- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes AIM to address attempts to bypass concept erasure through localized inpainting by automatically adjusting the mask before generation. The method uses the ACE model’s unconditional concept bias to detect prohibited concepts through object isolation, inversion-based reconstruction, and similarity assessment, then expands the mask to remove residual visual cues. The authors evaluate the framework’s protection capability across various types of content.
Critical strengths
-
The method addresses a real vulnerability: unmasked visual context can bypass concept erasure during localized inpainting. The proposed mask adaptation effectively mitigates this vulnerability under the evaluated settings, providing more comprehensive protection.
-
Repurposing the ACE model’s unconditional bias as a concept-detection signal through reconstruction behavior is an interesting idea that reduces reliance on explicit concept-name matching. The experiments also cover multiple concept types.
Critical weaknesses
-
In my view, the main contribution is detecting target objects through reconstruction behavior. It remains unclear how the full framework differs from simple alternatives such as rejecting the request or regenerating the content after detection. The overall design is also an incremental extension of ACE, so its distinct technical contribution and practical advantages need stronger justification.
-
The paper appears insufficiently polished, with several noticeable errors in the figures, algorithms, text, and references.
Questions for authors
- What are AIM’s key advantages over simple alternatives such as rejecting the request or directly regenerating the content after detection? Which experiments demonstrate the necessity of the full framework?
- Does the reconstruction difference between target and non-target concepts remain consistent across different image distributions and concept-erased models? How do the authors assess the effects of false positives and threshold selection on protection effectiveness and benign editing?
- Where is Figure 5?
- Is inversion performed using the original SD model followed by ACE reconstruction, or using ACE itself? The descriptions in the paper appear inconsistent.
- When Are Concepts Erased From Diffusion Models? (NeurIPS 2025) is closely related and already identifies the recovery of erased concepts through visual context in inpainting. Please review this work and clarify its relationship to AIM.