- Rating
- 4
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
Simulating the cutting of deformable 3D objects is notoriously difficult because the resulting gaps break traditional fast simulation methods. NeuralCut solves this by enabling real-time cut simulations without needing expensive, pre-recorded training data. It compresses complex deformations using neural skinning, paired with a clever geometric trick that cleanly separates the two sides of a cut while keeping the edges perfectly smooth. Instead of relying on heavy simulation datasets, the model learns directly from physics principles by minimizing energy and applying smart constraints. The result is a fast, versatile tool that works on standard 3D meshes and Gaussian splats alike, making it highly practical for applications like robot interaction and easily adaptable to entirely new objects when paired with a transformer model.
Critical strengths
Enables real-time reduced-order simulation with high computational speed. Utilizes data-free, physics-based self-supervised learning, eliminating the need to generate costly simulation datasets.
Employs a simple geometric technique—coordinate lifting—to effectively handle separation on both sides of a cut while maintaining smooth edges.
Supports both traditional 3D meshes and state-of-the-art 3D Gaussian splats; when integrated with a Transformer, it can generalize to entirely new objects. Proven effective for robotic interaction simulations, with significant potential for practical application.
Overall, the results are very good, and the figures are presented excellently.
Critical weaknesses
While it eliminates the need for external data, the self-supervised training process based on physical energy minimization and Monte Carlo sampling can be computationally expensive or difficult to converge.
As a "reduced-order" simulation, it may offer lower physical precision compared to traditional, high-fidelity, full-space simulations when dealing with extremely complex deformations.
Not very sure? Because the approach relies on specific geometrically derived formulas, it may face modeling constraints when encountering highly complex or non-standard dynamic cutting topologies.
Free to include in the reference:
Reduced-order neural modeling with differentiable simulation for high-detail tactile perception. In 2026 IEEE 9th International Conference on Soft Robotics (RoboSoft). IEEE.
RealSimLoop: Online real-to-sim adaptation via differentiable reduced-order simulation with vision feedback. In Proceedings of the 2026 ACM SIGGRAPH Asia Conference. Association for Computing Machinery.
Questions for authors
None
3 comments
Thank you for your detailed and satisfactory rebuttal. You have adequately addressed my concerns regarding the training cost, convergence stability, and the limitations of the reduced-order simulation. The additional clarifications and results provided are highly appreciated.
I have no further questions and will maintain my positive assessment of the paper. I wish you the best of luck with the final decision.
Additionally, I highly encourage you to open-source your code and models if the paper is accepted. This would be a valuable contribution to the community.
We sincerely thank the reviewer for the encouraging feedback and continued support. We are glad that our responses have addressed your concerns. We will release our code and models upon acceptance.
Rebuttal by Authors
We sincerely thank Reviewer W3pR for the thoughtful feedback and strong endorsement of our work. We are encouraged by the recognition of our conceptual and technical contributions, the strength of our experimental results, and the broad potential for practical applications. Below, we address the reviewer's comments.
Q1. Training Cost and Convergence.
Response: We appreciate the reviewer's concern regarding the computational cost and convergence of physics-informed self-supervised training.
Computational Efficiency. Our implementation is built upon NVIDIA Warp [1], leveraging GPU-accelerated computation for Monte Carlo sampling and physics-based optimization. We further profile the computational cost of the key training components, as reported below.
These results demonstrate that our GPU-accelerated implementation enables efficient physics-based optimization.
Convergence Stability. We agree that energy-based, data-free training can be difficult to converge. In our experiments, we observed similar difficulties when adopting the optimization strategy of Simplicits [2]. However, by incorporating the on-the-fly skinning-field normalization and conflict-aware gradient correction introduced in PhysSkin [3], we effectively address these convergence issues and achieve stable training in NeuralCut.
References
[1] Warp: A High-performance Python Framework for GPU Simulation and Graphics. NVIDIA GPU Technology Conference (GTC), 2022.
[2] Simplicits: Mesh-Free, Geometry-Agnostic Elastic Simulation. ACM Transactions on Graphics, 2024.
[3] PhysSkin: Real-Time and Generalizable Physics-Based Animation via Self-Supervised Neural Skinning. In Proceedings of the IEEE/CVF Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition (CVPR), 2026.
Q2. Reduced-Order Limitations under Complex Deformations.
Response: We thank the reviewer for highlighting this limitation. We acknowledge that reduced-order simulation may offer lower physical precision than high-fidelity full-space simulations when handling extremely complex deformations. One promising future direction is to augment the reduced-order representation with a complementary neural deformation model to capture residual deformations beyond the reduced subspace. We have further discussed this limitation and potential future direction in the revised paper.
Q3. Complex Cutting Topologies.
Response: We appreciate the reviewer's concern regarding complex cutting topologies. Our geometry-derived lifting formulation also enables generalization to curved cut surfaces without additional training, as demonstrated in
video_curved_cut.mp4in the updated Supplementary Material.Q4. Additional References.
Response: We thank the reviewer for suggesting these relevant works. We agree that both papers are closely related to NeuralCut and have incorporated the corresponding citations into the revised paper.