- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
scMeanFlow uses an NBAE, MeanFlow and FiLM for efficient scRNA-seq generation. NB-AE is used for learning representations while preserving the discrete count generation ability. MeanFlow is used for one step generation. FiLM is used for condition information fusion. scMeanFlow showed competitive performance on generation quality and efficiency, compared with other baselines. The authors also demonstrate scMeanFlow's performance on multi-condition generation and rare-cell data augmentation tasks.
Critical strengths
- By combining several existing techniques, the model achieves over 45x speed compared with diffusion-based baselines.
- The author conducted comprehensive evaluation on several datasets, using statistical metrics, marker gene validation, and race-cell classification.
Critical weaknesses
-
Limited novelty. NB-AE has been widely used in several works, including the scVI series and recent generation frameworks such as scDiffusion-X. Meanflow is used without substantial modification. FiLM is also an established method and shows relatively small improvements in the ablation study.
-
Insufficient motivation. The primary advantage is generation speed, but it is hard to say that generation speed is a meaningful bottleneck. Even the slowest method generates 10000 cells within 110s.
-
Most experiments focus on reproducing observed distributions, while the only downstream application is rare-cell classification, where the method is compared only against bootstrap resampling rather than competing generative models.
Questions for authors
- Can the author compare MeanFlow with standard Flow Matching using the same latent representation and backbone?
- How should the library size in Equation (10) be set during generation? How does this choice affect the generation results?
- Why does scDiffusion show a very poor marker gene expression correlation on PBMC 68k (Table 2) but outperform scMeanFlow on the same metric on Dentate Gyrus (Table 5)?
- How does the author unify discrete and continuous generated expression values from different methods?