acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

Token-axis Predictive Decomposition: What Information Does Each Token Add to the Hidden States of a Language Model?

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Interpretability research on large language models commonly relies on the decomposition along the layer axis provided by the architecture, . Along the token axis, however, the architecture provides no such decomposition. We decompose the hidden state at position into its expectation conditioned only on the past hidden states, , and the residual . Since the true conditional expectation cannot be computed, we approximate it with several predictors of different architectures and also examine how much the observed properties depend on the choice of predictor. At five layers of Pythia-410m-deduped, we evaluate this decomposition from three perspectives: temporal structure, linguistic information, and effect on the output. First, using a Transformer as the predictor reduces the squared error only slightly in the middle layers, but when the predictor aggregates the entire past, the autocorrelation of exceeds that of , while that of is nearly zero. Second, when linear probes trained on are applied unchanged to both components, attributes determined by the context (e.g., the document source) can be read out from and token-local attributes (e.g., noun number) from ; in deeper layers, the component that carries the attributes shifts toward . Third, the KL divergence of the next-token distribution when is replaced with is generally smaller for better predictors, and the output is more sensitive to reducing than to increasing it by the same amount. These results suggest that the predictive decomposition along the token axis, like the decomposition along the layer axis, can serve as a unit for analyzing internal representations.

Primary area:
interpretability and explainable AI
Keywords:
interpretability, large language models, hidden representations, residual stream, representation decomposition, linear probing, activation patching

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 2%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.33 over 3 reviews, above 2% of the others.
Reviewer_4JZfOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes a token-axis predictive decomposition of language model hidden states into a predictive component, estimated from preceding hidden states, and an innovation component defined as the prediction residual. Using Pythia-410M, the authors analyze their temporal structure, linguistic attribute decodability, and effects on the model's output distribution. The results show differences in temporal persistence and linguistic decodability between the two components, as well as asymmetric output sensitivity to scaling the innovation.

Critical strengths
  1. Well-defined token-axis analysis framework. The paper introduces a principled decomposition that separates information predictable from preceding hidden states from the remaining prediction residual. Unlike retrospective contextual decomposition, the predictive component is estimated without observing the current token.
  2. Interesting empirical observations. The analysis reveals consistent differences in linguistic decodability between the two components. In particular, the relative decodability of linguistic attributes shifts toward the predictive component in deeper layers, providing an interesting perspective on representation structure.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The interpretation of innovation is insufficiently validated. The true conditional expectation is approximated using finite-capacity predictors, so the residual may contain contextual information that the predictor fails to capture. Near-zero autocorrelation alone does not establish that the learned residual closely approximates the theoretical innovation. This limits the strength of the paper's interpretation of the two components.

  2. The significance of the empirical findings remains limited. Several observations, such as low innovation autocorrelation and the separation between context-dependent and token-local attributes, are broadly consistent with the proposed decomposition. Moreover, similar intervention asymmetry appears with simple baselines, including global-mean replacement and copying. While the framework is reasonable and the experiments are informative, it remains unclear what substantial new insights it provides beyond existing approaches such as TFA and PHi.

Questions for authors
  1. Does the residual retain information predictable from past hidden states? Are the findings robust to improved predictors?
  2. What insights does this decomposition uniquely provide beyond TFA and PHi, particularly regarding intervention asymmetry?
Reviewer_CxFmOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper aims to decompose language model hidden states along the token axis, analogous to the layer-axis decomposition given by the residual stream. At each position, the hidden state is split into a predictive component, defined as its expectation conditioned only on past hidden states at the same layer, and an innovation component, the residual, interpreted as the information added by the current token. The conditional expectation is approximated by trained predictors of increasing capacity, from simple predictors on the previous hidden state to causal Transformers on all past hidden states. On five layers of Pythia-410m-deduped, the authors find that the innovation component has nearly zero autocorrelation; that probes trained on the hidden state read context-level attributes from the predictive component and token-local attributes from the innovation component, with a shift toward the predictive component in deeper layers; and that replacing the hidden state with its prediction perturbs the next-token distribution less for better predictors, with the output more sensitive to shrinking the innovation component than to enlarging it.

Critical strengths

The main strength of this paper is its motivation. Interpretability work routinely relies on the layer-axis decomposition that the residual stream provides by construction, but no analogous decomposition exists along the token axis. Trying to put the two dimensions on equal footing, by separating what is already predictable from context from what the current token adds, is a well-motivated and worthwhile goal.

Critical weaknesses

Criticism 1: This entire investigation depends on the quality of the predictor. εt\varepsilon_t can only be interpreted as "innovation" from the latest token if the predictor is powerful enough to closely approximate E[ht∣h<t]\mathbb{E}[h_t \mid h_{<t}], i.e., to capture what is predictable from the preceding hidden states; otherwise εt\varepsilon_t also contains prediction error. Given that the best predictor reaches only R2≤0.50R^2 \le 0.50 (Table 1), this complicates the interpretability of the results. Moreover, even a perfect predictor conditions only on past hidden states at the same layer, which need not contain all the context information available to the model at that layer, so εt\varepsilon_t may still include context information rather than only what the latest token adds.

Criticism 2: While the original goal of the paper is well motivated, it is nevertheless not thoroughly executed, in my opinion. The layer axis allows one to investigate the evolution of information across many layers, since the per-layer increments compose: hL=h0+∑lΔhlh^L = h^0 + \sum_l \Delta h^l. However, the token axis, as it is constructed now, only admits a binary additive analysis: with or without the current token. Because h^t\hat h_t is a learned function of all of h<th_{<t} , the decomposition does not compose across positions, and hth_t cannot be attributed to the innovations of earlier tokens. More generally, one should investigate how information is progressively added throughout many token positions.

Criticism 3: The quantitative observations are largely trivial. More sophisticated predictors naturally result in better predictions of the hidden state, and hence higher R² and smaller KL when the hidden state is replaced. Similarly, the near-zero autocorrelation of the innovation component follows from the construction: the residual of a well-trained predictor is uncorrelated with the past hidden states, and therefore with earlier residuals. Likewise, context-level attributes are expected to be found in the predictive component, which by design cannot see the current token. As such, many of the results say less about autoregressive LLMs, and are more statements about these probes and predictors.

Questions for authors

In Transformers with causal masking, the layer and token axes are on unequal footing in the first place, which is why the authors must approximate the context-only component with a learned predictor. Have the authors considered applying their analysis to more recently developed LLMs, such as LLaDA (Large Language Diffusion Models; Nie et al., 2025), which are trained with token masking? There, masking the token at a given position is a native, in-distribution intervention, which could make it much easier to investigate the information carried by each token without relying on an approximate predictor. How would the authors expect their findings to transfer to such a setting, where the context is bidirectional?

Reviewer_Ymb5OpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
3
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes decomposing language-model hidden states into predictable and unpredictable components to study their temporal structure, linguistic information, and effects on model predictions. The framework is evaluated on Pythia-410M.

Critical strengths

The paper presents a clear and systematic application of predictive decomposition to token-level hidden representations, examining their temporal, linguistic, and functional properties through multiple predictor architectures and controlled experiments.

Critical weaknesses

1. Limited novelty and unclear scientific contribution

The paper fails to demonstrate novel insights into language-model behavior or establish a concrete interpretability benefit. The significance of the proposed framework and its advantages over existing approaches remain unclear.

2.Temporal-structure findings are largely expected by construction

The near-zero autocorrelation of the innovation component follows from the orthogonality properties of ideal conditional-expectation residuals. While the authors use learned approximations and a median-based measure, this behavior remains theoretically expected. The higher autocorrelation of the predictive component is not mathematically guaranteed, but its significance is not established through appropriate statistical controls. Consequently, the novelty of the first stated contribution is limited.

3.Linguistic-information findings may reflect already-known contextualization effects

The observation that linguistic attributes increasingly favor the predictive component in deeper layers is consistent with the established role of deeper Transformer layers in integrating contextual information. Although the precise trends are empirical, the paper does not demonstrate that they reveal a new phenomenon rather than expected contextualization. Comparisons with standard layer-wise probing and context-only baselines are needed to substantiate the second contribution.

4. Lack of comparative evaluation and generalization

The paper provides no experimental comparisons with existing interpretability methods and evaluates only Pythia-410M on short sequences from its training corpus. This limits the evidence for both the framework's advantages over existing approaches and its generalizability to larger models, different architectures, and longer contexts.

Questions for authors

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.