(1) Methodological novelty is limited, and the dataset's distinctive value needs clearer explanation: The data pipeline mainly combines subtitle-based segmentation with existing face and pose extraction tools. The model uses pretrained encoders, projection heads and established contrastive objectives. The overall methodological contribution is incremental. The paper needs to make a clearer case for POSTURE as a distinct resource: which data gaps it fills, which research problems call for dialogue text, faces and body pose together, and what these data enable beyond the usual benefits of scale. The current experiments mainly show retrieval gains from more training data, while these specific research uses remain insufficiently explained.
(2) Important validation experiments are missing or insufficiently reported, limiting attribution of the gains and confidence in the conclusions. The experiments demonstrate overall gains, but three aspects remain insufficiently validated:
The contributions of the trainable components are unclear. The default setup trains a pose encoder in addition to the projection heads, but the trainable parameter counts, initialization, and architectural details are incompletely specified. Although the paper mentions a random-initialization baseline with R@1 of approximately 0.0003, it does not clearly provide a task-matched comparison before and after training under fixed pretrained backbones, or controlled ablations of the projection heads and pose encoder. This makes the incremental effects of the individual trainable components difficult to assess. Using frozen backbones is reasonable; the concern is that these incremental contributions have not been sufficiently quantified.
The incremental contributions of the modalities lack direct evidence. Results are not sufficiently broken down into text–face, text–pose, and face–pose retrieval, and the paper does not report controlled modality-removal experiments involving retraining and evaluation on the same retrieval task. Replacing encoders or changing objectives does not directly establish whether each modality contributes additional information, particularly whether body pose provides the intended incremental signal.
The matched-size comparison covers only one dataset size. Table 3 compares all training sources at 9,222 clips, whereas the scaling experiment varies only POSTURE's size. It remains unclear whether the datasets offer comparable utility across multiple matched sizes. Learning curves at shared sizes, for example from 1,000 to 5,000 clips alongside the existing 9,222-clip result, would help assess this in representative configurations. Fixed evaluation conditions, explicit sampling rules, and uncertainty estimates across repeated runs would help determine whether the conclusion depends on a particular size or sampled subset.
Together, these gaps limit the central interpretation: which components and modalities produce the gains, how stable those gains are, and whether the automatically constructed data offer comparable utility at matched sizes.
Thank you for the positive assessment and constructive feedback.