acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

T-MOG: Temporally Structured Multi-Objective Guidance for Text-to-Image Diffusion Models

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

High-quality text-to-image generation must satisfy multiple objectives, including semantic consistency and aesthetic preference. However, existing multi-objective guidance mainly assigns weights across objectives by introducing multiple rewards at each step, implicitly assuming all objectives remain useful throughout generation. This parallel modeling overlooks the coarse-to-fine dynamics of diffusion, where semantics and spatial structure are usually established early, while local details are refined later. Thus, it remains underexplored whether different objectives should continuously participate in optimization. Continuous joint optimization may cause conflicts within the same stage and allow later detail refinement to disrupt earlier semantic structures. To address this, we propose T-MOG(Temporally Structured Multi-Objective Guidance), a training-free multi-objective guidance framework with temporal decoupling. Unlike existing methods that focus on coordinating objectives simultaneously, T-MOG redefines multi-objective guidance from an orthogonal perspective. It adaptively determines when and in what order different objectives should be optimized according to diffusion dynamics. Specifically, it dynamically selects the most suitable guidance objective for each generation stage, enabling each objective to act when most effective. We further introduce a cross-stage memory protection mechanism that monitors the influence of a new objective’s guidance direction on previous objectives after switching. It suppresses updates that may degrade earlier gains, thereby balancing new-objective improvement with the preservation of prior optimization. Comprehensive experiments demonstrate that T-MOG consistently delivers more balanced joint improvements than single-objective guidance and static reward fusion while preserving previously optimized objectives.

Primary area:
learning on time series and dynamical systems
Keywords:
Diffusion Model

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 2%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.33 over 3 reviews, above 2% of the others.
Reviewer_WEykOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
3
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

In this paper, the authors proposed a method called T-MOG for generative models which treats a multi-objective guidance problem as temporally ordered optimization process based on stage-wise effectiveness along the generation trajectory. They also proposed a cross stage objective protection mechanism that solve the problem of two conflicting objectives. Experiments showed that the proposed T-MOG method has better PickScore and SigLIP compared to baseline, DyMO, FMRG, and rewardFlow.

Critical strengths

The structure of the paper is well-designed and the idea is clearly expressed to the readers. The experiments support the authors' viewpoint about the proposed method: stagewise reward optimization works better than reward fusion.

Critical weaknesses

The idea of switching rewards temporally is not new and there are many similar works, for example, DyMO, MULTITUNE: PHASE-AWARE MULTI-OBJECTIVE TUNING FOR DIFFUSION MODELS.

The claimed cross-stage objective protection mechanism in section 2.3 is also a well-known optimization technique. The proposed method is more like empirical and it has no theoretical promise that it is better. I am worried that it is hard to be generalized.

It is hard to get any information from figure 4. Figure 5 and 6 is a little bit confusion and need more explanation. The Rank column in Table 1 is also confusing, does it mean with lower values ranked better. My understanding is that Rank=1 means the Ours beats all the others.

Some minor issues: 1.In line 191, before “where m denotes”, it should be a comma. 2.Equation (8) ends with a comma because the sentence is still going on. 3.In Line 429, “LVM judge”, what is the full name of LVM, also MLLM. I guess it is language-visual-model, and multimodal-large-language model. But it is always better to write the full name at the first position it appeared.

Questions for authors

In this article, the autos only considered the case for two objectives, what if there are more than 2 objectives, like semantic alignment, perceptual fidelity, localized grounding, object consistency, human preference and so on at the same time. Can this method be generalized easily and will it still have better performance compared to the baselines? More experiments may be needed to prove the efficiency of the proposed method.

Reviewer_bDzGOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes T-MOG, a training-free multi-objective guidance framework for text-to-image diffusion models. The method adaptively switches between structure-oriented and preference-oriented rewards according to the denoising trajectory and introduces a cross-stage protection mechanism that combines gradient projection and reward-based update rejection to mitigate conflicts between objectives.

Critical strengths

The paper addresses a relevant problem in multi-objective diffusion guidance. Considering the temporal effectiveness of different rewards and attempting to preserve earlier optimization gains during later refinement is intuitively reasonable. The experiments cover several diffusion backbones and show promising improvements in balancing semantic alignment and visual preference.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Limited methodological novelty. The central idea of scheduling different objectives across diffusion stages is closely related to existing dynamic multi-objective guidance methods, particularly DyMO. Moreover, the proposed cross-stage protection largely relies on standard gradient projection and reward-based update rejection, rather than introducing a fundamentally new optimization mechanism. The overall framework appears to be a combination of existing techniques. The paper should more clearly distinguish its contributions from prior temporal scheduling and gradient conflict resolution methods.

  2. Questionable mathematical formulation of adaptive switching. The switching criterion in Eqs. (4)–(5) is not sufficiently justified. In particular, the proposed limit of the difference between consecutive reward increments divided by the timestep approaches zero for any sufficiently smooth reward trajectory as the timestep vanishes, regardless of whether the structural objective has actually saturated. Therefore, this condition does not necessarily identify an effective switching point. Furthermore, a stable reward increment does not imply that further optimization is unnecessary. The paper should provide a mathematically sound switching criterion and demonstrate its relationship to actual objective saturation.

  3. Insufficient justification of cross-stage objective preservation. The gradient projection in Eq. (7) only addresses local first-order conflicts between reward gradients, while the acceptance criterion in Eqs. (8)–(9) checks reward degradation at the current denoising step. Neither mechanism guarantees that previously achieved improvements will be preserved after subsequent diffusion updates. Thus, the claimed cross-stage memory protection is stronger than what the formulation actually establishes. A more rigorous analysis of reward preservation throughout the denoising trajectory is needed.

  4. Limited diversity of optimization objectives. Although the method is presented as a general multi-objective guidance framework, the experiments primarily consider semantic alignment or text recognition paired with visual preference rewards, using PickScore and HPSv2 as the main preference objectives. These settings represent a relatively narrow family of optimization problems and do not sufficiently establish generality across objectives with different temporal characteristics. Additional reward combinations, particularly those involving spatial structure, compositional correctness, or other potentially conflicting objectives, would provide stronger evidence for the claimed general applicability.

Questions for authors

See weakness

Reviewer_q2MvOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

The paper claims multi-objective guidance, but it handles strictly two sequential objectives for text-to-image generation: an early structural reward R1 and a late textural reward R2. Building on existing reward-based inference-time guidance, it replaces multi-objective fusion with objective routing. The core is a threshold step at which R2 replaces R1, plus a cross-protection mechanism that preserves R1 gains during R2 guidance.

The motivation is a claimed conflict between the objectives and a wish to align with generation dynamics. The authors list identifying this temporal mismatch as one of three contributions, yet rely mainly on citations (chiefly Golan et al., 2026) and an inconclusive Fig. 1, so it is unconvincing that the conflict exists at all. Related work is missing from the main text (it sits in Appendix A), leaving scope and motivation very limited.

Notation is inconsistent across the method (Sec. 2), ablations (Sec. 3.4), and Figs. 2, 5, 6. Qualitative results (Figs. 4, 8) are not convincing. Numeric evaluations are prone to reward hacking, and the ablations and VLM evaluation lack implementation details, making them hard to interpret. The method appears overly simplistic, and the results do not convince otherwise. Given these concerns, I lean towards rejection.

Critical strengths

Evaluation on multiple text-to-image generative backbones: SD3.5, FLUX, SDXL, and SD1.5.

Critical weaknesses

Weak critical argument and missing core ablation:

  • No empirical evidence that simultaneous multi-objective guidance is insufficient or that the objectives compete. Fig. 1 is inconclusive: PickScore may be low early simply because the image isn’t formed yet, which doesn’t imply coarse structure is irrelevant to aesthetics.
  • No ablation against the competing multi-objective approach: equal-weight fusion or, ideally, a Pareto curve over objective weights.

Very limited scope:

  • Despite the multi-objective claim, the method handles only two sequential objectives. Eq. 9 also gives R1 extra priority, allowing R2 to be skipped on dynamically selected textural steps, which further limits R2.
  • No way to decide whether an objective is structural or detail-oriented. Why is human preference purely textural, when structure can affect it? Why is OCR structural, when text can be small and fine-grained?
  • No obvious extension to 3 objectives (e.g., prompt alignment, OCR, and aesthetics together).
  • No limitations stated.

Problematic results:

  • Qualitative (Figs. 4, 8): only the OCR group (4 of 24 samples) is distinguishable (more correct letters, though still not capitalized as prompted). In the other 20/24 it is hard to tell which baseline wins, if any.
  • Reward hacking risk: Tab. 1 measures the same rewards the method optimizes. Cross-reward scoring and a user study would make the evaluation more credible.
  • ParetoSlider is cited but not compared to as a baseline.
Questions for authors

Missing evaluation details.

  • Unclear ablations: Figs. 5-6 use names that differ from the descriptions in Sec. 3.4 and map to no method component. E.g., “Complementary Cross-stage Protection” (called Cross-stage Reward Memory in Fig. 6) refers to gradient and score memory, which Sec. 2 never defines.
  • Hard to interpret Ours in Fig. 5-6 with bars showing only A1-A8. It is unclear whether values are relative to Ours. The text says “All variants are compared with the full T-MOG” but does not explain the relation.
  • Missing VLM eval protocol: what was the VLM asked to judge, with which system prompt, and what exactly was assessed under Structural Faithfulness (SF), Anti-Hacking (AH), etc?
  • Lack of baseline details: for DyMO and RewardFlow, which are multi-objective, why are R1-only and R2-only results of interest? How was Fusion implemented for FMRG? Hyperparameters in the appendix would help. What was the reasoning behind choosing these baselines?
  • Redundancy: Fig. 3 shows the same numbers as Tab. 1 in relative form, apparently (method−base)*100/base, without stating the formula. Why are both needed?

Unclear method notations.

  • Reproducibility: how is the limit in Eqs. 4-5 implemented in practice? Is there a threshold? Fig. 2 uses ratioswitchratio_{switch}, which is never introduced in the text.
  • Method Fig. 2: What is Gradient Memory, which Sec. 2 never mentions? Why do the stage-1 bars show R2 if the method never computes it there? What do the skeleton-like overlays in stage 1 represent?

Unclear separation between preliminary and method.

  • Eq. 1 is attributed to Zhong et al., 2025, a survey of reward models, which is too broad a source for this formula. Since it is given “to compute image-level rewards”, it also belongs in Sec. 2.1.2, not 2.1.1.
  • Sec. 2.1.2 introduces reward gradient guidance, which the Introduction attributes to recent studies, but has no citation at all. It is unclear whether it is posed as novel.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.