- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper addresses the challenge of deblurring by tackling the domain gap and prior conflicts between real and synthetic datasets. Real datasets capture complex, realistic motion blur but often suffer from noisy ground-truth references, whereas synthetic datasets provide clean ground truth but fail to faithfully simulate real-world blur dynamics. When fine-tuning pre-trained diffusion models, which are typically trained on high-quality, sharp images, this mismatch leads to prior conflict. To address this, the authors propose Real-Synthetic Decoupled Supervision (ReSyDS), equipped with Instance-Driven Realistic Blur (InstaBlur) and Motion-Strength Modeling (MSM). ReSyDS decouples the learning of fidelity and blur realism through two different paths: the synthetic path aims to preserve the fidelity, while the real path learns realistic blur patterns. InstaBlur generates diverse global, local, and mixed blur patterns using an instance-based synthesis strategy, while the MSM module captures the motion of pixels, repositioning the detail in the latent space. Experiments demonstrate that the proposed framework achieves strong performance across multiple benchmark datasets under no-reference quality metrics.
Critical strengths
S1. Promising No-Reference Metric Performance: As shown in Table 1, the proposed DS-DeBlur consistently and significantly outperforms state-of-the-art methods across all six benchmarks on five no-reference metrics. The paper effectively leverages pre-trained diffusion models while successfully mitigating prior conflicts.
S2. A Reasonably Designed Method with Clear Motivation: The paper clearly identifies the issue of prior conflicts (Figs. 2a and 2b), highlighting the quality gap and distribution mismatch between real and synthetic datasets that pose challenges for diffusion models. The authors thoroughly analyze the dilemma inherent in deblurring datasets, specifically, the trade-off between sharp-but-noisy images and clean-but-blur images. To address this, the proposed method decouples real and synthetic processing paths. This allows the model to learn fidelity from synthetic data and realistic blur degradation from real data without cross-domain interference. Table 3 empirically confirms these complementary benefits, showing that training on real data favors full-reference metrics, whereas synthetic data yields better no-reference metrics.
Critical weaknesses
W1. Limited Technical Novelty: The technical novelty of the proposed method appears somewhat incremental, as several key modules rely heavily on existing techniques. Specifically, the one-step SD-based generator is adapted from OSEDiff, the fidelity discriminator leverages DINOv2, and InstaBlur combines motion trajectories from DeblurGAN with second-order blur synthesis from Real-ESRGAN. Additionally, the proposed MSM integrates spatial-transformer warping with dynamic convolution. While the concept of decoupling real and synthetic paths provides a meaningful insight, the overall methodological novelty remains limited.
W2. Suboptimal Performance in Full-Reference Metrics: The proposed method fails to improve no-reference metrics while maintaining performance in full-reference metrics. Furthermore, performance on full-reference metrics is concerning. As shown in Table 3, the synthetic-only variant performs well on most no-reference metrics (CLIP-IQA, MUSIQ, MANIQ, and LIQE), whereas the real-only path works well on all full-reference metrics (PSNR, SSIM, and LPIPS). However, the adopted ReSyDS framework fails to achieve the best performance on almost any metric except NIQE, and even falls behind by noticeable margins on full-reference metrics. A similar trend is observed for the MSM in Table 5. Overall, comparing the performance on no-reference metrics, the performance on full-reference metrics is concerning. This issue is reflected in Table 2 of the supplementary material, where DS-Deblur yields sub-optimal full-reference results.
Questions for authors
Q1. Suggestion for Evaluation on Datasets with Clean Ground Truth: The authors are suggested to evaluate the proposed method on standard synthetic benchmarks with clean ground-truth images. In the supplementary material, the suboptimal full-reference metric performance is attributed to potential low quality in the ground truth. Evaluating the method on synthetic datasets with clean ground-truth targets would eliminate this confounding factor and can provide a clearer assessment of the model's true capability in preserving full-reference fidelity.
Q2. Request for Evidence on Adaptive Restoration Claims: In Lines 350–352, the authors claim several advantages of the adaptive restoration scheme. To support these claims, could the authors provide qualitative and quantitative evidence (e.g., visual comparisons and ablation metrics) demonstrating the specific contributions and effectiveness of the adaptive restoration mechanism?
Q3. Insight into NIQE Performance Advantage: In Table 3, NIQE is the sole no-reference metric where the adopted ReSyDS outperforms both the real-only and synthetic-only variants. Could the authors provide further insight or analysis into why ReSyDS specifically excels on NIQE compared to the other no-reference metrics?
As the deadline approaches and the authors have not submitted a rebuttal, I am unable to assess whether my concerns have been addressed. I therefore retain my original score.