- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper investigates the bypass effect in distilled reasoning models, which describes the phenomenon where a model produces a correct final answer despite containing uncorrected errors within its chain-of-thought reasoning. The authors observe this phenomenon via two approaches: manually injecting errors and auditing natural errors spontaneously generated by the model. A keyword marker detector and an LLM judge are adopted to classify bypass cases, and human annotation validation is used to evaluate classification agreement. The experiments mainly cover DeepSeek-R1 distilled models of varying sizes, involving mathematical and logical reasoning tasks. Experimental results show that the prevalence of the bypass effect depends on task type; simply scaling up model size does not substantially reduce the conditional bypass rate. The experiments reveal that models can derive the correct answer in the generation phase after the end of the thought block. A reduction in bypass rate is also observed in the RL post-trained models tested in the work.
Critical strengths
-
The paper defines the bypass rate and conditional bypass rate, which respectively measure the fraction of bypass cases among all samples and the proportion of samples with uncorrected errors among all samples yielding correct final answers. The definitions distinguish whether errors within the chain of thought are corrected and whether the final answer is correct. The authors employ a keyword marker detector and an LLM judge to categorize different outcomes, and perform human verification on sampled cases to check the agreement of classification results. This provides relatively clear definitions and measurement pipelines for the bypass effect.
-
The work considers both artificially injected errors and natural errors produced by the model itself. By auditing validated natural arithmetic errors, the paper examines whether the bypass phenomenon only exists in artificially constructed error settings, which supplies additional empirical evidence.
-
The paper uses attention interventions and interruption tests during the answer generation of reasoning models, to investigate whether the correct answer in bypass cases is re-derived inside the answer block. Furthermore, the authors compare distilled models with their corresponding RL post-trained versions and observe a reduced bypass rate in the latter. These experiments analyze the behavioral characteristics of the bypass effect to some extent and explore potential mitigation strategies for this phenomenon.
Critical weaknesses
-
Prior work has already investigated the phenomenon where reasoning models produce correct answers despite perturbed chain-of-thought reasoning or unfaithful rationales. Although this work defines clear metrics for the bypass effect, accounts for natural errors, conducts behavioral interventions and performs RL post-training experiments, it remains unclear what novel insights these incremental contributions deliver beyond prior work. The paper has not sufficiently illustrated how these additional analyses substantially change our understanding of this phenomenon, nor their concrete implications for the evaluation of reasoning models.
-
Classification of bypass cases relies on judgments of error-correction behavior, and the keyword marker detector and LLM judge may yield divergent classification outcomes. While the authors evaluate classification agreement via human annotations, the audit of natural errors is largely restricted to arithmetic errors, and the associated human-validated sample size is relatively small. Moreover, the comparison between fixed-position injection and injection at natural-error positions uses different item subsets. Thus, the observed differences may be affected by sample composition and cannot be fully attributed to the error injection position itself.
-
Comparisons between the distilled model and its RL post-trained counterpart show a substantial drop in bypass rate for the latter. However, current experiments do not conduct precise attribution for this observation. Differences in RL training data, prompt sets and post-training configurations can all influence the results. The paper notes that control experiments with continued SFT on identical prompts may help disentangle these competing explanations, yet such experiments are not provided. Therefore, the present results only support a correlation between RL post-training and reduced bypass rate, and the exact cause driving this change cannot be confirmed.
Questions for authors
-
In Table 7, the comparison between fixed-position injection and injection at natural-error positions uses different subsets of problems. Could the authors explain the criteria for selecting these two groups of samples, and whether compositional differences between the samples affect the observed differences in "bypass" rates? Could paired analysis on a shared subset of problems be provided to better disentangle the effects of injection position versus sample composition?
-
The results presented in the paper show that "bypass" rates drop substantially after post-training with RL on distilled model checkpoints. However, existing experiments do not fully disentangle the exact source of this change. Could the authors further elaborate on the concrete differences between the RL post-trained models and the original distilled models in terms of prompt sets, training data, and training configurations? To what extent can the observed reduction in "bypass" rate be attributed to RL post-training itself?
-
The paper conducts experiments mainly on the DeepSeek-R1 distilled model family, with tasks largely limited to mathematical and arithmetic reasoning. Could the authors generalize the conclusions of this work to other model families and a broader range of reasoning tasks?
5 comments
Reply to Reviewer cSMb (2/2)
Q1. Paired analysis on a shared subset
Done (Sec. 4.5, Table 7). Every row uses validated errors and is paired by item. The rows for the 7B distill on GSM8K (marker; bypass rate on the model's own errors and on injected errors, same items):
| Injected at | Items | Own errors | Injected errors | Difference (points) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Token 40 | 54 | 8.3% | 22.7% | +14.4 [+5.9, +23.6] |
| Position of a validated own error | 28 | 5.4% | 26.8% | +21.4 [+8.0, +35.7] |
| Token 40, the same 28 items | 28 | 5.4% | 27.7% | +22.3 [+10.1, +36.3] |
Redoing Table 7, we found two faults in the row we had reported for the position-matched arm. Its natural rate included error flags that had not passed validation. And its injection positions came from an older version of the verifier, so only 28 of the 52 validated items were injected at a validated error. We therefore withdraw the claim that matching the position of the natural error closes the gap. Appendix E gives the details.
Position still matters for injected errors on their own. Over all 450 items of that arm, moving the injection to token 40 raises bypass by 4.9 points [+1.8, +8.1].
Q2. How the RL post-trained models differ from the distills, and how much is due to RL
- Training. Skywork-OR1-7B starts from the DeepSeek-R1-Distill-Qwen-7B checkpoint and is trained with rule-based RL on about 105K math and 14K code prompts (Sec. 3.5). Appendix N gives the stated recipe of every added model.
- Behavior. The difference is in how often the short form of think block is used. Skywork-OR1-7B writes one in 13.0% of its GSM8K traces, the distill in 81.2%. Within short-form traces it bypasses as often as the distill (69.0% against 62.4%). Forcing its first word to "First," raises its bypass from 18.0% to 70.7% (Table 3).
- Other post-trained models show the same pattern (Figure 2a, Table 11). The two made by further SFT stay at their parent's rate (+0.2 and -0.9 points). The three whose post-training includes RL are lower (17.4%, 37.8% and 21.2%), each in step with its share of short-form traces.
- How much is due to RL itself. We cannot say, and the paper does not claim it. What the control shows is that supervised training on the RL model's traces is sufficient to produce its rate (W3).
Q3. Other model families and tasks
- Families. We added ten public models (Sec. 3.5, Table 11). The five from other pipelines bypass at most 0.4%. They include two SFT students of DeepSeek-R1 made by other groups and two Qwen3 models. So the finding does not generalize to distillation at large, and the paper no longer says it does. It holds along one lineage: the six distills and the six models post-trained from them bypass 49.9 to 69.0% within short-form traces.
- Tasks. On AIME and BBH nearly every think block is long-form, and bypass is low (about 2 to 10%). A bare-prompt rerun on AIME gives 1 bypass trace of 60. This agrees with the form account. We also say that the task comparison cannot test it separately, because BBH was not rerun with a bare prompt.
We hope this answers your concerns, on novelty in particular. If it does, we would be grateful if you would consider raising your score. If something is still open, please tell us what it is, and we will address it in the remaining days of the discussion.
Dear Reviewer cSMb, a short reminder that the discussion closes for authors on 18 November. If something is still open after our response, on novelty or on the paired analysis in particular, please tell us and we will address it before then. Thank you for your time.
Reply to Reviewer cSMb (1/2)
Thank you for the detailed review. We answer in your order. Section and table numbers refer to the revised PDF.
W1. What is new beyond prior work, and what follows for evaluation
Table 1 (Sec. 2) places the paper against the six closest studies. Our contribution beyond them has three parts.
For evaluation (Sec. 5, Sec. 4.6):
W2. Detectors, scope and sample size
W3. RL attribution
We agree: the evidence supports a correlation only. The submission called the result a comparison of checkpoints, not a property of the RL objective, but its abstract and section heading read more strongly. Both are reworded, and Limitations calls the comparisons observational.
We added a control with supervised fine-tuning on fixed prompts (Sec. 4.6, Table 12). Every arm uses the same recipe, the same 1,800 GSM8K training problems and 339 updates.
So supervised training on traces is sufficient to move the rate either way. This does not isolate what the RL objective contributes, and the paper says so.