acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

DeltaSkill: Residual Skill Compilation and Evidence-Guided Control for Long-Horizon Terminal Agents

Abstract

Skills have enabled a new class of language-model agents that draw on modular procedures and execution strategies to solve complex tasks. However, poorly adapted skill use can prolong task execution and waste tokens. In this work, we study adaptive skill use in language-model agents, combining capability-aware residual skill compilation with evidence-guided execution control. We call this framework DeltaSkill. We evaluate DeltaSkill against seven baselines on three long-horizon benchmark tasks, comparing execution time, task scores, and token consumption. Our findings reveal that lower execution costs can accompany improved or near-best solution quality. These benefits include improved reward on Generals, near-best quality on Spot with 57.2% fewer execution tokens and 84.7% less recorded wall time than Structured Local, and complete artifact delivery on DuckDB, where the seven baseline executions remain incomplete. To our knowledge, this is the first study to couple receiver-conditioned residual skill compilation with the retention of validated task artifacts and evidence-guided continuation for long-horizon terminal agents. Finally, we outline directions for extending DeltaSkill to continual capability profiling and cross-task skill adaptation, toward more efficient and generalizable agents.

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
Language-model agents, Reusable skills, Skill compilation, Execution control, Long-horizon agents, Context management

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 27%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.00 over 4 reviews, above 27% of the others.
Reviewer_p4WfOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper introduces DeltaSkill , a framework for adaptive skill use in long-horizon terminal agents. The authors observe that poorly adapted skill use can prolong task execution and waste tokens. DeltaSkill consists of two primary components: capability-aware residual skill compilation and evidence-guided execution control. It first constructs a capability profile for the agent, then compiles task related skill sets by retaining, merging, reinforcing, or removing existing skill instructions. During execution, the evidence-guided execution control checks the agent's results, saves the best validated output, and stops execution when further attempts fail to make progress, reducing unnecessary model calls. The authors evaluate DeltaSkill on three long-running tasks: Generals, Spot, and DuckDB. Experimental results demonstrate that DeltaSkill improves rewards on certain tasks while reducing execution time, the number of model requests, and observed token consumption.

Critical strengths
  • The research problem is practical and important.
  • Experiments show substantial efficiency improvements.
Critical weaknesses
  • Insufficient comparison with related work. For example, SkVM has already proposed skill compilation based on model-harness capability profiling, while SkillAligner has explored task conditioned skill adaptation. Not sure if the Residual Skill Compilation proposed by this paper is better than these baselines.

  • Limited evaluation. The main experiments only run with GPT-5.4-mini+Terminus2, while the profile matching experiments only run with GPT-5.5+Terminus2/OpenCode. Not sure if the improvement could be generalized to other models/harness.

  • The paper claims that DeltaSkill significantly enhances efficiency. However, it primarily reports token consumption during the agent execution phase, which is after skill compilation is complete, not covering the cost of capability profiling and skill compilation. Also, it's not clear whether the profiling results and compiled skills could be reused for multiple tasks.

Questions for authors
  • Do Capability Profiling and Skill Compilation need to be re-executed for every individual task, or can they be reused across multiple tasks? could you do some experiment results to show whether the profiling results and compiled skills could be reused for multiple tasks.

  • could the results be expanded to a broader range of Model+Harness combinations? why do you only choose GPT-5.4-mini+Terminus-2 for main experiments?

  • What are the fundamental differences between DeltaSkill’s Residual Skill Compilation and existing works like SkVM or SkillAligner? Can you do some ablation study experiments to show the specific contribution of DeltaSkill’s Residual Skill Compilation?

Reviewer_U9pYOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
1
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes DeltaSkill, a framework for improving the execution efficiency of long-horizon terminal agents by adapting skill instructions to agent capabilities and task requirements. It probes the receiving model and harness to build a capability profile and compiles residual skill instructions that keep only the guidance the task requires and the profile shows to be missing. During execution, it retains the best task output that passes validation checks and uses validation feedback and execution progress to decide when to continue or stop. Experiments on three benchmarks, including Generals for strategy-bot development, Spot for cost-constrained scheduling, and DuckDB for query-optimizer development, report improved or competitive task outcomes with shorter execution times than baselines that lack an explicit stopping rule.

Critical strengths

The problem setting of improving execution efficiency for long-horizon terminal agents is practical.

Critical weaknesses

The major performance claims rely on a single run per condition. Despite the complexity of the proposed framework, the ablations provide limited evidence for a reliable contribution from the residual skill instructions or their interaction with stopping. The results are insufficient to support the broader conclusions.

The comparisons involve differences in stopping policies, runtime configurations, and task-specific execution support. Moreover, wall-clock measurements can be affected by external API latency and execution overhead. The current experimental design does not adequately isolate the contribution of DeltaSkill from these factors, making the reported performance and efficiency gains difficult to attribute to the proposed method.

Questions for authors
  • Could authors clarify under what conditions the ineligible reward is reported as N/A in DuckDB? This remains unclear even after reviewing Appendix C.1.

  • How would DeltaSkill compare with recent skill adaptation and compilation methods such as SkVM [1] and SkillSmith [2] under the same execution conditions?

  • In Table 1, the baselines appear to run until they exhaust their allocated budgets without an explicit stopping rule. How would the results change if the baselines were evaluated under comparable wall-clock time budgets, for example, by limiting each run of the Spot baselines to approximately 30 minutes with the same artifact-finalization protocol?

  • How do the benefits of DeltaSkill vary with the capabilities of the underlying models and agent harnesses? The current experiments provide limited evidence that the residual skill instructions remain beneficial as these components become more capable.

[1] SkVM: Revisiting Language VM for Skills across Heterogenous LLMs and Harnesses

[2] SkillSmith: Compiling Agent Skills into Boundary-Guided Runtime Interfaces

Reviewer_cMENOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
1
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper introduces DeltaSkill, a framework designed to improve the task quality and execution efficiency of end-stage agents in long-duration processes. The framework first organizes skill guidelines based on task requirements and the agent’s capability test results, consolidating repetitive instructions, retaining key steps, and supplementing necessary support; it then verifies and saves valid outcomes during execution, deciding whether to continue exploration or stop based on actual progress. Experiments conducted by the authors on three tasks—strategy-based robot development, production scheduling, and database optimization—demonstrate that DeltaSkill can reduce execution time and token consumption for some tasks while improving or maintaining performance close to the optimal level. However, given the limited number of experimental tasks and repetitions, the stability and generalizability of its performance still require further validation.

Critical strengths

This paper offers significant practical value by proposing immediately applicable solutions to real-world problems in long-process agents, such as repetitive skill guidance, ineffective exploration, and delayed termination. Experimental results demonstrate significant benefits: the method improves or maintains high task quality across multiple tasks while reducing execution time or token consumption, reflecting a favorable trade-off between quality and cost. Furthermore, the core approach is clear and intuitive; it requires no model retraining and is primarily achieved through skill guidance adaptation and execution process control, making it easy to integrate into existing agent workflows.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The main experiments covered only three tasks: Generals, Spot, and DuckDB. The ablation experiments were run only once for each condition. Mean, variance, or confidence intervals based on multiple independent runs are missing. The performance of long-term agents is susceptible to the influence of initial strategies, agent feedback, and search trajectories; therefore, although the current results show significant improvements, they are not yet sufficient to determine whether these gains can be consistently replicated. We recommend conducting additional replicates and expanding the range of tasks covered.

  2. The paper defines four actions: Keep, Merge, Reinforce, and Remove. However, the experiments do not clearly demonstrate their necessity, roles, or actual benefits. Appendix G.1 shows that Remove was never triggered and Merge was used only four times, while Keep and Reinforce left the source text unchanged.

Questions for authors
  1. Why do you design the four actions? Can you provide any evidence that they are necessary?

2, Are the improvements consistent across repeated runs and more ?

Reviewer_a7EBOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

DeltaSkill combines receiver-conditioned skill compilation with evidence-guided execution control for long-horizon terminal agents. It profiles agent capabilities, routes and consolidates procedural guidance, retains validated task artifacts, and controls continuation using public progress evidence. Evaluation covers Generals, Spot, and DuckDB, with seven baselines and separate Spot experiments examining profile matching and the interaction between compiled support and adaptive stopping. The reported executions show promising quality–resource trade-offs, although the main comparison consists of selected development endpoints.

Critical strengths
  1. The integration addresses a practical failure mode of long-horizon agents. Separating candidate exploration from artifact retention prevents later unsuccessful revisions from overwriting a valid solution. The Spot trajectory provides a concrete example: finalization restores the retained artifact after subsequent candidates deteriorate. Connecting this mechanism to continuation control is operationally useful.

  2. The compilation–stopping experiment provides promising component-level evidence. Table 3 fixes the task, helper, evaluator, and best-artifact finalization across four conditions. Adaptive stopping with compiled support reaches 0.9457 reward using 0.338M tokens, compared with 0.9538 and 4.155M under fixed continuation. The substantially larger quality loss with raw skills suggests a useful interaction between procedural support and stopping, although replication is needed.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The evaluation does not yet establish a repeatable quality–cost advantage. The main results use one selected development endpoint per method and task, with task-specific DeltaSkill revisions, different command limits, and additional DuckDB support and recovery (Appendix B.2). Baselines run to their execution limits, and intermediate baseline quality is unavailable, preventing a matched time-to-quality comparison. The independently frozen Spot ablation improves control but still has one run per cell on one task. These results are promising case studies, but insufficient to establish robustness or separate the proposed method from configuration choices and run variability.

  2. The independent contribution of capability-conditioned compilation remains unclear. The default acquisition procedure cannot reach the 0.95 removal threshold; all 39 archived active-compilation decisions retain text or merge duplicates, with no removals (Appendices A.2 and G.1). Earlier routing and global linking can still matter, but their benefits are not isolated from support instructions and runtime control. The profile comparison provides limited additional evidence: each cell has one run, and the Terminus-2 matched condition also includes a recovery intervention. A matched profile-free or fixed-support control is needed to establish why measured capability profiles improve on simpler adaptation.

Questions for authors
  1. Endpoint selection and robustness: What rule selected the 24 main-table endpoints from the development archive? Are repeated runs available under a common frozen configuration, including matched command limits and recovery procedures?

  2. Capability-profile contribution: What are the no-profile outcomes for the September 24 experiment referenced in Appendix H.1? Does matching remain beneficial when recovery is standardized and compared against supplying the same fixed support to both receivers?

  3. Stopping efficiency: Can you report best-valid-artifact quality at matched elapsed-time or token checkpoints? For Table 3, such measurements would help distinguish faster progress from the savings obtained by ending execution earlier.

  4. Closest-method comparison: Can the authors compare against SkVM, or explain the concrete compatibility barriers? SkVM already combines model–harness capability profiling with compilation and runtime adaptation, making it particularly relevant for assessing the added value of DeltaSkill’s artifact-retention and continuation mechanisms.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.