- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This study proposes a novel real-time Document Layout Analysis (DLA) model. The proposed model is based on the YOLOv12 architecture. One of the core contributions is replacing the base architecture's Area Attention block with Page-Axis Layout Attention (PALA). PALA performs full attention along horizontal and vertical axes rather than the block attention used in Area Attention. PALA leverages the inductive bias that document layouts exhibit strong horizontal and vertical structure. Another core contribution is a synthetic document generation method called Mesh-candidate BestFit (MBF). The study shows that synthetic document data generated by MBF improve model performance. The study conducted extensive experiments on representative DLA benchmarks and showed that the model achieved superior performance to existing real-time detectors and specialized DLA methods.
Critical strengths
- The study conducted extensive comparisons across various benchmarks and alternative methods.
- The study analyzes performance from multiple perspectives including accuracy and speed.
- The study conducted sufficient ablation studies on the proposed core components.
- Strong performance.
Critical weaknesses
Major Weaknesses
- MBF is one of the core contributions of this study. 1M synthetic pages generated by MBF contribute to improving model performance. However, I could not find any statement about releasing the MBF source code in the current manuscript. Although methodological details are described in Algorithm 1, it is strongly recommended to release the generation code for reproducibility and follow-up studies.
- YOLO-DLA [1] is a document-specific YOLO-based method and uses axial attention which seems closely related to PALA. It is worth discussing as a related method. An additional comparison would also be valuable if feasible.
- The novelty of PALA and its relationship to existing axis-aware methods should be positioned more clearly in the main text. Approaches exploiting horizontal and vertical structure already exist. The Introduction does not sufficiently explain how PALA differs from existing axis-aware methods. PALA's distinguishing features, such as parallel H/V attention, independent normalization, and full-axis interaction, should be described clearly in the Introduction or Related Work.
- DocLayNet is a widely used DLA benchmark. Although comparison results are reported in the Appendix C.1, they are limited. I recommend adding comparisons with recent DLA methods to Table 3. If such comparisons are not feasible, the reason should be explained.
- The effectiveness of synthetic data generated by MBF is evaluated only on in Table 5. It would be valuable to include another benchmark, such as PRIMA-LAD. This would provide a more complete evaluation of its generalizability.
Minor Weaknesses and Suggestions
- This study provides sufficient aggregate ablation studies on PALA's effectiveness. In addition, a sample-wise qualitative analysis showing how the horizontal and vertical branches capture structural relationships in real document samples would be beneficial for understanding the behavior of the proposed method.
- DocMY/Mamba-YOLO [2] overlaps with several benchmarks used in this study. I recommend adding quantitative comparison results to Table 3.
- Please correct the following typos:
- L824:
deault->default - L1059:
EVALUATION EVALUATION->EVALUATION
- I recommend reporting the generation speed of synthetic document generation methods, such as the number of pages generated per second.
[1] Qi, Haoyan, Xinyang Meng, and Zhijuan Du. "Yolo-dla: A yolo-based unified framework for multi-scale document layout analysis." Expert Systems with Applications (2025): 129981.
[2] Ma, Wenkang, et al. "Mamba-YOLO: Multi-level adaptive rectangular convolution for document layout analysis." Pattern Recognition 170 (2026): 112031.
Questions for authors
- Table 1 states that PRIMA-LAD contains 478 pages, 7453 elements, and 5 element types. However, the footnote in Appendix B.1 states that "11-class annotation configuration adopted in our experiments, containing 8,942 valid regions over 478 pages". Could the authors clarify this discrepancy?