- Rating
- 2(−1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies conflicting tokens in supervised fine-tuning, where the supervised target disagrees with a confident pretrained prediction. The authors show that these conflicting tokens do not behave uniformly during SFT, but instead follow different learning trajectories: some are resolved early, some gradually, and some remain difficult to learn.
Based on this observation, the paper proposes ForeToken, which predicts the resolution tendency of conflicting tokens before SFT begins. It uses the initial SFT optimization direction and finite-difference estimates of token-level probability and entropy changes to construct a forecasting score. The method then retains predicted Intermediate conflicts while masking predicted Early and Late conflicts during training.
Experiments across math, medical, agent, and code adaptation, multiple model families, and continual fine-tuning settings show that ForeToken improves target-domain adaptation while better preserving general capabilities than standard SFT and several token-level baselines.
Critical strengths
-
The paper provides an interesting analysis of conflicting tokens during SFT. Instead of treating all conflicting tokens uniformly, it identifies different learning trajectories and shows that these groups have different effects on the adaptation-retention trade-off.
-
The proposed forecasting mechanism is simple and practical. It avoids the need for an additional full SFT run and only requires a one-time preprocessing step before training. The experimental evaluation is also broad, covering multiple domains, model families, and continual fine-tuning settings.
Critical weaknesses
-
The trajectory forecasting signal is still relatively coarse. The paper itself shows substantial overlap between the forecasting-score distributions of Early, Intermediate, and Late conflicts. This suggests that the score captures a group-level tendency rather than reliably identifying the trajectory of each individual token.
-
The method depends on the probability and entropy thresholds used to define conflicting tokens. The appendix shows noticeable performance variation across different threshold choices, especially on Pass@1, so it is unclear how robust the method is to these hyperparameters across models and domains.
Questions for authors
-
How accurately can ForeToken distinguish Intermediate conflicts from Early and Late conflicts at the individual-token level? Since the score distributions overlap substantially, could the authors clarify how much misclassification occurs and how sensitive performance is to this prediction noise?
-
How should the conflict thresholds be selected in a new domain or model without validation data? Are the default thresholds expected to transfer reliably across settings?
-
Could the authors provide more intuition for why Early conflicts should be masked? Some Early conflicts are learned quickly, so it would be useful to better understand why retaining them is less helpful than retaining Intermediate conflicts.
4 comments
Q3: Why Mask Early Conflicts Rather Than Intermediate Conflicts?
Although Early conflicts resolve quickly, this does not necessarily mean they provide useful supervision. As shown in Figure 3, approximately 49% of Early conflicts later re-enter the conflict region, suggesting that their initial resolution is often unstable. To examine this further, we separate Early conflicts into Stable and Reverting groups (Table 5). Masking Reverting conflicts achieves 37.5 AMC and 5.0 AIME, compared with 30.2 AMC and 3.4 AIME when masking Stable conflicts. This supports our hypothesis that instability contributes to the limited usefulness of Early supervision. In contrast, Intermediate conflicts resolve gradually through sustained optimization, suggesting that they provide more useful learning signals.
Table 5. Effect of masking Stable vs. Reverting Early conflicts (Qwen3-8B Math).
| Masking Strategy | AMC P@1 (%) ↑ | AIME P@1 (%) ↑ | MMLU (%) ↑ |
|---|---|---|---|
| No Mask (SFT) | 29.4 | 2.5 | 71.1 |
| Early-Stable (Resolved) | 30.2 | 3.4 | 71.5 |
| Early-Reverting (Re-entered) | 37.5 | 5.0 | 71.5 |
Consistent with this, Table 5 in the paper shows that masking Intermediate conflicts reduces AMC performance (28.6 vs. 29.4 for standard SFT), whereas masking Early conflicts improves it to 38.9. Together, these results support retaining Intermediate conflicts while masking Early conflicts as a more effective supervision strategy.
Dear Reviewer,
Thank you so much for your time and efforts! As the discussion period ends soon, we would appreciate it if you could review our responses and additional experimental results. We’re happy to clarify anything further.
Best regards, The Authors
Thank you for the additional experiments, which address some of my original concerns.
However, after reading the comments from reviewers QxEo, odjK, and g38u, as well as the authors' responses, I share their concerns about the experimental setup. In several domains, even standard SFT fails to improve over the base model, making it difficult to assess whether ForeToken achieves a meaningful adaptation–preservation trade-off rather than simply mitigating performance degradation.
I believe this is a significant limitation of the current evaluation. Therefore, I have decided to lower my rating from 3 to 2.
We thank the reviewer for their valuable suggestions and for recognizing the strengths of our work. We address each concern below and have updated the submitted PDF with additional results and clarifications.
W1 / Q1: Individual-Token Prediction Accuracy and Sensitivity to Prediction Errors
We evaluate how accurately ForeToken identifies the Intermediate group by comparing its predictions with the actual trajectories observed during SFT (Table 1). ForeToken correctly identifies 20,779 of 26,000 Intermediate tokens on Qwen3-8B Code and 19,952 of 28,951 on DeepSeek-R1-Qwen3-8B Math. We further compare ForeToken with simpler random, probability-based, and entropy-based predictors (Table 2), showing its advantage in identifying Intermediate conflicts.
Table 1. Counts of Intermediate conflicts identified and missed by ForeToken across models and domains.
Table 2. Intermediate group F1 comparison with simpler predictors across models and domains.
Importantly, ForeToken is not intended to perfectly classify every token's trajectory. Its objective is to estimate when conflicting tokens are likely to resolve during SFT and use this information to guide selective supervision. Thus, perfect classification is not necessary as long as the predictions help identify useful tokens.
Sensitivity to prediction errors. To examine how these prediction errors affect downstream performance, we compare ForeToken's predicted token selection with post-hoc selection using the actual token trajectories recorded during SFT (Table 3). Despite imperfect predictions, ForeToken achieves performance close to selection using actual trajectories, with only 1.6 points lower AMC and 0.6 points lower AIME P@1. This suggests that the observed prediction errors have a limited impact on downstream performance.
Table 3. Impact of trajectory prediction errors on downstream performance (Qwen3-8B Math, P@1, %).
W1 / Q2: Threshold Sensitivity and Transfer Across Models and Domains
To assess this concern, we conducted additional experiments on Qwen3-8B Math using five threshold configurations (Table 4; mean ± standard deviation over three evaluation runs). The results show limited sensitivity across the tested thresholds: AMC P@1 ranges from 54.45 to 56.61 and AIME P@1 from 10.10 to 12.29, while P@16 remains relatively stable (87.17–88.64 on AMC and 43.00–45.78 on AIME).
For models or domains without validation data, we propose percentile-based threshold selection. Our default thresholds (τp = τH = 0.30) correspond to the 14.81st and 88.49th percentiles, respectively. Applying these percentiles to a new model's pretrained distributions provides a validation-free way to adjust thresholds. While this offers a practical approach to threshold transfer, its reliability across different models and domains remains to be evaluated.
Table 4. Threshold sensitivity on Qwen3-8B Math (mean ± standard deviation over three runs, %).