- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
PrimingVLA adapts a frozen VLA model by training only a few parameters across VLM and action prompts. It first primes action prompts through masked action reconstruction, then jointly adapts both prompt banks using observation-conditioned flow matching. Cross-Prompt Calibration constrains action-prompt updates relative to VLM-prompt updates. Various experiments show the effectiveness of PrimingVLA.
Critical strengths
- The topic, achieving effective task performance with very few trainable parameters, is quite important for VLA policy fine-tuning.
- The training design is intuitive and easy to understand.
- Various experiments have been performed to assess the effectiveness of PrimingVLA.
Critical weaknesses
- The connection between staged learning and the challenges of adapting a frozen VLA with very few prompt parameters is insufficiently explained.
- CPC lacks sufficient justification and comparison with simpler alternatives, such as using a lower learning rate for action prompts.
- Bridge and Adaptation use the same inputs, objective, trainable parameters, and CPC mechanism, but differ mainly in optimizer settings. The necessity of separating them, particularly resetting the optimizer, is neither clearly motivated nor directly ablated.
- The real-world evaluation lacks quantitative success rates and comparisons with baseline methods.
- Beyond the concerns regarding the motivation and evaluation, the paper lacks polish in both its writing and figures. For example, Figure 4 is poorly cropped and contains truncated content, reducing readability and overall presentation quality.
Overall, the paper appears insufficiently mature in its current form. The proposed training recipe is not adequately motivated, and the paper does not clearly explain why its components address the challenges of parameter-efficient VLA adaptation. Together with the insufficient real-world evaluation and noticeable issues in writing and figure presentation, I believe that the paper does not currently meet the standard expected for acceptance at ICLR.
Questions for authors
See weakness above.