- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents FragFlex, it combines fragment-level discrete diffusion with node insertion and deletion for variable-size molecular generation. A neural attachment-site predictor and valence-aware assembler reconstruct atom-level molecules.
Critical strengths
-
The design is well motivated. Fragment-level generation reduces structural complexity, while the neural attachment predictor provides a flexible alternative to the attachment lookup table used by FragDiffusion.
-
The large-scale evaluation is useful for examining repeated generations beyond small sample sets. FragFlex reports impressive validity and uniqueness metrics at 10 million samples, with additional scaffold and retrosynthetic-feasibility analyses.
Critical weaknesses
-
The baseline comparison is not sufficiently controlled. Experiment section retains each implementation’s default dataset and configuration, without specifying the exact datasets and filtering differences. Coverage of the 100-fragment vocabulary is also unclear. These differences may affect validity, QED, SA and retrosynthetic success, making the improvements difficult to attribute to the method.
-
The contribution of flexible-size diffusion is not isolated. Table 3 changes the assembly selection rule, insertion schedule and terminal state, but provides no fixed-size counterpart with the same neural assembler. Connectivity repair and beam search also influence the final results. A controlled comparison is needed to separate the benefit of size adaptation from assembly.
Questions for authors
-
Are FragFlex and FragDiffusion trained on exactly the same molecules? Please specify dataset sizes, filtering rules and how molecules containing fragments outside the vocabulary are handled.
-
See weaknesses.