- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
Targeting the one-step pMF generator, the paper proposes a post-training procedure that retrieves real-image candidates for each generated image, filters them by relative reward improvement, and selects the nearest eligible target in feature space.
Critical strengths
None
Critical weaknesses
[1] Performance is presented primarily through trajectory plots, without a consolidated numerical comparison.
[2] The algorithm is understandable, but Sections 4.1-4.2, Section 6.1, and Appendix D repeatedly discuss abstract interfaces and untested alternatives, including teacher-generated targets, human feedback, and alternative matching losses. These discussions could be condensed to prioritize implementation details and stronger experimental validation.
Questions for authors
[1] The “continual learning” terminology is not substantiated by the experimental setting. All experiments concern a single fixed ImageNet task, without changing tasks or domains, sequential knowledge acquisition, or retention and forgetting assessments.
[2] Black-box reward guidance, online supervision renewal, and generation-conditioned target search all have established precedents, making RCL appear primarily an engineering combination of existing techniques. What methodological novelty or nontrivial benefit does their combination introduce beyond prior approaches?
[3] Please report FID and Inception Score (IS) for both RCL and the pretrained pMF-H under the same evaluation protocol to assess how post-training affects generation quality and diversity.
[4] The composite matching objective lacks ablations justifying its MAE, DINOv2, Inception, LPIPS, and pixel components and their weights. The later deterioration in FD$r^6$ and increasingly similar backgrounds further motivate component-wise ablations and evaluation in feature spaces excluded from training to assess distribution drift and potential diversity loss.
[5] The paper lacks comparisons with DrPO, MeanFlowNFT, and DiffusionOPSD. Comparisons under matched backbones, rewards, and training budgets, are needed to establish RCL’s benefit beyond existing reward-guided post-training methods.
[6] Please ablate the preference thresholds and analyze how it affects target acceptance rates, the quality, diversity, and source compatibility of selected images, and the resulting preference-distribution trade-off.
[7] What value of is used? Please report it explicitly and provide ablations on both and the number of retrieved candidates .