- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes SpikeUAV-DETR, an end-to-end spiking detector for object detection in UAV imagery. Built on RT-DETR, the method introduces temporal–channel adaptive multi-level integrate-and-fire neurons (AT-LIMF), high-resolution cross-layer feature fusion, and gated semantic enhancement modules (S2FD/CSGF). It also adopts SNN–ANN hybrid structures for query selection and deformable attention. The method is evaluated on the VisDrone2019-DET and UAVVaste datasets, with detection accuracy, theoretical energy consumption, and inference speed reported, along with component ablation studies and NMS-threshold sensitivity analysis. In the experiments, the T=3 configuration achieves 46.0% mAP@50 on VisDrone2019-DET, and 49.0% mAP@50:95 and 80.4% mAP@50 on UAVVaste, with an inference speed of 65 FPS.
Critical strengths
-
The paper reports detection accuracy, theoretical energy consumption, and inference speed on two UAV image datasets, and compares the method with ANN and SNN detectors, providing quantitative results across multiple performance metrics.
-
The paper uses AT-LIMF, S2FD/CSGF, and SNN–ANN hybrid modules to address spike information encoding, fine-grained feature preservation, and accuracy-sensitive operations, respectively. Ablation experiments further quantify the effects of each module on mAP, energy consumption, parameter count, and FPS.
Critical weaknesses
- The proposed method does not appear to be spike-driven. As shown in Fig. 2, CSGF contains a Sigmoid activation function. Moreover, the use of ANN–SNN hybrid modules contradicts the claim that the method is spike-driven. To my knowledge, Deformable Attention also involves floating-point operations arising from bilinear interpolation.
- Does each block in Fig. 2 have an AT-LIMF module before it? If so, the annotation below Fig. 2 is problematic. If not, then the network is fully ANN-based.
- Since the proposed method is a hybrid network, I believe its energy consumption cannot be calculated simply by following the practices used in other SNN papers. ANN and SNN components cannot run simultaneously on a chip supporting spike-driven computation; otherwise, the efficiency of the SNN would be substantially compromised. Therefore, the proposed method would need to run its SNN component on a neuromorphic chip and its ANN component on a conventional GPU or another edge-computing device, which would introduce additional I/O costs. The authors should include these costs in their inference-cost analysis.
Questions for authors
See Weakness, if authors can resolve my concerns or correct my misunderstandings, I will revise my score.
Dear authors, the AC has reminded us reviewers to respond to your rebuttal. If there is anything you would like to clarify or discuss, please leave a comment here, and I will respond as soon as possible.