- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies collision-avoidance methods for generating point cloud, which can be viewed as a trajectory planner for swarms. The original flow-based generative methods is pointwise independent, thus external correction needs to be applied to avoid collision. The authors first analyzed learned correction, and found that second order does not bring in improvements. They then constructed a learning-free pairwise correction, and achieved decent results in experiments. The ablation study further shows the effect of integration control.
Critical strengths
The methodology of this paper makes sense. It first studied the learned correction, and honestly admit its failure cases. The authors then tried a simple learning-free correction methods, and demonstrate that it can achieve good results in experiments. The ablation study also show the important factors which influence the results.
Critical weaknesses
The contribution and novelty of this work is limited. The proposed method is just a simple potential-based pairwise N-body force model penalizing collision. Moreover, the advantage of the proposed method is unclear, as it does not exceed the previous ORCA method in collision avoidance.
Questions for authors
How do the learned correction perform with the same displacement cap and adaptive sub-steps as the fixed correction? In the caption of figure 3, it says "the learned heads are integrated without the fixed correction’s displacement cap and sub-steps". As shown in Table 2, removing the displacement cap drops the fixed correction from 500 to 341 clean rollouts. It is unclear whether the learned corrections fail because of the integration scheme or the model.
Thank you for the review.
We agree that the fixed correction is a simple pairwise force. Our contribution is the empirical comparison of correction design and integration, including their different effects on collision avoidance and geometry. We will make that distinction clearer in the revision.
The fixed correction does not consistently outperform ORCA. Lowering ORCA's radius from 0.03 to 0.015 brings its results closer to those of the fixed correction at moderate crowding. Surface distances are within about one reference thickness of each other, and we did not find a statistically significant difference in clean-rollout counts; this does not establish equivalence. Under heavy crowding, mainly airplane at N = 1024 and 2048, ORCA keeps more clean rollouts, while the fixed correction stays closer to the surface. We will report this comparison. One note is that ORCA was observed to be more computationally expensive than the fixed correction, even with the sub-steps. Implementation aside, which was an order of magnitude more expensive, the fixed correction is a pairwise sum, computed with a few tensor operations alongside the flow model, while ORCA solves a small linear program for each agent at every step.
On your question: we have not run the learned corrections with the same cap and sub-steps. In earlier runs without either control, the fixed correction performed better at N = 128 and 256 on airplane: 90 and 83 clean rollouts out of 100, compared with 72 and 31 for the best learned correction. That does not establish whether the gap remains under matched integration. We will add this comparison; until then, we will limit the conclusion to the configurations tested.