acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

CARET: Evidence-Grounded Compilation of Verifiable Agent Tasks

Abstract

Engineering workflow traces capture task requirements, tool interactions, and observed workspace changes. Turning these traces into reusable training tasks requires recovering missing context and reconstructing an unresolved state while preserving the source objective. We introduce CARET, an evidence-grounded framework for compiling these traces into executable agent tasks. A shared evidence contract links source requirements, workspace facts, unresolved dependencies, and verifier properties. It guides the joint construction of the initial workspace, instruction, verifier, and reference solution. Admission checks evaluate the initial state, reference repair, and a designated surface-only repair in separate fresh sandboxes. Execution feedback guides bounded revisions, and revised candidates must pass renewed checks before admission. We construct a corpus of 10,139 tasks and collect 24,187 trajectories. The task format supports demonstration collection for supervised fine-tuning (SFT) and resettable interaction for reinforcement learning (RL), with disjoint source-group partitions. Experiments compare CARET with OpenThoughts-Agent and ClawGym at 4B-Instruct, 8B, and 14B scales after SFT and subsequent RL. CARET achieves the highest PinchBench and WildClawBench pure-text scores in all six scale–stage comparisons. After RL, its margins over the strongest baseline at each scale are 2.00–2.40 and 2.40–2.70 percentage points, respectively. Component ablations support the training utility of the evidence contract, joint construction, and execution-guided revision

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
LLM Agents, Data Synthesis, Executable Verification, Agentic RL

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 30%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.67 over 3 reviews, above 70% of the others.
Reviewer_4fTAOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper transforms the actual engineering records into training tasks for agents. The author first summarizes the original requirements, and then uses these requirements to constrain the generation of the tasks, the environment, and the verifier. After generation, the tasks will be actually run for checking, and the tasks will be modified based on the failure logs. Finally, these tasks are used for SFT and RL, and the training effects are compared.

Critical strengths

S1. Having the tasks, environment and verifier follow the same set of requirements is a relatively straightforward design. When generating separately, it is prone to situations where the tasks have requirements but the environment does not support them, or the verifier does not check them.

S2. The checks are not only based on whether the reference solution can complete the task. The author also checked the scores when doing nothing and when only addressing superficial issues. After failure, modifying the task based on the logs can also help filter out problematic tasks.

S3. The generated data shows training benefits across multiple model scales. Both the SFT and the subsequent RL stages can see improvements.

S4. The author constructed over ten thousand executable tasks and collected over twenty thousand execution trajectories. The tasks are equipped with a runtime environment and a verifier, which can support SFT and RL.

Critical weaknesses

W1. The ablation experiment did not specify how much data each group used, nor did it provide the specific training budget. This makes it impossible to determine whether the performance decline is due to a deterioration in the quality of the tasks or a reduction in the training volume.

W2. "TerminalWorld" and "Terminal-Universe" already have very similar task construction and execution check processes. This paper emphasizes explicit evidence constraints, but does not directly compare how much it reduces the number of tasks that deviate from the original requirements relative to existing methods. The existing experiments show that the generated data is useful. It is not clear how much value the new design brings.

W3. The main experiment did not clearly state whether the SFT trajectories of each group were generated by the same teacher model. If the teachers are different, the improvement may also come from better demonstrations.

Questions for authors

Q1. Can you provide the actual data volume and training budget used by each ablation group? If these were not matched, would there still be similar benefits after matching them?

Q2. Can you use the same batch of original records and a similar generation budget to compare the construction processes of this paper and TerminalWorld? I would like to see how much the new evidence constraints can reduce cases where the original requirements are omitted or changed.

Q3. Can you explain whether the SFT trajectories of each group were generated by the same teacher model? If not, can you provide a control group using the same teacher?

Reviewer_gkDEOpenReview ↗
Rating
3(+1)
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2(+1)
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes CARET, a pipeline that turns internal engineer–agent traces into executable agent tasks in Harbor format (instruction, unresolved workspace, private verifier, reference solution). An LLM first extracts an "evidence contract" that ties each scored property to a trace anchor, a workspace fact, an unresolved dependency and a verifier check, and the contract then guides joint construction of all task components. A task is admitted only if, in separate fresh sandboxes, the unchanged workspace scores at most 0.2, the reference repair scores 1.0, and a designated surface-only repair scores below 0.8. Candidates that fail get a bounded number of revisions based on execution logs.

The authors build 10,139 tasks and 24,187 trajectories, then train Qwen3-4B/8B/14B with SFT followed by GRPO and compare against tasks from OpenThoughts-Agent and ClawGym on ClawEval-General, PinchBench and WildClawBench (pure text). CARET gets the best PinchBench and WildClawBench scores at every scale and stage, with post-RL margins of 2.0–2.4 and 2.4–2.7 points over the strongest baseline. Ablations on the 4B model (PinchBench) show drops of 5.66, 4.04 and 2.21 points when removing the evidence contract, joint construction and execution-guided revision, respectively.

Critical strengths
  1. The problem is practical and the pipeline is carefully engineered. Instruction, workspace, verifier and reference solution are built against one shared contract, and a task is admitted only after explicit execution gates (unchanged state, full repair, surface-only repair), leakage checks and source-group-disjoint SFT/RL/eval partitions. This targets real failure modes of trace-derived tasks, such as a workspace that already contains the answer or a verifier that ignores the dependency that matters.
  2. The downstream evaluation is reasonably well set up. The same tasks are used for SFT and then RL at three model scales, against two recent baselines with similar SFT budgets and RL task counts and results are reported on three external benchmarks.
Critical weaknesses
  1. Limited methodological novelty. Most components have close precedents. The evidence contract is the most distinctive piece, but it is an LLM-generated intermediate specification, and the only ablation removes it entirely, there is no comparison with a simpler alternative such as a generic structured plan without the trace-to-property links. What remains is an engineering pipeline plus a corpus built from private traces, which falls short of the novelty bar I would expect for ICLR.
  2. The evidence for the claimed gains and for data quality is thin. The margins over baselines are small and no variation across training seeds is reported, the STD in Table 1 reflects evaluation reruns only. The ablation covers a single 4B model and a single benchmark. I could not find whether the baseline trajectories come from the same teacher models and scaffold as CARET's, so the gains cannot be confidently attributed to task construction. On data quality, there is no human audit or estimate of verifier false-accept/false-reject rates: the gates test one designated surface-only repair, and the diagnostics in Section 5.5 and Appendix H are hand-built single fixtures that, as the authors state, do not measure the generator's behavior. Because the source traces are private and only governance-approved bundles will be released, readers cannot independently check these quality claims.
Questions for authors
  1. Were the SFT trajectories for OpenThoughts-Agent and ClawGym generated by the same teachers and scaffold? If not, how do you rule out that the gains come from the teacher or scaffold rather than from the tasks?
  2. Can you report multiple training seeds for the main comparison? Can you also run the ablation on another scale or benchmark, and add a variant where the contract is replaced by a generic structured plan without trace-to-property links, to show that the gain comes from the evidence linking rather than from extra structure in the prompt?
  3. Have you manually audited a sample of admitted tasks? How often does a task pass all three gates but still admit a shortcut other than the designated surface-only repair?
1 comment

Good job, and thanks for the extensive experiments. They addressed some of my concerns, so I will increase my score to 3.

Reviewer_duAJOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper tackles the problem of reconstructing pre-existing (human-made) engineering traces for the purposes of creating SFT/RL data for model training, which if done carelessly, can change the objective or omit prerequisites needed to test success. CARET addresses this through a shared evidence contract linking source requirements, workspace facts, unresolved dependencies and verifier properties. It guides joint construction of the task components, followed by fresh-sandbox checks of the unchanged state, reference repair and a designated surface repair, with bounded revision (§3, pp. 3-4). The paper reports 10,139 tasks and 24,187 trajectories, using smaller subsets for training. Experiments across three model scales evaluate SFT and subsequent RL, while component ablations and controlled diagnostics examine the construction procedure. Favorable results are reported.

Critical strengths
  1. The shared evidence contract addresses changed objectives and omitted prerequisites in reconstructed tasks. Linking source evidence to verifier properties is a useful contribution beyond the three-state checks shared with prior work (§§3, 6). Fresh-sandbox controls and bounded revision provide concrete checks of necessity and solvability. Appendix H illustrates preservation checks and acceptance of an alternative repair.
  2. CARET improves PinchBench and WildClawBench pure-text results over both baselines across three model scales and both training stages (Table 1), especially after RL. These gains support complete-pipeline utility, despite mixed ClawEval rankings.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The comparisons do not isolate construction quality. Published recipes use different SFT teachers, but teacher matching for these baseline rows is unspecified (§5.2). Source tasks, filtering and token exposure also lack comparable accounting. Each RL run inherits its method's SFT checkpoint (Appendix B). Table 7 describes the full corpus, without the training subsets' domain mix or its relationship to the assistant benchmarks. Table 2 supports component utility within CARET, but lacks variant-level training budgets and does not explain the advantage over other pipelines. Teacher quality and task distribution could contribute to that advantage.
  2. The central contract is operationally underspecified. Section 3.2 describes K, Equation 2 defines its evidence spine, and the supplement provides a schema. However, the extraction procedure and semantic consistency checks are withheld, leaving insufficient detail to reproduce how evidence supports requirements and unsupported assumptions are rejected. This limits assessment and reuse. The missing aggregates and table-regeneration scripts, despite the inclusion statement on p. 10, further restrict scrutiny.
Questions for authors
  1. Which teachers produced each Table 1 SFT set, and were baseline trajectories reused or regenerated? Please provide available comparisons of task difficulty and token exposure, and Table 2's candidate/admitted counts and training budgets.
  2. How were Table 7's proportions and the SFT/RL subsets selected? What existing analysis compares their domain mix across pipelines and connects it to benchmark task categories?
  3. Can you specify K's extraction and semantic validation procedure and locate the aggregates/scripts promised on p. 10? For the planned governed release, will the full task/trajectory corpus or a subset be available, and when?

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.