- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
In this paper, the author mainly focuses on AC and CH types of equations, which could be derived from the energy dissipation law. The author first pointed out the drawback of the traditional PINN method, which uses the residual as an indicator for the sampling. Then, they propose potential-based adaptive sampling and calibrate the idea with some experiments on AC, CH, and RD equations from 1d to high dimensions
Critical strengths
- The authors proposed a simple but efficient way for AH and CH types of equations using the potential.
- The results presented in the paper confirm the efficiency for these types of equations.
Critical weaknesses
- It seems that the author does not acknowledge the existing work on the PINN residual and error analysis. In 2024, Liu et al., in the paper: Preconditioning for Physics-informed neural networks, and Tim De Ryck et al on ICLR, AN OPERATOR PRECONDITIONING PERSPECTIVE ON TRAINING IN PHYSICS-INFORMED MACHINE LEARNING, have pointed out the fundamental problems of PINNs using the residual as an indicator. They have done rigorous analysis and related the gap with the condition number of the differential operator.
- The authors should be very careful about the Modica-type gradient estimations. It is only valid for the stationary AH equation. For non-stationary AH, a small correction term is needed. For the Cahn-Hilliard equation, it is worse since there is not maximum principle for CH equation.
- I have some doubts about the numerical results in Table 1 and Table 7. why the Random-R, R3, Rsmote, and PAS always have the same memory in Table 1 . And why you increase Npool, does the memory not change in Table 7. 4.The authors overclaimed the applicable scope. It is not applicable for general energy-based govening equation for example the PNP, NS equation, where there is no potential energy inside or is not the dominate one. So the auther should narrow down there scope.
Questions for authors
-
Can the authors clarify whether is intended as an interface/transition indicator or as a surrogate for solution error? What do you mean by "suitable assumptions," especially for CH? For example, if my u_0= sin(kx), then the condition is not satisfied at the point x=0
-
How is GPU memory measured for each method? In particular, are candidate pools processed in batches, on CPU or GPU, and is adaptive-sampling overhead included consistently for PAS and RAD/RAR?
-
Can the authors test PAS in a case where the predicted interface is initially misplaced, to assess whether -based sampling can recover the correct interface rather than only refine an already well-located one?
-
Please do a careful literature search. Your current theoretical results have been mentioned.
-
Your current method is only valid for AH. The applicability to Cahn–Hilliard requires a more discriminating test. I suggest evaluating PAS during spinodal decomposition from a near-homogeneous, non-well-prepared initial state, and reporting performance separately during early interface formation and late coarsening. Also, the result in Proposition 2 is not correct. For CH, there is a conservation law. So the solution cannot be any constant. If it is a constant solution, it must be the avarge of the initail value.
-
The proposed PAS indicator relies on a potential-energy term that is strongly correlated with transition/interface regions, which is a special structural feature of phase-field models such as Allen–Cahn. The authors should substantially narrow the claimed scope of applicability and clearly specify the class of PDEs for which a meaningful -based sampling indicator exists.