- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper constructs a dynamic multi-relational graph in which aircraft are represented as nodes connected through four types of relations: spatial, kinematic, intent, and order. The framework is designed for two region-specific prediction tasks. The experiments are comprehensive, and the proposed relations have clear practical interpretations. However, the methodological novelty is limited, as the framework mainly combines existing graph learning techniques.
Critical strengths
- Using aircraft states to predict future regional demand is meaningful compared with traditional time-series prediction, as it allows the model to capture interactions among aircraft.
- The four types of relations including spatial, kinematic, intent, and order have clear physical meaning.
- The experiments are comprehensive and demonstrate substantial effort.
Critical weaknesses
-
The methodological innovation is limited. The multi-relation graph, relation-specific message passing, attention gating and task-conditioned pooling are all established techniques, and the proposed framework mainly combines them. For ICLR that clearly expects algorithm or method novelty, authors may consider incorporate physical constraints into the evolving graph relations to better reflect aircraft interactions. I would encourage the authors to consider submitting this work to a domain-specific journal, where its practical contributions may be better appreciated, rather than ICLR, which places greater emphasis on methodological novelty.
-
The authors primarily use adjacency matrices to construct a supergraph. However, the edges weights can carry important information. Adding physical constraints to model relation dynamics on edges could improve the novelty.
-
The four types of relations are constructed according to the predefined rules in Table 6. These rules are reasonable domain knowledge, but extensive sensitivity analysis is not particularly necessary or informative. introducing some mechanisms for adaptive relation construction would be more suitable for a submission to ICLR.
Questions for authors
see weaknesses
2 comments
Thanks for your reply. I will keep my assessment.
Thank you for your time and insightful comments
Thank you for taking the time to review our work. We will give your suggestion of a domain-specific journal serious thought. We are also grateful for your concrete suggestions on incorporating physical constraints into the graph and learning relations adaptively.
We especially appreciate the care you took in considering where this work might find a receptive audience. Kind regards.