- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
MAPLE extends predictive latent learning from visual tool-use trajectories to multilingual settings, adding a cross-lingual consistency objective while preserving standard tool-free inference. Experiments across multilingual visual perception benchmarks and several VLM backbones report improvements in accuracy and cross-lingual consistency.
Critical strengths
The paper reports substantial improvements in multilingual accuracy and consistency across several backbones. The component ablations and correct-consistency evaluation provide useful evidence that these gains extend beyond simply producing identical answers across languages.
Critical weaknesses
- Limited methodological novelty over Pearl. Predictive trajectory alignment, next-latent regularization, prediction tokens, and the inference procedure closely follow Pearl (Adhikari and Lapata, 2026). The main additions are multilingual supervision and cross-lingual consistency. The paper does not sufficiently establish a substantive methodological insight beyond this extension, which limits its significance despite the empirical gains.
- The added objective is insufficiently characterized. Table 4 supports the usefulness of CLLC, but its advantages over alternative cross-lingual alignment objectives and its interaction with trajectory learning remain underexplained. Additional training costs and effects on broader VLM capabilities are also unclear, limiting assessment of the extension’s practical value and wider applicability.
Questions for authors
- Does the “w/o CLLC” variant faithfully reproduce Pearl with the same multilingual data and training budget? What implementation or tuning differences remain?
- Which objectives are retained in , and why do its reported results exactly match SFT? Does this comparison isolate the contribution of cross-lingual alignment without trajectory prediction?
- What additional training time and memory does CLLC require? Is there evidence about its effects on general VLM capabilities beyond the evaluated perception tasks?
As the discussion period is approaching the end and the authors do not give a response to my concerns, I will keep my rating as weak rejection.