- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
Inspired by morphological component analysis, morphoSAE splits an SE into named addictive dictionaries, each with its own top-K budget. The morphological component analysis adds an optional cross-dictionary cosine loss to reduce overlap between groups decoder rows.
Critical strengths
This paper talked in a very honest way, including a lot of declaration and disclosure about the performance. It also have good comparison designs, with careful separation of the allocation and geometries, reconstructions and functions for each of the parts. It included transparent statistics.
Critical weaknesses
However, it also have the issue for methodology has not been demonstrated of the benefit and the positive result does not supporting the paper's methodology which making the weak evidence basis and the efficiency of the methodology become a challenge. This paper is relatively harder to understand.
Questions for authors
In what concrete natural analysis would guaranteed returned indices change a conclusion? Can you show one, or a case of starvation under named-global at realistic budgets?
We appreciate your recognition of the controls and honest reporting. Your request for a concrete use case helped clarify the contribution. We have revised the paper to include new matched experiments, simpler explanations and explicit limitations. All references below point to the revised paper.
W1 No demonstrated practical benefit or efficiency advantage
See revised §§5.6–5.7, Tables 4–5 and Appendices D.3 and F.2–F.4.
We did not test deployment uses, other traits, runtime or memory savings or efficiency at smaller budgets: we compared learned selectors at a fixed budget. Simpler mean-difference or low-rank baselines were also not tested. Transferring correction patches between articles still gives 75.53% recovery for quota and 70.79% for global, making those alternatives important. Whether an SAE is needed remains open (Table 5; §6).
W2 The positive result does not identify the method's benefit
See revised §§5.5, 5.7, Table 3 and Appendices C.1–C.3 and F.2–F.3 for the matched controls and remaining limits.
W3 Difficult presentation
We added definitions and a worked example before equations, including the quota's reconstruction cost. Section 5.7 explains the clean reference, eight reused features and recovery example. Table 5 explains which question each test answers. Appendix F provides formulas; F.2 specifies that SAE selection uses 32/128 development articles, while probes use all 128. These changes are in the revised paper.
Q1 What natural conclusion changes, or where is realistic starvation?
See revised §§5.6–5.7 and Appendices D.3 and F.3.