- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes CrossFreq-UHR, which adds a feature enhancement block to the UHR-DETR pipeline. The block samples global context according to each selected patch’s coordinates, separates local features into a smoothed component and a reconstruction residual, and processes them through different branches. Global context is introduced into the structural branch, while the detail branch is refined locally. Experiments are conducted on SODA-A and STAR.
Critical strengths
- The method addresses a practical problem: how to use global information to improve selected high-resolution patches without processing the entire image at full resolution.
- The reported results improve over the baseline on both datasets with limited additional inference cost. The matched-patch-budget and parameter-controlled ablations also provide evidence that the added block is useful.
Critical weaknesses
- My main concern is that the technical contribution is limited, and the experiments do not clearly support its central explanation. Most of the detection pipeline is inherited from UHR-DETR. The added block mainly combines coordinate-based feature sampling, smoothing and residual construction, and branch-specific feature refinement. More importantly, Table E shows that spatial alignment does not outperform the alternatives when each variant is trained separately. The shifted variant achieves 56.25 AP50 and 30.58 AP, compared with 56.08 and 29.47 for the aligned variant. Even spatial averaging achieves a higher AP of 30.29. Alignment helps large objects, but these results do not establish that it is the key missing connection described in the paper.
- The comparison with existing methods is incomplete, and several baseline differences need explanation. The UHR-DETR paper reports 58.0 AP50 for SparseFormer and 59.5 for CEASC on SODA-A, but neither appears in this paper’s SODA-A comparison, where CrossFreq-UHR reaches 56.1. These methods are slower, but including them would give a more complete picture of the accuracy–efficiency trade-off.
Questions for authors
- Why were SparseFormer and CEASC left out of the SODA-A comparison? Are their results in the UHR-DETR paper comparable with the setting used here? Including them, or explaining the differences in evaluation, would help assess the claimed accuracy–efficiency trade-off.
- What accounts for the different UHR-DETR baseline results: 34.9 versus 28.62 on STAR, and 53.3 versus 54.18 on SODA-A? Please clarify which results were reproduced and whether the baseline and proposed method used the same training and evaluation settings.