acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Developmental World Model: A Child-Machine Framework for Heterogeneous World Dynamics

Abstract

World models are commonly learned for one environment or through a shared parameterization across related tasks. We study heterogeneous worlds whose mature dynamics can differ substantially while following a common organization of how state evolves, behavior is generated, events change state, observations are produced, and autonomous rollout proceeds. Inspired by Turing's child-machine distinction, we introduce Developmental World Model (DWM), which supplies this event-time organization before fitting and learns a separate numerical realization for each world. Development moves from teacher-supported fitting toward autonomous generation, with candidate stages selected by autonomous prediction and a fixed-event-path contraction certificate. A final post-hoc affine-logit calibration adjusts predictive probabilities after autonomous trajectory generation. The mathematical analysis connects finite-dimensional behavioral prediction to the DWM event-time form, establishes contraction along realized event paths, and derives a Wasserstein contraction condition for autonomous transition kernels. Experiments across sequential, temporal, multi-agent, and embodied environments show that the same dynamical organization can develop distinct world-specific dynamics and state semantics. Code: https://anonymous.4open.science/r/DWM-29D4/.

Primary area:
learning on time series and dynamical systems
Keywords:
world models, developmental learning, dynamics learning, shared dynamics, heterogeneous environments, long-horizon prediction, stability

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 10%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.67 over 3 reviews, above 10% of the others.
Reviewer_zzukOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
1
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

The manuscript studies world models that share "common structural organization", which seems to be about sharing high-level structure with differing low-level dynamics. The authors then propose, test a model tailored to modeling this class of systems, and develop theory that provides some guarantees about them.

Critical strengths
  • Studying methods that exploit structure in dynamical systems (which this paper does) I believe is often-overlooked with lots of potential.
Critical weaknesses
  1. There are severe presentation issues with the manuscript. E.g., technical terms like "organization structure", "event-update families", "flow", are not defined; equations 1 and 2 are the same. The Develop operator is undefined and not explained, even though it is seemingly a core operation. As another example: the manuscript focuses on "heterogenous" world models. What is exactly meant by this? The word is in the title, but it is used only in the introduction and the conclusion and it is never explained what this refers to.
  2. The connection between the main theorems and the manuscript's stated goals are not described. Similarly, the connection between the theorems and the experiments is not explained clearly. This puts a heavy burden on the reader for understanding what the contribution is and how the different sections form a coherent whole. This makes it hard to assess what exactly the experiments are testing relative to the setup described in the theory.
Questions for authors
  • Would you consider formally defining the manuscript's core terms? E.g., "heterogenous worlds", "mature dynamics", "organization structure", "behavioral meaning", etc. This would clarify a lot of the manuscript.
  • Would you clarify the connection between the stated goal, the main theorems, and the experiments?
  • Would you clarify what the insights from the theorems are?
1 comment

Response to Reviewer zzuk We thank the reviewer for the detailed comments on clarity and presentation. We have revised the definitions in Section 2 and strengthened the connection between the theoretical results and experiments.

W1 and Q1. Definitions of the central concepts. A: Heterogeneous worlds are environments with different behavioral distributions, temporal dynamics, action responses, and observations. They share the DWM model structure but learn separate parameters from their interaction data. The continuous flow describes state evolution between events; the event map describes the change caused by a realized action. Mature dynamics are the fitted parameters obtained through Development. The behavioral meaning of a latent direction is determined by its effect on action probabilities and its response to actions. Section 2 defines the model, while Section 4 and Appendix D.6.2 illustrate these quantities in the learned dynamics.

W1. Difference between Eqs. (1) and (2). A: Equation (1) defines the original event time transition through F(e)F(e) and g(e)g(e). Equation (2) constructs a continuous flow and event map whose composition reproduces that transition. Theorem 2.1 also transforms the behavior model consistently, establishing equivalence of the resulting trajectory distributions under its assumptions. Equation (1) specifies the process; Equation (2) gives the representation used by DWM. Appendix C.10 contains the derivation and identification analysis.

W1. Definition of Develop. A: Develop maps an initialized model and its training data to a fitted dynamical model. Training proceeds from observed trajectories toward autonomous generation. Each stage evaluates a candidate using held out autonomous prediction and stability certification. An accepted training duration is replayed on the full training data, and the certified model becomes the parent of the next stage. Equation (12) specifies the acceptance rule; Eq. (13) defines the composition of stages. Appendix B.1.4 gives the implementation. Affine calibration subsequently adjusts scoring probabilities without changing the generated trajectory.

W2 and Q2. Connection between theory and experiments. A: Theorem 2.1 motivates the continuous flow and event maps that we fit and analyze experimentally. Theorem 2.2 gives the fixed event path contraction property assessed through developmental certificates and the independent audit in Appendix D.6.3. Theorem 2.3 establishes that stage selection preserves the certified model class; Section 3.4 examines how the accepted stages affect prediction and dynamics. Section 4 and Appendix D.6.2 connect the fitted state to behavioral coefficients, action responses, and subsequent evolution.

Q3. Insights from the theorems. A: Theorem 2.1 establishes a representation in which continuous evolution and the effect of actions can be examined separately. Theorem 2.2 combines contraction between events with the effect of event updates. Appendix C.11 extends the analysis to the autonomous transition kernel, accounting for state dependent action probabilities. Theorem 2.3 establishes preservation of the certified model class during Development. Together, these results explain the model's mathematical construction, stability properties, and learning procedure. The experiments investigate how these properties appear in fitted models. We appreciate the reviewer's suggestions, which have made the relationship between the equations, learning procedure, and empirical analysis clearer.

Reviewer_RT5POpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes the Developmental World Model (DWM), which models heterogeneous environments with distinct dynamics by leveraging a shared dynamical organization. The approach predefines a structure shared across environments and independently learns environment-specific dynamical parameters. The paper provides theoretical analyses on predictive state representations, dynamical stability, and autonomous generation, and conducts experiments across a variety of tasks, including sequence prediction, multi-agent interaction, and embodied environments, demonstrating competitive predictive performance and a degree of interpretability.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper provides detailed theoretical derivations.
  2. The learned models are visualized and interpreted in a meaningful way.
Critical weaknesses
  1. There are concerns regarding novelty. The paper emphasizes that different environments can share a dynamical organization while learning their respective environment-specific dynamics. However, this core idea exhibits notable conceptual overlap with existing work. For instance, Zhang et al. [1] have already investigated modeling frameworks that share latent structure across environments while accommodating variations in environment dynamics. Although the two works differ in their specific implementations and parameter-sharing schemes, this paper has not sufficiently articulated the substantive novelty of its core modeling idea relative to such prior work. Furthermore, the proposed Developmental Learning primarily manifests as a gradual transition from teacher-supported training to autonomous generation, achieved through stage-wise adjustment of training objectives and the introduction of a stage-promotion rule. This bears considerable resemblance to established ideas in Curriculum Learning and Scheduled Sampling. The authors need to clarify whether Developmental Learning introduces a genuinely novel learning mechanism that goes beyond these mature methods, rather than merely reorganizing and relabeling existing training strategies.
  2. The theoretical analysis does not yet clearly establish a benefit attributable to the proposed developmental schedule. For example, the conclusion of the Developmental Closure theorem follows directly from the assumptions that the initial model and every promoted full-TRAIN realization belong to the same fixed-event-path-certified DWM class. While this result verifies preservation of the fixed-event-path contraction certificate, it does not by itself establish a theoretical advantage of the proposed developmental schedule.

[1] Amy Zhang et al. Learning Robust State Abstractions for Hidden-Parameter Block MDPs.

Questions for authors
  1. The paper proposes to unify the modeling of heterogeneous worlds through a shared dynamical organizational structure, but the core motivation and the necessity of the method are not yet sufficiently clear. Since different environments still independently learn their own dynamical parameters, what is the fundamental difference between the proposed approach and simply training models with the same architecture separately in each environment? I would appreciate it if the authors could further clarify the key limitations of existing methods in modeling heterogeneous worlds and explain how the proposed framework specifically addresses these issues.
  2. Could the authors provide supplementary experiments to more clearly disentangle the respective contributions of Developmental Learning and post-hoc probability calibration, or otherwise elaborate on their individual contributions?
  3. The paper treats the cross-environment shared dynamical structure G\mathcal{G} as a pre-specified design choice, learning only environment-specific parameters θw\theta_w, but does not sufficiently explain how to construct or select a unified structure that is suitable for heterogeneous environments. Could the authors further elaborate on the rationale behind the choice of the current event-driven structure, causal ordering, and dynamics function family? How can one determine whether a chosen G\mathcal{G} is applicable across different environments? Moreover, how sensitive is the model to the choice of G\mathcal{G}, and how is performance affected when the pre-specified structure is mismatched with the actual environment dynamics?
1 comment

Response to Reviewer RT5P We thank the reviewer for the thoughtful assessment and for recognizing the theoretical analysis and interpretability of DWM. We have clarified the model's contribution, developmental procedure, and choice of dynamics in the revised manuscript.

W1. Novelty relative to shared state abstractions and curriculum learning. A: Zhang et al. study state abstractions for hidden parameter MDPs. DWM instead models the complete interaction process: the latent state generates behavior, each realized action changes that state, and the updated state governs subsequent behavior. The continuous flow, behavior model, and event map jointly define the trajectory distribution. Theorem 2.1 establishes the relationship between an event time process and this representation. Development also goes beyond changing the training schedule. Candidate stages are evaluated by autonomous prediction and stability certification; accepted training durations are replayed on the full training data before promotion. Section 2.3 specifies this procedure in Eqs. (10)–(13).

W2. Contribution of the Developmental Closure theorem. A: Theorem 2.3 proves that the developmental procedure preserves the certified model class. Its induction follows the stage promotion rule, linking the learning algorithm to the stability condition in Theorem 2.2. Section 3.4 and Appendix D.6.1 examine the empirical effect of Development through comparisons with direct fitting and analyses of learned time scales and action responses. These results connect certified learning with the dynamics acquired by the model.

Q1. Why share a structure while fitting parameters separately? A: DWM shares a model of how time, actions, and state changes interact, not numerical parameters across environments. Equations (3)–(8) use one state to generate actions and model their consequences. This enables the same analysis of temporal modes, behavioral coefficients, and event responses in different environments. Section 4 illustrates the resulting dynamics in Melting Pot and PARTNR, where the fitted states organize different behaviors within the same mathematical formulation.

Q2. Contributions of Development and calibration. A: Section 3.4 and Appendix D.6.1 distinguish these effects in Tables 4 and 15. Development changes the continuous generator, behavior coefficients, and event responses. The comparisons with direct fitting reveal differences in temporal persistence and action dependent state changes. Affine calibration adjusts scoring probabilities after the autonomous trajectory has been generated, leaving the state dynamics unchanged. Table 15 applies identical calibration procedures to Full DWM and NoDevelopment, separating the analysis of learned dynamics from probability adjustment.

Q3. Choice and applicability of the dynamical structure. A: The model follows the temporal order of interaction: continuous evolution precedes action generation, and a realized action updates the state. This gives the flow, behavior model, and event map distinct roles. Theorem 2.1 establishes the representation under its assumptions; Appendix C.10 characterizes how variation in event intervals identifies continuous evolution separately from event updates. We assess the specified structure across environments using autonomous prediction, temporal modes, behavioral loadings, and action responses. Section 2 and Appendix C.12 explain the common model family and its task specific interfaces. We thank the reviewer again for helping us clarify the mathematical contribution and developmental mechanism.

Reviewer_gXe4OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper introduces Developmental World Model (DWM), a hybrid state-space model that uses a common structural specification while fitting separate parameters for each environment. Its event cycle combines continuous latent evolution, behavior generation, an action-dependent state update, and an observation model. All experiments use a four-dimensional latent state, with particle filtering over an observed support prefix followed by autonomous query prediction. Training proceeds through stages that increase exposure to generated trajectories. Candidate stages are selected using held-out autonomous prediction and a fixed-event-path contraction certificate. A final affine-logit calibration adjusts scoring probabilities without changing the generated trajectories. The theoretical analysis covers predictive realization, flow–jump equivalence, fixed-path stability, and a separate sufficient condition for autonomous Wasserstein contraction. Experiments evaluate behavioral prediction on human-interaction datasets, bsuite trajectories, Melting Pot, and PARTNR. DWM achieves the lowest reported NLL on two of the three standard sequence tasks and outperforms the reported DreamerV3 comparisons on the two higher-dimensional settings. Additional analyses examine developmental stages and the functional roles of learned latent directions.

Critical strengths
  1. The model offers an inspectable representation with credible predictive results. The explicit flow, behavior, jump, and measurement maps make it possible to examine how latent directions affect predictions and subsequent state changes. This is supported by quantitative results: on PersuasionForGood, DWM achieves 3.1579 NLL versus 3.2422 for the strongest reported baseline, Markov. The Melting Pot and PARTNR comparisons provide further evidence that the approach is useful beyond one small sequential dataset. These results make the compact model worth studying.

  2. The stability analysis identifies a distinction that matters for autonomous rollout. When actions depend on the latent state, perturbing that state changes both the transition within an action branch and the probability of selecting different branches. Appendix C.11 explicitly accounts for both effects in the autonomous contraction condition. This gives a clearer account of the model’s stability requirements than inspecting the continuous flow alone. The separation between development diagnostics and final-test results is also a positive feature of the evaluation.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The experiments do not yet establish how much the developmental procedure contributes beyond calibration and ordinary fitting. Table 4 is particularly revealing. On Public Goods, development without calibration improves NLL from 0.490294 to 0.487607, whereas the subsequent calibration improves it to 0.476087. The calibration gain is therefore substantially larger than the developmental gain in this experiment. The uncalibrated DWM result is also essentially the same as the GRU result of 0.4875 in Table 1. The sequential ablation is useful, but it omits direct fitting followed by the same calibration. The paper also does not establish whether the competing predictors receive comparable calibration. Consequently, the full-model comparison does not isolate the proposed developmental mechanism. Stage-by-stage improvements on development folds are encouraging, but cannot replace a comparison against direct autonomous training with a comparable optimization budget. This matters because development guided by a stability certificate is a central methodological contribution.

  2. The breadth of environments is stronger than the evidence that the model captures their dynamics beyond behavioral statistics. The bsuite results have no comparison methods. For K2, the reported NLL of 0.69242 is close to the uniform predictor’s log⁡2≈0.69315\log 2 \approx 0.69315; for K3, the corresponding values are 1.08365 and log⁡3≈1.09861\log 3 \approx 1.09861. Without the trajectory-generating policy and simple predictive baselines, these numbers provide little evidence about which temporal structure has been learned. The higher-dimensional experiments compare only against DreamerV3, although simpler sequence predictors are competitive elsewhere in the paper. The existing Melting Pot observation ablation is relevant, but its differences are small: 1.15489 for the full model, 1.16664 for action-only, and 1.15837 with shuffled visual features, without cross-seed uncertainty for this diagnostic. These results support behavioral forecasting, but leave unresolved how much the environmental observations and proposed dynamics contribute. Stronger controls would make the cross-environment claim substantially more convincing.

Questions for authors
  1. Contribution-isolating comparison: What happens when direct-fitting DWM and the strongest sequence baselines receive the same out-of-fold affine calibration? In particular, how does direct fitting plus calibration compare with the full developmental pipeline under a comparable training budget? Results on Public Goods and one additional environment would directly affect my assessment of the central contribution.

  2. Evaluation clarification: Which behavior policies generated the bsuite trajectories, and how do empirical-frequency and first-order Markov predictors perform under the same support–query protocol? For Melting Pot and PARTNR, does DWM retain its advantage against a suitably trained GRU or another simple sequence predictor using the same inputs and calibration?

  3. Certificate clarification: How are the norm, the constant MM, and the audited time intervals fixed when computing ηlower\eta_{\mathrm{lower}} in Figure 5? The definition of a maximum admissible rate over finite paths depends on these choices. Please also specify the implemented certificate penalty and whether the learned models satisfy the stronger κauto<1\kappa_{\mathrm{auto}}<1 condition. I recognize that the latter is a sufficient condition rather than a necessary one, but its empirical status would clarify what the stability analysis guarantees for the fitted models.

1 comment

Response to Reviewer gXe4 We sincerely thank the reviewer for the careful and constructive assessment. We particularly appreciate the recognition of DWM's explicit dynamical representation and its treatment of stability during autonomous generation. We address the concerns about Development, predictive comparisons, and certification below.

W1 and Q1. Contribution of Development beyond calibration and direct fitting. A: Thank you for highlighting the importance of this comparison. Section 3.4 and Appendix D.6.1 examine the contributions of Development and affine calibration separately. Table 4 presents the successive effects of developmental training and calibration, while Table 15 compares Full DWM with NoDevelopment under identical calibration procedures. The matched affine comparison shows that the models obtain similar predictive likelihood while learning different dynamics. Development changes the time scales of the latent state and its responses to actions, whereas affine calibration adjusts the final predictive probabilities. The same distinction is examined through the action response analysis on DeliData. The direct fitting control follows the same model architecture, initialization procedure, training partition, particle configuration, and random seeds as Full DWM. Its optimizer updates and learning rate schedule match the deployment training budget of the accepted developmental stages. This comparison directly examines how developmental training changes the fitted dynamics relative to autonomous fitting from initialization. Table 1 provides the broader sequence model comparison, while Tables 4 and 15 isolate the roles of Development and calibration within DWM.

W2 and Q2. bsuite policies, predictive baselines, and high dimensional environments. A: We appreciate this suggestion. Appendix D.4 now describes the bsuite trajectory generation policy and the comparison with empirical frequency and first order Markov predictors. Trajectories are generated by an observation conditioned stochastic policy with uniform exploration. The predictive baselines follow the same support and query protocol as DWM. DWM achieves better likelihood across the evaluated task groups, with more pronounced gains on tasks containing richer predictive structure. We have also included GRU comparisons on Melting Pot and PARTNR. GRU achieves the strongest prediction on Melting Pot, while DWM performs best among the evaluated models on PARTNR. Appendix D.5.1 provides a paired comparison on Melting Pot. The observation analysis examines the role of visual information, and Appendix D.6.2 investigates how the learned state influences action probabilities and subsequent transitions. In Melting Pot, different actions produce distinct state responses, including changes outside the dominant trajectory direction. In PARTNR, the learned behavioral representation distinguishes manipulation from navigation. These results connect autonomous prediction to the dynamics represented by the model.

Q3. Certificate norm, contraction bound, and training penalty. A: Thank you for requesting the implementation details. Appendix D.6.3 specifies the weighted infinity norm with unit weights and its induced matrix measure. In the Public Goods experiments, the audited event intervals and event sensitivities yield M=1M=1, and the contraction bound is determined by the matrix measure of the continuous generator. Appendix B.1.3 gives the differentiable stability penalty used during optimization. The penalty is the squared positive part of the difference between the required contraction margin and the estimated contraction rate. Candidate models undergo independent certification before promotion, and Appendix D.6.3 reports successful certification of the evaluated Public Goods models. The certificate concerns trajectories following the same realized event sequence. Appendix C.11.2 derives the separate autonomous contraction condition, κauto<1\kappa_{\mathrm{auto}}<1, which also accounts for changes in action probabilities when the latent state changes. The empirical certificates establish fixed event path contraction, while the autonomous condition characterizes the additional requirement for contraction of the complete transition kernel.

We sincerely thank the reviewer again. The revised presentation makes the contribution of Development, the predictive comparisons, and the stability guarantees more precise.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.