- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies boundary detection in high-dimensional point clouds and proposes a hyperplane method and a directional uniformity method. The former finds a hyperplane that keeps as many neighboring points as possible on one side, while the latter examines whether the neighborhood directions are uniform. Experiments show that the proposed methods outperform existing methods when the density is non-uniform, the ambient dimension is high, and noise is present.
Critical strengths
- The proposed methods are highly innovative and effectively address the problem that existing methods rely on density.
2.Experimental results show that the proposed method is more stable than existing geometric methods under high ambient dimensions and noise, and can also provide normals. This strongly demonstrates the effectiveness of the method.
Critical weaknesses
1.Although the results on synthetic data are relatively good, there is a lack of quantitative comparative experiments and metrics on real data, which raises doubts about the practicality of the method.
Questions for authors
- It is suggested to add quantitative experiments on real data.
2.When the true intrinsic dimension is unknown, how should one choose between the hyperplane method and the directional uniformity method? When spectral gap estimation of the dimension fails, the hyperplane method may mistake a noise-thickened surface for a boundary. Beyond post-hoc comparison, is there an automatic criterion that does not rely on the true dimension?
3.On real data, do high scores actually correspond to the boundaries claimed by the authors? For example, in spatial transcriptomics, what proportion of the high-scoring points come from the outer edge of the tissue section versus the mesenchymal-like–proliferative-like transition, respectively?
Rebuttal
We thank the reviewer for taking the time to review our paper, and we appreciate the positive remarks about the effectiveness of our method.
Response to weaknesses:
We have clarified in our revision that both the spatial transcriptomics data set and the LLM data have ground truth boundaries. As we wrote in response to reviewer #1:
“For the real-world spatial transcriptomics data set, a very good proxy for the ground-truth tumor boundary is the mesenchymal/proliferative contrast, shown in Figure 10 (left). The tumor boundary is where this contrast is close to zero. We explain this more clearly in our revision. We emphasize the our boundary detection methods did not use the the mesenchymal/proliferative contrast. For the character counting manifold, the ground truth boundary is {(i, w) s.t. i = 0 or i = w or w = 15 or w = 150}, where i = character position and w = line width. We show in Figure 11d that our detected boundary largely agrees with the ground truth.”
Response to questions:
Q1: Thank you for this feedback. See our response above.
Q2: One criterion is to check for pointwise consistency of the dimension estimates. If the pointwise dimension estimates are not consistent with each other, then this is a strong indication that one does not have an accurate dimension estimate. In that case, we suggest using the directional uniformity method.
Q3: We clarify that the boundary points near the tissue edge can be ignored because one can visually see that these high-scoring points are on the tissue boundary.