- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The authors propose a method alongside CUT3R’s recurrent state tokens for dual-memory streaming depth estimation. The two memories, local and global, are read through parallel cross-attention branches. The method is evaluated on NuScenes, KITTI, Bonn, and TUM-Dyn at 50–500 frames.
Critical strengths
The problem is well motivated. The windowed and recurrent memory design is a clean framing. The overhead is modest: about 4% more parameters and roughly 25 FPS on an H200.
Critical weaknesses
- The major improvement of this paper seems to come from fine-tuning on datasets rather than the memory design. The baseline + gating in Table 2 beats other methods by over 20%, while the gain from the memory design is minimal, at merely 4%. The strong gain is from the gating, but the gating mechanism is weakly justified. Meanwhile, given the degraded numerical results on 500 frames, I doubt the usability of the local and global memory design.
- Missing critical baselines. STream3R, Point3R, and Online Video Depth Anything are all cited but not compared.
Questions for authors
- What is the baseline in Table 2? The fine-tuned CUT3R?
- A fairness concern about the evaluation protocol. FlashDepth targets 2K, while CUT3R and StreamVGGT run around 512. FlashDepth natively predicts relative disparity, while CUT3R-family models predict pointmaps. If every method is aligned in one space, some baselines are being evaluated outside their native output. So, how did the authors handle evaluation fairness?
- Figure 2 does not show an improvement of the proposed method, but raises a concern about the relative location of the balloon and the people. If a fair visualization protocol were used, the improvement would be mainly in temporal consistency, as shown in Table 4. The authors are encouraged to add results on TAE to both Tables 1 and 2.