- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies sparse-view gait recognition, where each training identity is observed from only one viewpoint rather than the dense multi-view coverage normally assumed in cross-view gait recognition. GaitWM uses the pretrained Vista4D video-reshooting model to reconstruct a dynamic 4D scene from an observed gait sequence and generate additional gait videos from six novel azimuths. The generated sequences inherit the source identity and are used as additional training samples. To reduce the effect of identity corruption in synthetic videos, the authors introduce Generative Identity Regularization, consisting of stronger label smoothing for generated samples and an angle-dependent triplet margin. Experiments on SUSTech1K and CASIA-B show substantial improvements under the proposed sparse-view protocol. For example, BigGait improves from 45.2% to 87.1% on SUSTech1K and from 49.6% to 76.0% on CASIA-B, with gains also observed for GaitBase, DeepGaitV2, and Gait-X.
Critical strengths
-
The empirical effect under the proposed sparse-view setting is large and consistent across multiple recognition architectures and input modalities. GaitWM improves not only BigGait but also GaitBase, DeepGaitV2, and Gait-X, making it unlikely that the result is specific to one recognizer. The appendix also reports cross-domain improvements, which strengthen the claim that the generated viewpoints provide useful supervision beyond a single benchmark.
-
The choice of a temporally consistent 4D/video-reshooting model is well matched to gait recognition, where preserving motion dynamics is more important than independently generating plausible frames. The paper also provides useful qualitative failure analysis, including background distortion and failures at extreme viewpoint changes, rather than presenting only successful generations.
Critical weaknesses
-
The manuscript presents GaitWM as a new paradigm for sparse-view gait recognition, but the positioning relative to the closest prior work is incomplete. GaitCSV already explicitly studies sparse-view gait recognition, and prior gait view-synthesis methods have used generated viewpoints to improve recognition. More recent generative gait-recognition methods further weaken the broad claim that generative modeling for biometric recognition is largely unexplored. Most importantly, GaitCSV is discussed in the related work but is not included in Table 1. As a result, the current experiments establish that GaitWM substantially improves conventional gait recognizers under the proposed sparse-view setting, but they do not establish superiority over the closest method specifically designed for sparse-view recognition.
-
Section 4.1 states that the SUSTech1K training viewpoint is randomly sampled for each identity, whereas Appendix A.2 states that the assignment is deterministic and requires no random seed. This inconsistency directly affects reproducibility because the identity-to-view assignment determines the difficulty of the sparse-view training protocol. In addition, the “dense-view data + 6 synthetic views” result in Table 5 is almost numerically identical to the sparse-view BigGait+GaitWM result in Table 1, despite the former supposedly retaining the full dense-view real training set. This requires clarification because it affects the interpretation of the claimed source-domain degradation and cross-domain trade-off.
-
The dominant improvement comes from adding synthetic viewpoints, while Generative Identity Regularization contributes only a relatively small additional gain. However, the paper does not compare Vista4D-based synthesis against a simpler geometry-based augmentation, another gait-specific view-synthesis method, or an alternative video-generation approach. Therefore, the current evidence supports the conclusion that additional synthetic viewpoints are highly beneficial, but it does not yet establish that the specific generative world-model formulation is necessary. A controlled synthesis baseline is important for attributing the gain to the proposed methodology rather than to viewpoint augmentation more generally.
Questions for authors
-
In Table 5, why does the “dense-view data + 6 synthetic views” experiment produce a SUSTech1K result almost identical to the sparse-view BigGait+GaitWM result in Table 1? Please confirm exactly which real training sequences were included and whether this row comes from an independent training run.
-
Can the authors provide a comparison with GaitCSV under exactly the same one-view-per-identity protocol? Since GaitCSV is explicitly designed for sparse-view gait recognition, this comparison would materially affect my assessment of the contribution.
-
Is the SUSTech1K sparse-view assignment random, as stated in Section 4.1, or deterministic, as stated in Appendix A.2? Please provide the exact identity-to-view assignment procedure and, if randomness is involved, the seed and sensitivity across different assignments.
-
Can the authors compare Vista4D augmentation against a simpler view-generation baseline or an existing gait-specific view-synthesis approach? This would clarify whether the large gain is specifically attributable to the proposed generative video/world-model approach rather than to synthetic viewpoint augmentation in general.