an unordered serving grid and further serving properties. This matters because the unordered test and serving-specific measurements address choices that a fixed threshold sequence does not settle, as Appendix G explains.

Reviewer_ykVJOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper introduces Redline, a distribution-free, finite-sample procedure that deploys the fastest configuration whose reference-relative risk it can keep within a user-chosen budget at a user-chosen confidence. Experiments on two block-diffusion model families across math and code tasks demonstrate efficiency gains under controlled reference-relative risk. Additional experiments extend the procedure to lossy speculative decoding and weight quantization, enabling risk-controlled improvements in token acceptance efficiency and memory usage, respectively.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper presents a simple and statistically principled framework for selecting efficient serving configurations under an explicit regression budget. Simultaneous risk control makes the subsequent cost-based selection well justified.

  2. The controlled engine analyses and experiments across block-diffusion serving, speculative decoding, and quantization provide useful evidence of the framework’s applicability.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Redline uses negative-flip risk as its quality constraint and selects the fastest candidate that passes certification. However, the practical motivation for prioritizing regression protection over accuracy remains unclear. The paper also lacks an intuitive comparison showing how much speed or overall accuracy may be sacrificed by imposing this constraint.
Questions for authors
  1. Does TPF adequately capture end-to-end speedup? A configuration may commit more tokens per forward yet generate longer responses, potentially offsetting the efficiency gain. Reporting end-to-end response latency would therefore provide a more direct measure of practical speedup.

  2. I am not entirely clear on the connection between Section 3 and the proposed method. How do these analyses inform Redline’s design, given that the configurations discussed could themselves enter its candidate pool?

  3. The experiments show that code tasks are more sensitive to lossy acceleration than math tasks. What might explain this difference?

8 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer ykVJ (1/5)

We thank the reviewer for noting that simultaneous risk control makes the cost-based selection sound.

Before writing this response, we ran a number of new experiments for the reviews and restructured the paper around their results, which took much of the discussion period. We realize that little time remains, and we respectfully ask the reviewer to read our response and the new experiments.

Our answers in brief.

W1. Regression protection and accuracy. The regression budget bounds failures on previously correct prompts and net accuracy drop, and does not replace accuracy protection. It protects previously correct prompts whose failures a mean can hide (Section 4.1, Appendix H.2).

W1. Cost of the constraint. The fastest configuration still deploys when certified, and otherwise Redline preserves more net accuracy. The comparison quantifies what protection costs in speed and accuracy (Table R2, Appendix H.2).

Q1. End-to-end speed. Every main-grid deployment increases throughput and lowers request latency, including longer answers. TPF gains therefore translate into measured request savings (Tables R1 and R4, Appendix H.1).

Q2. Role of Section 3. Its serving-loop measurements supply Redline's candidates and identify the risk their speed requires. The analyses therefore determine what is certified (Sections 3 and 4).

Q3. Code sensitivity. Changed code answers fail more often than changed math answers even at matched reference lengths. This matches execution-based grading's greater sensitivity to token changes (Appendix H.5).

W1. Why bound regressions as well as accuracy.

However, the practical motivation for prioritizing regression protection over accuracy remains unclear.

Answer. The regression budget bounds failures on prompts the reference answers correctly and also bounds net accuracy drop. It does not prioritize regression protection at the expense of an accuracy bound.

The risk RR upper-bounds net accuracy drop (Section 4.1). With probability at least 1−δ1-\delta, Redline's deployment loses at most α\alpha in net accuracy and regresses on at most a fraction α\alpha of prompts.

A regression is a prompt answered correctly by the reference and wrongly by the faster configuration. Its rate is the negative flip rate that model-update studies [1, 2] track (Section 4.1). In net accuracy, the prompts the faster configuration fixes offset these regressions.

ComparisonResult
SDAR math deployment, α\alpha = 0.10Regressions on 7.1% of prompts, nearly three times the net accuracy drop of 2.5 points (Section 5.3, Table R2)
SDAR math reference served again on its calibration GPU modelCorrect on the same prompts in a second serve and each of three further cards, changing none of these regressions (Appendix H.1)
Net-drop test with a betting p-value and the same Holm step, SDAR math, α\alpha = 0.10Net drop within budget in every split
Joint regressions under that testAbove 10% on 91.4% of splits, against 0.0% for Redline
TPF gain in that comparison+35.7% against +8.3% (Section 5.3, Table 15, Appendix H.2)
Both math grids, α\alpha = 0.15 and 0.20The two tests' mean deployed gains agree within 0.1 point (Table 15)

Testing net drop gives the weaker guarantee. Fixes can offset regressions and allow more deployment.

The paper studies how to bound failures on previously correct prompts, whatever the faster configuration fixes elsewhere. This matters because net accuracy can hide those failures, as Appendix H.2 explains.

This is the serving requirement in Section 4.1.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer ykVJ (2/5)

W1. What the regression budget costs.

The paper also lacks an intuitive comparison showing how much speed or overall accuracy may be sacrificed by imposing this constraint.

The speed and accuracy comparison in Table R2 gives the cost, with speed preserved in most pairs and more net accuracy preserved in the others.

We compare Redline with the fastest configuration of each grid and with an empirical-risk rule that gives no guarantee.

To compare speed and accuracy sacrificed by imposing the regression budget, Table R2 collects values for each grid's fastest configuration and Redline's deployment from Appendix H.2.

Table R2. What the regression budget costs.

The fastest configuration of each grid, with its pooled regression rate, beside the one Redline deploys, as TPF gain (%) / net accuracy change (points).

GridFastest, gain / change / regressionsRedline, α\alpha = 0.10α\alpha = 0.15α\alpha = 0.20
LLaDA2 math+37.5 / -4.0 / 7.2%+37.5 / -4.0+37.5 / -4.0+37.5 / -4.0
LLaDA2 code+42.4 / -13.1 / 15.7%reference+33.7 / -7.0+42.4 / -13.1
SDAR math+36.6 / -4.6 / 10.5%+13.1 / -2.5+36.6 / -4.6+36.6 / -4.6
SDAR code+59.7 / -14.0 / 17.8%reference+25.7 / -5.0+59.7 / -14.0

Redline keeps the fastest configuration where it is certified and otherwise deploys a slower configuration with a smaller accuracy drop.

ComparisonResult
Fastest configuration of each grid, Table R2No speed cost in 7 of the 12 grid-budget pairs
Other 5 pairsSlower deployment, losing 2.1 to 14.0 points less net accuracy (Table R2, Table 21)
Fastest configuration whose empirical risk on all prompts fits budgetSame deployment in 8 of the 12 pairs
That rule without any guaranteeBudget exceeded in up to 64.1% of held-out splits (Appendix H.2, Table 15)
Other four pairsThat configuration's empirical risk is 0.1 to 2.4 points under budget, within sampling error covered by the finite-sample guarantee
Fastest configurations' regression rates, in grid order7.2, 15.7, 10.5 and 17.8%
Sweep of 30 budgets from 0.01 to 0.30Fastest configuration deploys once the budget is 1.5 to 2.3 points above its regression rate
LLaDA2 code, α\alpha = 0.15+33.7% TPF at -7.0 points, instead of +42.4% at -13.1

The speed cost lasts only up to a small margin above the fastest configuration's regression rate. Redline deploys that configuration at every budget of Table R2 above its rate, and a slower configuration with smaller net drop below it.

The paper studies the speed and accuracy costs of regression protection. This matters because the constraint trades speed for regression protection only where certification requires it, with the retained accuracy quantified, as Appendix H.2 explains.

References.

  • [1] Yan, Sijie, et al. "Positive-Congruent Training: Towards Regression-Free Model Updates." CVPR 2021.
  • [2] Xie, Yuqing, et al. "Regression Bugs Are In Your Model! Measuring, Reducing and Analyzing Regressions In NLP Model Updates." ACL 2021.
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer ykVJ (3/5)

Q1. End-to-end latency and request throughput.

Does TPF adequately capture end-to-end speedup? A configuration may commit more tokens per forward yet generate longer responses, potentially offsetting the efficiency gain. Reporting end-to-end response latency would therefore provide a more direct measure of practical speedup.

Answer. No, TPF alone does not capture answer length, and every deployed main-grid configuration is faster when measured directly for each request.

To test whether longer responses offset TPF gains, we measured end-to-end latency by serving all prompts of each grid one at a time in both rounds.

Table R4. Mean end-to-end latency for each request.

Requests use batch 1, prefill without CUDA graphs, and one H100 card for each grid over all prompts and two rounds. Changes are against the reference, with their 95% paired-bootstrap intervals (Table 20).

GridConfiguration (deployed at α\alpha)ReferenceConfigurationChange
LLaDA2 mathacc85/semi70 (0.10 to 0.20)3.197 s2.570 s-19.6% (-23.0 to -16.1)
LLaDA2 codeacc85/semi90 (0.15)0.732 s0.569 s-22.2% (-27.7 to -15.3)
LLaDA2 codeacc85/semi70 (0.20)0.732 s0.549 s-24.9% (-29.0 to -20.6)
SDAR mathacc90/semi90 (0.10)1.668 s1.554 s-6.8% (-10.9 to -2.6)
SDAR mathacc85/semi70 (0.15, 0.20)1.668 s1.259 s-24.5% (-27.8 to -21.1)
SDAR codeacc90/semi90 (0.15)0.309 s0.269 s-12.8% (-19.9 to -5.9)
SDAR codeacc85/semi70 (0.20)0.309 s0.230 s-25.5% (-30.9 to -21.1)

Every deployment reduces end-to-end request latency, rather than merely committing more tokens for each forward. Every configuration that Table 2 deploys lowers mean end-to-end latency, and every 95% interval excludes zero.

Timed comparisonResult
All main-grid deploymentsMean latency reduction 6.8 to 25.5% (Table R4)
LLaDA2 math acc85/semi70, timed runs of Table R19.4% more tokens per request, 26.0% more requests in the same time, by committing in fewer forwards
That configuration, batch 1Mean request latency 19.6% lower (Table R4, Appendix H.1)
H100, calibration batch capsMean request throughput 14.6 to 40.3% higher, at least 12.0% in every round (Table R1, Appendix H.1)
Revised abstract, LLaDA2 math acc85/semi70, α\alpha = 0.10Reports 26% higher throughput

Longer answers do not erase the measured request-level gain. The configuration the reviewer describes can generate longer answers and still gain request speed.

The timed deployments improve request throughput and latency, including the longer-answer case.

Section 5.2 gives these throughput gains, batch-1 latency of every deployment and SDAR throughput on its calibration GPU. Table 19 pairs each configuration with its TPF gain and GPU time for each request, and Table 20 lists batch-1 latency.

Comments on the paper

6 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

General Response (1/5)

We thank the three reviewers. The reviews find the formulation clean and principled and ask for wall-clock evidence beyond TPF, what the regression budget costs, a sharper contrast with Learn-Then-Test, CALM and tuning, the cost of calibration, and newer models and tasks. The revised PDF answers each with new results (new Appendix H).

Our answers in brief.

Request speed beyond TPF. Every timed main-grid deployment serves requests faster, including longer answers. The gains therefore persist after accounting for answer length (Table R1, Appendix H.1).

Calibration conditions and hardware changes. Changed serving conditions require calibration, and repeated calibration retains faster deployments. The guarantee follows the calibrated environment, with measured savings that repay calibration (Section 4, Appendices H.4 and H.10).

Cost of regression protection. Redline retains the fastest configuration when certified and otherwise preserves more net accuracy. The budget limits failures that accuracy averages conceal, with its speed and accuracy costs quantified (Table R2, Appendix H.2).

Stronger selectors. Redline improves on Pareto Testing's speed in the code grids and bounds regressions left above budget by net-drop testing. The serving choices affect both deployment and protection (Table R3, Section 5.3, Appendix H.6).

Contribution beyond Learn-Then-Test and CALM. Redline uses shared tests to bound serving regressions without training across an unordered grid, including variation between serving runs, and does not claim a new testing framework. The contribution concerns which serving failures are bounded and which faster settings can deploy (Appendix G, Table 18).

Newer models and tasks. Redline selects faster settings on both suggested newer models and TriviaQA while excluding riskier settings at small budgets. The additional evaluations test its use beyond the main grids (Appendices H.8 and H.9).


Measured request speed.

Answer. Every timed main-grid deployment serves requests faster, including configurations that generate longer answers.

To test whether TPF gains translate into faster requests despite longer answers, we served deployed configurations against each round's reference at the calibration batch caps. The measurements use H100 cards and, for SDAR, RTX A6000 cards, averaged over three rounds.

Table R1. Deployed configurations and measured request costs.

Configurations deployed on the four main grids, served at the batch caps of the calibration runs, 16 on LLaDA2 and 8 on SDAR, on H100 cards and, for SDAR, on RTX A6000 cards, against the reference of the same round (mean of three rounds).

GridConfiguration (deployed at α\alpha)CardsTPF gain (Table 2)Request throughputGPU time for each requestTokens for each request
LLaDA2 mathacc85/semi70 (0.10 to 0.20)H100+37.5%+26.0%-20.6%1.094x
LLaDA2 codeacc85/semi90 (0.15)H100+33.7%+32.1%-24.3%0.985x
LLaDA2 codeacc85/semi70 (0.20)H100+42.4%+27.8%-21.7%1.081x
SDAR mathacc90/semi90 (0.10)H100+13.1%+19.8%-16.5%1.014x
SDAR mathacc85/semi70 (0.15, 0.20)H100+36.6%+40.3%-28.7%1.040x
SDAR codeacc90/semi90 (0.15)H100+25.7%+14.6%-12.7%1.000x
SDAR codeacc85/semi70 (0.20)H100+59.7%+30.4%-23.3%0.977x
SDAR mathacc90/semi90 (0.10)A6000+13.1%+19.3%-16.2%0.951x
SDAR mathacc85/semi70 (0.15, 0.20)A6000+36.6%+42.8%-30.0%0.953x
SDAR codeacc90/semi90 (0.15)A6000+25.7%+15.2%-13.2%1.071x
SDAR codeacc85/semi70 (0.20)A6000+59.7%+34.3%-25.6%1.133x

Every listed configuration of Table R1 raises request throughput, even where it writes longer answers. Each configuration raises throughput in every round, by at least 12.0%.

The request-level measurements and alternative cost ranking give the following results.

MeasurementResult
Mean end-to-end latency reduction, batch 16.8 to 25.5% (Appendix H.1)
Distilled checkpoint of Table 4, batch 1Mean latency 30.6% below the reference and 7.4% below the base checkpoint at the same thresholds (Section 3.2)
Ranking by forwards at the batch capsSame order as GPU time for the timed configurations of each grid, preserving 11 of the 12 main-grid deployments of Table 2
Changed deployment, LLaDA2 code at alphaalpha = 0.20acc85/semi90 serves requests faster in Table R1 and is 6.1 points more accurate, with the same guarantee (Appendices H.1 and H.7)

The request-level gains persist when answer length is counted, and the guarantee allows ranking by forwards.

The measured deployments reduce request cost as well as increasing token efficiency. Appendix H.1 reports the request-level measurements.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

General Response (2/5)

Calibration conditions and hardware changes.

Answer. The guarantee covers the hardware, engine build and batching policy of calibration, and a changed environment takes one calibration.

We checked served outputs against calibration outputs and repeated calibration on the new cards. On LLaDA2, calibrated on H100 NVL cards and timed on H100 80GB cards, each configuration stays below its budget in every round (Appendices F.3 and H.1).

Check or costResult
SDAR calibration and servingRTX A6000 cards, three cards with the grid runs' engine build, settings and batch cap, KV cache of 5,144 pages
SDAR served outputsEvery output identical to its calibration output, so the same prompts regress at a rate below budget
SDAR request throughputAt least 14.6% higher on every card (Appendix H.1)
New hardware or engine buildOne calibration, as Section 4 states
Main-grid calibration cost4,266 to 7,550 reference requests
Repayment wherever a faster configuration deploys16,183 to 47,371 served requests at alphaalpha = 0.10, 0.15 and 0.20
Selector overheadEvery selector of Table 15 needs this calibration, test and selection about 0.1 ms per budget (Appendix H.4)
Re-calibration on H100 80GBFaster deployment in all 10 pairs of grid and budget of Table 2 where the calibration hardware does, the same configuration in 8 (Appendix H.10, Table 30)

SDAR preserves the calibrated outputs under its calibration conditions, and re-calibration retains faster deployments on the new cards.

Serving conditions belong to the guarantee, and calibration cost can be repaid by the measured serving savings. Appendices H.4 and H.10 report the costs and re-calibration.


Cost of the regression budget.

Answer. The budget preserves speed where the fastest configuration is certified and otherwise protects more net accuracy.

To compare speed and accuracy sacrificed by imposing the regression budget, Table R2 collects values for each grid's fastest configuration and Redline's deployment from Appendix H.2. Each entry reports TPF gain and net accuracy change.

Table R2. What the regression budget costs.

The fastest configuration of each grid, with its pooled regression rate, beside the one Redline deploys, as TPF gain (%) / net accuracy change (points).

GridFastest, gain / change / regressionsRedline, α\alpha = 0.10α\alpha = 0.15α\alpha = 0.20
LLaDA2 math+37.5 / -4.0 / 7.2%+37.5 / -4.0+37.5 / -4.0+37.5 / -4.0
LLaDA2 code+42.4 / -13.1 / 15.7%reference+33.7 / -7.0+42.4 / -13.1
SDAR math+36.6 / -4.6 / 10.5%+13.1 / -2.5+36.6 / -4.6+36.6 / -4.6
SDAR code+59.7 / -14.0 / 17.8%reference+25.7 / -5.0+59.7 / -14.0

Redline keeps the fastest configuration where it is certified and otherwise deploys a slower configuration with a smaller accuracy drop.

Against the fastest configuration whose empirical risk on all prompts fits the budget, a rule without any guarantee, Redline matches 8 of these 12 cells. In the other four, that configuration's empirical risk is 0.1 to 2.4 points under budget. The extra certification requirement therefore affects configurations close to the empirical budget boundary.

A mean lets fixed prompts offset failed ones. The SDAR math configuration deployed at alphaalpha = 0.10 regresses on 7.1% of prompts, nearly three times its net accuracy drop (Section 5.3).

The regression budget bounds failures on previously correct prompts that net accuracy can conceal, and the comparison quantifies its speed and accuracy costs. Appendix H.2 carries the comparison.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

General Response (3/5)

The following parts compare Redline with three stronger baselines, Pareto Testing, Learn-Then-Test run on the net drop and a fixed-sequence walk as in CALM, state what Redline adds to Learn-Then-Test and CALM, and cover two newer models and a third task.

Comparisons with stronger selectors.

Answer. Redline gains more speed than Pareto Testing on the code grids and bounds regressions left above budget by net-drop testing.

To compare Redline with stronger baselines, we ran a new selector comparison on the same calibration splits, counting fallback as zero gain. Pareto Testing finds a risk and cost front on one part of each calibration half and tests it in sequence on the other.

Table R3. Redline against Pareto Testing [1].

The comparison uses the 1,000 half splits of Table 15 and reports mean TPF gain %, fallback as zero.

Gridα\alpha = 0.15, RedlinePareto Testingα\alpha = 0.20, RedlinePareto Testing
LLaDA2 math37.537.437.537.5
LLaDA2 code24.720.640.235.2
SDAR math36.532.036.636.6
SDAR code25.824.046.941.7
LLaDA2 math, 50 configurations72.070.672.072.0

Redline is as fast or faster in all ten cells, by up to 5.2 points. Searching a Pareto front before testing therefore gives no speed advantage on these grids.

Additional comparisonResult
Optimization fractions 0.2 and 0.3Redline faster or within 0.1 point
Held-out exceedance in these cellsBoth under 7%
alphaalpha = 0.10, LLaDA2 mathRedline +36.6%, Pareto Testing +24.5%
Same budget, SDAR math+8.3% against +5.4%
Same budget, 50-configuration grid+50.5% against +31.5% (Appendix H.6)
Learn-Then-Test [2] on net drop, SDAR math, alphaalpha = 0.10Same Holm step, betting p-value, net drop within budget in every split
Joint-budget exceedance against pooled risk in that comparison91.4% of splits, against 0.0% for Redline (Section 5.3, Table 15)

Controlling net accuracy drop can leave reference-relative regressions above budget, while Redline controls those regressions.

Redline retains regression protection beyond net-drop control while matching or exceeding Pareto Testing's reported speed. Appendix H.6 carries the Pareto Testing comparison.


What Redline adds to Learn-Then-Test and CALM.

Answer. Redline uses the testing framework shared with Learn-Then-Test and CALM to bound serving regressions without training across an unordered grid, including variation between serving runs. This shared testing framework is not the paper's claimed contribution.

Model-update studies [3, 4] lower the negative flip rate by training a new model. Redline bounds it below a budget for serving configurations of a fixed model without training, which also bounds net accuracy drop.

The risk is non-monotone in serving thresholds. A fixed sequence as in CALM [5] can stop at an out-of-order configuration, while Holm needs no order.

Fixed-sequence walk in design-threshold order, Table 15Result relative to Redline
LLaDA2 code, all three budgets from 0.10 to 0.20, and SDAR math at 0.10Deploys less, by up to 7.0 points of mean TPF gain
LLaDA2 math at 0.05 and 0.10Deploys 0.1 point more
SDAR code from 0.10 to 0.20Deploys 0.8 to 3.8 points more
Held-out exceedance wherever it deploys moreAt least Redline's, reaching 16.2% on SDAR code at alphaalpha = 0.15, against 4.1%

A fixed sequence can reduce deployment, and its extra deployment does not reduce held-out exceedance.

Measured between separate serving runs, the risk also counts run-to-run variation. A second bound covers the smallest budget at which a task gains speed. One test covers thresholds, a distilled checkpoint, speculative-decoding acceptance and weight quantization. The serving guarantee therefore accounts for repeated execution and spans candidate types beyond a single decoding threshold.

Bayesian optimization states no bound for the configuration it returns. Run on other prompts, it can generate candidates for Redline (Section 6, Table 18 in Appendix G).

The paper studies risk-controlled selection across serving configurations. This matters because one budget limits regressions and net accuracy drop without requiring an order on the configurations, as Appendix G explains.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.