- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper shows that Sobol indices computed from a single trained parametric surrogate (e.g., an LC-PINN) provide a tight, achievable lower bound—the "architectural floor"—on the relative error of any architecturally restricted neural function class, and uses this to select architectures, verify that trained restricted networks reach their predicted floors, and diagnose a biased readout in a Fourier-HDMR estimator.
Critical strengths
The empirical verification is honest.
Critical weaknesses
The verification (Table 2) uses the projection computed from the same decomposition, so it validates the estimation pipeline rather than the operational claim.
Table 7 shows regression reaches the floor on three targets, but the physics-informed case leaves floors loose.
The estimator section (Section 7) diagnoses a bias but offers little guidance on when the Fourier-HDMR estimator is worth using.
Questions for authors
Could the authors show a concrete case where the floor rules out an architecture that a reasonable practitioner would otherwise have tried, and where training that architecture confirms the floor was informative?
I found this paper extremely difficult to follow. Can you add more background/related work sections, e.g., in the appendix, to ease understanding? It would be better to have more illustrations as well.