- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
It is not fully clear to the reviewer what exactly this submission is trying to achieve. The abstract is rather cryptic. It is clear that the authors are trying to include some principles of photonic dynamics into the process of recurrent computations commonly used in some associative memories (it is not clear either from title, abstract or EVEN introduction, which type of associate memory authors are working with). The reviewer does not really understand what the study is trying to do based on its introduction (e.g., "Higher-order associative memories make this question concrete." but what is the question?) and does not find it possible to comment on authors's contributions.
Critical strengths
The starting point of the paper is interesting: whether optical projections can be a useful part of an associative memory with recurrent computations.
Critical weaknesses
Based on both the initial assessment of the reviewer and on the self-assessment provided in “AI Use Statement”, the paper appears to be almost entirely AI-generated, which explains why it is nearly unreadable (not in terms of language but it terms on being a piece of academic writing).
Questions for authors
Based on the text in connection to “AI Documentation For Reviewing” panel, the reviewer's interpretation is that they are softly discouraged to use any AI tools during the review process. When this observation is combined with the earlier conclusion that the paper was created almost entirely by AI, the reviewer does not find it neither necessary nor fair to spend a significant amount of their own time formulating questions to the authors, especially, considering the authors' limited involvement into the process of conducting the research reported in the paper.
2 comments
The reviewer would like to thanks authors for the rebuttal and for having considered the highlighted weaknesses and questions.
We appreciate the reviewer's concern about the accessibility of the central idea. We have comprehensively revised the manuscript's abstract, introduction, method overview, and discussion to state the task and contribution before introducing the hardware and auxiliary experiments.
Task. We store image representations in an associative-memory bank and recover the corresponding identity and continuous image reconstruction from a corrupted cue. A recurrent higher-order energy layer compares the evolving state with stored memories, strengthens higher-order compatibility, and updates the state. A memory-conditioned radial readout restores the magnitude required for image decoding.
Research question. How should the recurrent dynamics be learned when inference ends after a prescribed number of feedback steps? The key result compares a four-step-trained memory with its own fixed point:
At P=128, the finite execution horizon provides 5.31 dB higher PSNR. The same model is evaluated at both depths, and state/gradient-convergence diagnostics confirm that the fixed-point computation is being approached as iteration continues. The training-depth controls also show how the preferred execution depth moves with the learning horizon.
Presentation changes. The abstract opens with this task; the introduction states the execution-budget question and quantitative result; Figure 1 identifies the optical projection and electronic recurrence operations; and the detailed mathematical and photonic design choices follow in the method. The conceptual system illustration is placed in the appendix. The related controls are grouped by their explanatory role: interference and basins, reconstruction scale, finite-depth training, and physical sensitivity. We have proofread the full main text and supplementary material for terminology, transitions, and correspondence between each claim and its table or figure.
AI-assisted preparation and provenance. The manuscript retains a detailed AI Use Statement describing brainstorming, implementation, experimental design, drafting, and the two conceptual illustrations. The quantitative figures and image panels are linked to retained model outputs and experiment records; the updated paper identifies the modeling assumptions behind its optical controls. The authors are responsible for validating the computations, experimental records, citations, and final scientific conclusions.
We thank the reviewer for prompting a clearer, more direct presentation of the work.