- Rating
- 4(+1)
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes Neural Dirichlet Random Measures (Neural DRM) for partition-agnostic urban spatial learning. Instead of learning representations for predefined spatial regions, the method constructs a continuous intensity field whose integral over arbitrary regions provides additive spatial quantities. A Dirichlet–multinomial formulation further ensures quantity conservation and probabilistic consistency across spatial partitions. Experiments on ten U.S. cities demonstrate improved population and POI prediction accuracy, as well as better cross-city transfer compared with conventional fixed-partition representation learning.
Critical strengths
S1: The paper addresses an important limitation of urban spatial representation learning: dependence on predefined spatial partitions and inconsistency across spatial scales.
S2: The integration-based formulation guarantees quantity conservation, while the Dirichlet–multinomial model provides a principled probabilistic framework for spatial count allocation.
S3: The experiments cover ten U.S. cities and multiple spatial partitions, demonstrating consistent improvements in population prediction and cross-city transfer.
S4: The paper is generally well organized, with clear mathematical formulations and extensive experimental comparisons.
Critical weaknesses
-
Limited novelty. The method combines established techniques, including continuous intensity fields, spatial integration, and Dirichlet–multinomial distributions, without substantial methodological innovation.
-
Insufficient baselines. Comparisons with established population disaggregation, dasymetric mapping, and spatial statistical methods are missing.
-
Overstated partition-free claims. The implementation relies on a fixed 40 m lattice and pretrained embeddings, limiting its spatial resolution and flexibility.
-
Limited applicability. The method requires known regional totals, restricting it to conditional count allocation rather than general urban prediction.
-
Weak representation learning gains. Improvements for POI prediction are marginal (1%–3%), and target-city training performs better in several settings.
-
Limited theoretical novelty. Quantity conservation follows directly from established properties of integration and Dirichlet distributions rather than new theoretical insights.
Questions for authors
See the above
6 comments
Response to Reviewer vUaz (2/4)
Overstated partition-free claims: a fixed 40 m lattice and pretrained embeddings limit resolution and flexibility.
We agree that the wording can be misread, and we clarify what partition-free means. Neither training nor prediction is tied to a particular partition: statistics on any partition can serve as training data, and any partition can be queried. It does not mean unlimited spatial resolution.
The 40 m grid is not a partition. It only serves to compute the integrals numerically, is shared by all partitions, and can be refined. We integrated the same trained field on grids refined from 80 m to 10 m (new Appendix G). The block shares converge: for population with AlphaEarth, their total-variation distance to the 10 m result is 0.086 at 80 m, 0.037 at 40 m and 0.025 at 20 m. The conclusions are unchanged at 40 m and finer, and at 10 m the population NLL is lower than with the paper's 40 m grid in all ten cities; only the coarser 80 m grid hurts. Refining the grid only resolves region boundaries more finely; the input stays at 40 m.
Pretrained embeddings are inputs, not a limit of the method. We agree that what the field can express is bounded by the information in its input (RQ3). The input, however, is not restricted in form or source. Any modality, including images, polygons, text and graphs, enters through an encoder that gives a feature at each location, and the features of several sources are concatenated into . Existing work shows that such data carry information on population and human activity:
- images: street view (Fan et al., 2023) and satellite imagery (Jean et al., 2016; Yeh et al., 2020), including building energy consumption (Sun et al., 2026);
- polygons: building footprints and 3D buildings (Li et al., 2023; Esch et al., 2022; Che et al., 2024);
- text: GeoLLM (Manvi et al., 2024);
- graphs and mobility: POI graphs and mobility flows (Huang et al., 2023; Wang & Li, 2017; Schläpfer et al., 2021; Moro et al., 2021);
- mobile phone data (Aiken et al., 2022; Chi et al., 2022);
- night lights (Li et al., 2020).
RQ3 already applies the same field to 12 input representations, including image-token models that take images directly (Figure 4, Table 9). We use pretrained embeddings such as AlphaEarth in the experiments because they are available worldwide, natively at 10 m, and thus support broad experiments across ten cities, several partitions and 12 input representations. Recent work keeps extending what such satellite data reveal about human activity, from mobility flows in cities (Xu et al., 2025) to human development (Sherman et al., 2026). As massive urban data are brought in, the field places no constraint on how the information is organized: new sources can be added to the input, and the field can also be learned end to end from raw data such as imagery, a direction the paper names as future work.
In the revision, we have stated this in Definition 2, in Section 3 (Lines 245–253) and in the introduction (see also our reply to Reviewer EJB1).
Limited applicability: known regional totals are required.
We agree, and the paper lists this as its first limitation. However, we want to clarify that conditioning on totals is a deliberate design. It separates how a quantity is distributed within a region from how much of it there is, so data from different sources and partitions can be learned together (Problem 2). Known totals are also common in practice, such as census counts and administrative statistics. Replacing the Dirichlet random measure with a Poisson or negative-binomial random measure would remove the need for totals; the paper names this as future work.
Response to Reviewer vUaz (3/4)
Weak representation-learning gains: POI improves by only 1–3%, and target-city training is better in several settings.
We agree that the POI gains in MAE are small. There are two reasons:
- In pretraining, POIs are observed only on block groups, about 14 blocks each, so the encoder never sees POIs at the block scale. This is a harder test than for population, which is observed on blocks.
- POIs are sparse: 81% of blocks have none, which compresses differences in MAE. The same holds in Table 1, where our field lowers the MAE relative to areal weighting by 36–44% for population but by 8–23% for POIs.
The NLL, which evaluates the full predictive distribution, still improves consistently for POIs: against fixed-partition pretraining, it is significantly lower at every label fraction and lower in 8 or 9 cities.
For population, the gains are large: against fixed-partition pretraining, the block MAE drops by about 15% at every label fraction, and the NLL is lower in all ten cities (Table 2, Figure 3). All these comparisons are controlled, and the gain comes from the integral readout itself. Pooled pretraining, with the same data and architecture, is significantly worse (point 1), and a random encoder with the same architecture is much worse, which rules out the extra nonlinearity as the source. Conventional pretraining is even significantly worse than the raw input features in 11 of the 12 settings, i.e., it transfers negatively (Table 8).
Target-city training uses the labels of the target city itself and serves as an upper reference. With 5% and 20% labels, our encoder has a significantly lower population NLL; with all labels, and in POI MAE, target-city training is better, as the paper reports. Pretraining thus helps most when labels are scarce.
Limited theoretical novelty: conservation follows from known properties of integration and Dirichlet distributions.
We agree that conservation follows from known properties of integration and of the Dirichlet distribution, and we do not claim it as a new theorem. Our contribution lies in using these properties for urban representation learning, so that one representation can learn from and predict on any partition (point 1).
The revision also takes the theory one step further. We extend the Dirichlet random measure from space to space × attribute, as a marked random measure (Daley & Vere-Jones, 2003), and add a proposition in Appendix F, to which Section 3.3 now points. It shows that:
- any indicator that is a statistical functional of additive counts, such as a median, a ratio or a Gini index, can be computed on any region from the predicted counts;
- these indicators are consistent across all partitions: the counts of the subregions sum to those of the region, whose indicator is thus recovered exactly;
- predicting such an indicator region by region cannot guarantee this, because, for example, the median of a region is not determined by the medians of its parts.
This turns conservation from a property of counts into a consistency guarantee for a much broader class of urban indicators, which covers every estimate in the ACS detailed tables (see our reply to Reviewer KdXs). It also shows what a field-based model should learn: the additive measure behind an indicator, from which the indicator follows by computation.
A preliminary demonstration. We built three such indicators from fields in the ten cities, with both inputs: median household income, median home value and per capita income. The block-group values are consistent with the tract values, and with AlphaEarth input, 73–83% of the block groups fall within the published 90% margins of error of the ACS (Appendix F). These results show feasibility only.
We present the proposition as a formal extension rather than a new theory, but it substantially widens what field-based urban foundation models can learn from. We will study this direction in more depth in future work, including indices that require modeling many variables jointly or the dependence between locations.
Response to Reviewer vUaz (1/4)
We thank you for the careful review and the valuable, constructive suggestions, and for recognising the importance of the problem and the principled formulation. You raise six points:
We agree that the components are established: continuous intensity fields, integration over regions and the Dirichlet–multinomial distribution are all known tools.
Our contribution is to turn them into a representation-learning paradigm. These tools have been used for interpolation and allocation in single tasks. We make them a way to train urban foundation models and geospatial embeddings: one representation learns from statistics on any partition and serves any partition.
The key methodological choice is to read out at every location and then integrate over regions, instead of first pooling representations within a region and then reading out, as conventional urban representation learning does.
Controlled evidence. The paper isolates this choice: in the comparisons below, the data, the network architecture and the likelihood are the same, and only the readout differs.
What this enables. One representation predicts consistently on any partition, learns from data on any partition, with each dataset entering training on its own partition (Appendix C), and transfers to new cities (Table 2, Figure 3).
These methods allocate one quantity within one region, whereas our aim is a reusable representation that stays consistent across partitions (Problem 2). Disaggregation is still a direct test of whether the field formulation itself is sound, so we compared with them in the paper's setting and with the same protocol. The table below groups the nine methods by the three families you name; the random-forest dasymetric method is the one behind WorldPop.
Each entry is the reduction in MAE achieved by our field, averaged over the ten cities and the evaluation partitions; positive values favour our field. § uses GHSL layers, which are extra information in the AlphaEarth columns. † also uses NLCD land cover. ‡ also uses the totals of neighbouring tracts.
The results:
On disaggregation, the field formulation is thus on par with the strongest method, and it also serves as a representation reused across quantities, partitions and cities.
In the revision, we have added Appendix E with the results and the details of each method, a paragraph in Section 4.2 that summarizes them, and a sentence at the end of Appendix A.2 that points to them.